“It is not clear that the PAP has the ability to come up with practical solutions to the challenges we face in the future,” said Dr Paul Tambyah, Chairman of the Singapore Democratic Party (SDP) in response to the Prime Minister’s National Day Rally 2019 speech.
In a video on the SDP Facebook page, Dr Tambyah said, that Singaporeans were hoping to hear of “bold and dynamic” proposals to address challenges in this rapidly changing world, especially geopolitical challenges, however, they were “disappointed”.
Touching on three points that Mr Lee spoke on in his speech, Dr Tambyah started with the announcements by the Prime Minister relating to early childhood education. This includes doubling he full-day preschool capacity, upgrading pre-school facilities, setting up MOE kindergartens, and
Dr Tambyah recalled a Singaporean saying: “When the government gives you a chicken wing, they take the whole chicken.” Elaborating further, the SDP Chairman said that while the enhanced subsidies are “good”, they become “less meaningful” when the cost of education materials, supplies and fees keep increasing.
“The government needs to take a holistic view of the entire education system,” asserts Dr Tambyah, adding that Singapore is one of the most unequal societies in the developed world, comparable to the US. He noted that studies by the Singapore Children’s Society and other research has shown that the majority of children in so called type 3 schools come from low income families.
Unfortunately, parents who are able end up paying around S$2,000 or more to send their children to brand name pre-schools that promise to give their children a head start in the ‘rat race’ of Singapore’s education system. Not something every one can afford.
While Dr Tambyah concedes that kindergartens by the Ministry of Education are a “step in the right direction”, his party proposes that early childhood education be nationalised, similar to primary and secondary schools now. This, he says, will give every child the ability to learn rather than obsess with standardised test and exams.
Moving on to the announcement of increased bursaries for university and polytechnic students, Dr Tambyah pointed out that this initiative doesn’t deal with “key underlying issues”, primarily that of inequality. He then mentions several studies that show how children in deprived households show lower cognitive development across all ages.
Another study he mentioned, the Household Expenditure Survey in 2014, showed that Singaporeans have spent about $1 billion a year on tuition fees. This has amplified the inequality that already exists in the country, warns the Chairman.
He adds, “if we continue to depend on standardised test to sort our children, we are going to be vulnerable to entrenched generation inequality regardless of the aid provided to the few who managed to overcome the structural obstacles places in their way.”
Moving on to a different section, PM Lee had talked about raising the retirement age, specifically the recommendations of the Tripartite Workgroup on Older Workers which included raising the retirement age from 62 to 65 and the re-employment age from 67 to 70.
While the PM seems to think that Singaporeans want to work until they are 70, Dr Tambyah notes the in reality, the average lifespan of Singaporeans is between 69-78 years old according to data from the registry of births and deaths. Dr Tambyah argued that the Prime Minister didn’t show any evidence that Singaporeans didn’t want to enjoy a hard earned retirement. Instead, Dr Tambyah pointed out, Mr Lee “insisted that we should continue working at lower overall wages at the same job until the age of 70.”
Later, Dr Tambyah mentioned a conversation he had with a former Minister of Manpower where he had asked if the minister would be comfortable being operated on by a 70 year old brain surgeon or travelling in a bus by a 70 year old bus driver”. The minister argued that those individuals could be retrained.
Dr Tambyah countered, “I know a number of neurosurgeons and bus drivers and none of them believe they will be able to learn another trade which will allow them to maintain the same standard of living well into their 60s. Most of them would prefer a reliable state-supported pension to supplement gaps in their CPF savings.”
Finally, the SDP chairman lamented that the PM’s segment on climate change was “perplexing”, noting that while the PM showed a map to illustrate the parts of Singapore that would be affected by rising sea levels, he followed that with another map showing how those very same areas would become part of a new real estate development.
Dr Tambyah noted that SDP agrees that climate change is critical issue, but they also think that Singapore should take the lead in the global battle against climate change as a small country with bright and educated individuals.
“Singapore can take steps towards a carbon light future, encourage our young people to be creative and come up with ideas and solutions which can help the whole world deal with the bigger issues of climate change,” said Dr Tambyah.
He continued, “In order for that to happen, we need freedom of information, access to government data on climate and the weather and also the freedom to engage, debate and discuss on all issues relevant to us.”
Dr Tambyah ended by saying, “Singaporeans need strong, transparent and accountable leadership. It is not clear that the PAP has the ability to come up with practical solutions to the challenges we face in the future.”
He noted that the new developments among the alternative parties is encouraging and hoped that Singaporeans will vote wisely in the coming elections.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

It is sad and unbecoming that some people have chosen to cast aspersions on Pritam Singh’s intentions, says Dr Tan Cheng Bock

Leader of the Opposition (LO) Pritam Singh from the Workers’ Party (WP)…

【武汉冠状病毒】23例!本地单日确诊创新高

根据新加坡卫生部文告,截至3月17日中午12时(17日),本地新增23起武汉冠状病毒(COVID-19)确诊病例,创下单日新高。 这使得本地累计确诊病例增至26起;今日有五人出院,累计出院114人,不过仍有14人需待在加护病房。 今日新增确诊病例有17例都属入境病例,其中两起与早前病例有关联。但也有其中四例感染源头不明。 一些病患到过欧洲各国 第244例是53岁男公民,与早前的36岁男公民有关联,他们上月26至29日曾在德国、29至本月7日在意大利、本月7至14日到过瑞士。 7日人在意大利时,他就已出现症状,返国后15日就被送到鹰阁医院,昨日中午确诊。在入院前他曾前往河谷路(River Valley Road)的住家式办公处,住在亚历山大路一带。 76岁确诊病患在滨海盛景西座上班 第245例是76岁男公民,近期未到过境外感染重灾区,12日出现症状,15日就被送到中央医院。入院前曾前往滨海盛景西座(Marina One West Tower)上班,住在文礼通道(Boon…

ST Forum Letter – A Case of Too Much Editing?

A few days ago, TOC received an email from a member of…

【武汉冠状病毒】本地新增三起确诊病例 与此前两教会感染群有关

截至本月19日中午12时,本地新增三起武汉冠状病毒确诊病例,使之累计确诊病例84起。另一方面,再有五名病患出院,包括本地首宗病例。 其中两起新增确诊病例与神召会恩典堂有关;另一人与基督生命堂有关。 第82起病例是57岁的女公民,近期未到过中国。她在本月9日出现症状,并在10日、12日和14日求医。13日和15日前往黄廷芳医院,并于18日中午确诊。 为预防起见,与上述女子同处普通病房的病患,已转移到单人间,目前正进行测试并等待结果,惟他们都未出现呼吸道症状。至于黄廷芳医院的医护人员则追踪曾与确诊病患接触的人士,有关病房也已经消毒。 第83起病例则是54岁男公民,近期未到过中国,不过常到马国出差。他在今早确诊。第84起病例,则是35岁女公民,也是在今早确诊,她与第66例(28岁男公民,在神召会恩典堂工作)有关联。 其余和第66例有关联的,还包括第68(79岁女公民)和第70例(27岁女公民)(家属)、第80例(38岁女公民),以及曾与他接触的第71位病患。 累计34病患出院 迄今,已累计34位病患出院,目前仍在治疗中的病患大多情况稳定,且有好转,仍有四位病患处在加护病房。 今日则共有五位病患出院,包括本地首例病患、第32、33、44、第55例。 本地首例病患子来自武汉,66岁,是在上月20日晚10时40分,乘坐中国南方航空CZ351航班抵达我国樟宜机场。 他当时曾喉咙疼痛,但没有发烧。 隔日才出现发烧和咳嗽症状,立即到中央医院急诊部求医,院方也马上实施隔离,将他列为疑似病例。…