The son of billionaire Sam Goi, Ben Goi, 43, died on Sunday (3 Feb) and a number of People’s Action Party current as well as former ministers were reportedly seen at the wake consoling Sam Goi.

Some of the present ministers who went to the wake included Heng Swee Keat, Vivian Balakrishnan, Masagos Zulkifli and Josephine Teo.

The relationship of Sam Goi and PAP is a close one. Sam Goi is one of the important grassroots leaders at Ulu Pandan, under the Holland-Bukit Timah GRC, which is helmed by Vivian Balakrishnan.

Mah Bow Tan continues to hold shares in Sam Goi’s company GSH Corp

Some PAP ministers and MPs, after their retirements from politics, would go on to invest in Sam Goi’s companies.

One example is former National Development Minister Mah Bow Tan. He stepped down from the Cabinet after 2011 GE but continued as part-time MP until 2015.

After 2011 when Mah was no longer a member of the government, he invested in GSH Corp, essentially a property company. Sometime between Mar 2012 and Mar 2013, records shows that Sam Goi substantially increased his shareholdings in GSH from 15% to 46.5%, making him the largest shareholder. Simultaneously, Mah also entered into the fray and became the 6th largest shareholder with 165 million shares (3.3%).

A financial article in 2014 explained that it was in 2012 when Sam Goi was appointed the new chairman of GSH that the company set off to go into property business and ditched its original IT distribution business. Around the same time, Mah also went in to invest in GSH.

By Mar 2014 the second year, Mah increased his stake in GSH to become the 5th largest shareholder. At the time, he owned 365,575,000 shares (3.7%) with a market value of about S$28 million.

He then started selling his shares for the next couple of years. The latest company annual report (as at Mar 2018) shows that Mah now owns 24 million shares (1.2%).

Last month (10 Jan), Sam Goi acquired more GSH shares, increasing his stake from 50.01% to 51.16%. He has been gradually increasing his stake in the property company from 47.32% since the end of 2014.

GSH Corporation is a property developer in South-east Asia, with four properties under development in Kuala Lumpur and Kota Kinabalu. It also owns the Sutera Harbour Resort in Kota Kinabalu, comprising two five-star hotels – the Pacific Sutera and Magellan Sutera Resort, a 104-berth marina and 27-hole championship golf course.

Mah Bow Tan says value of HDB flats would grow over time

Mah’s investments into property companies may not necessarily show that he is familiar with the mechanics of property business.

Before Mah stepped down from his National Development post in 2011, he once attacked Workers’ Party’s proposal to lower the price of new HDB flats. Then WP Secretary-General Low Thia Khiang had called for the pricing of land to be lowered for HDB flats, saying it is a matter of internal transfers within the government.

Mah replied that the WP’s proposal will devalue existing flats as home buyers turn to new flats rather than resale flats. He also criticised that WP’s proposal to lower land costs would amount to an illegal raid on Singapore’s reserves. He said that state land forms part of the reserves. When the government takes state land for public housing, it has to pay the full value of the land back into the reserves. But of course, he forgot to mention that this full value of the land is being passed on to Singaporeans buying the HDB flats.

In fact, just before 2011 GE, Mah even said, “We’re proud of the asset enhancement policy. (It) has given almost all Singaporeans a home of their own… that grows in value over time.”

In any case, this turned out to be false. In 2017, the present National Development Minister Lawrence Wong made a public statement saying that only 4% of HDB flats were redeveloped through Sers since 1995. That is, these old flats, typically at very good locations, were bought back by HDB and the flat owners were compensated accordingly.

But the vast majority of flats, Wong warned, will be returned to HDB when their 99-year lease run out without any compensation. “As the leases run down, especially towards the tail-end, the flat prices will come down correspondingly,” he said. “So buyers need to do their due diligence and be realistic when buying flats with short leases.”

Hence, Wong’s clarification contradicted Mah’s exuberance with regard to HDB’s value growing over time. They do not and their value would hit zero when the leases end. Mah appears not to have understood the meaning of leasehold in property when he was the National Development Minister.

Who is Chandra Das Nareshkumar?

In the latest top 20 shareholders of Sam Goi’s company GSH (as at Mar 2018), listed at rank 17th was a person by the name of Chandra Das Nareshkumar who owned 6 million shares.

It’s unclear if Chandra Das Nareshkumar is linked to Chandra Das S/O Rajagopal Sitaram, who is a former PAP MP from 1980 to 1996 as well as the Chairman of the Trade Development Board from 1983 to 1986 and Chairman of NTUC Fairprice from 1993 to 2005.

According to the Bloomberg, both Chandra Das S/O Rajagopal Sitaram and Sam Goi sit on the same board of F&B company Super Group Ltd. Sam Goi is the Vice Chairman while Chandra Das S/O Rajagopal Sitaram is the non-executive director of Super Group.

And of course, Chandra Das S/O Rajagopal Sitaram himself was the Chairman and Director of Action Information Management (AIM), the $2 company which had the PAP headquarters in New Upper Changi Road registered as its address. The company came into prominence after it was revealed in public that the company had bought over the public funded town council management software just before PAP handed the Aljunied TC to WP in 2011.

AIM Saga

At the time, WP asked how public interest was served when the PAP town councils sold a computerized town council management system to AIM.

Then, WP MP Sylvia Lim said, “It is regrettable that both Dr Teo’s and Mr Das’ statements have been calculated to side-step the most critical question of how the public interest was served when the PAP-managed Town Councils, which developed the computing and financial systems at significant cost and co-owned them, sold them off to a third party which could exercise rights of termination if there was a ‘material change’ in the composition of a town council.”

“What justification was there for the Town Councils to relinquish ownership and leave the continuity of Town Council operations at the mercy of a third party? Residents all over Singapore have a right to know.”

“In other words, the PAP-managed Town Councils saw it fit to sell away their ownership of the systems, developed with public funds, to a political party (PAP), which presumably could act in its own interests when exercising its rights to terminate the contracts,” she added.

“If anything, this episode clearly demonstrates the risks to Singaporeans of having a lack of alternatives in every sense.”

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

TOC dismayed by apparent reversal of 'light touch' approach to internet regulation

~Editorial~ February 2012 will be remembered as the month in which defamation…

社会关怀计划 去年逾亿元助7万9500人

社会与家庭发展部的社会关怀计划(ComCare),在去年发出的援助总额达到1亿3100万元,使7万9500人受惠。 该部在昨日发文告,发表社区关怀计划2017财政年报告和2013-2017年社会关怀计划进展报告。 社区关怀计划分为:短期援助(SMTA)、长期援助(LTA)、学术托管费援助\、临时补助(Comcare Interim Assistance)和社区补助。 中短期援助,旨在协助低收入家庭或个人,例如因疾病等因素而临时无法工作者、或收入低而需要辅助。 在2017财政年,有2万7986家庭,以及6万4191个人获得中短期援助,总值8千529万元。他们可获得针对不同开销的补助,例如生活开销、租金、水电费、医药费和就业补助。 在长期援助计划下,则有4千409家庭,以及4千675个人受惠,总拨款达2千352万元。长期援助主要针对年迈、疾病或伤残、收入/无收入、无家庭依靠的人士。其中79巴仙为年长者。 他们获得的援助可分为日常生活开销、保健储蓄补助和其他必需品的额外援助。 补助低收入家庭孩童上托管中心 在学生托管费援助下,去年则有8千413家庭和1万331名孩童受惠,拨款达2千045万元。有关补助针对年龄7至14岁的低收入家庭孩童,提供每月补助,在他们父母上班时,上学生托管中心(SCCs)。 至于社会关怀临时补助,在去年共援助了7千090人。由社会服务中心(SSO)、公民咨询委员会、家庭服务中心和社区正义中心等单位评估,需要紧急财务援助的家庭和个体。…

Of penguins, swans and families – NLB’s misplaced concerns

By Howard Lee Jillian, 11, would be the typical girl that the…

林学芬手工拼花被子拍卖 所得捐弱势群体培训中心装修经费

前总理李光耀二媳妇、李显扬妻子林学芬,除了是名律师,也擅长手工拼花创作。她的其中一幅手织作品“绽放的端庄(DIGNITY BLOOMS)”,将在下月进行网上慈善拍卖,价高者得。 拍卖所得将作为新加坡社会企业“厨尊”(Dignity Kitchen),旗下一座新设立培训中心的装修经费。厨尊于2010年成立,是新加坡首个结合美食的社会企业,旨在为弱势群体、障友提供培训,让他们也能参与餐饮服务,有尊严地自力更生。 据厨尊在众筹平台Give Asia的介绍,由于疫情冲击,有更多弱势群体在找工作,使得为这些人士提供培训的需求倍增。 新中心位于文庆路69号。从民众募捐、拍卖所得,都将用在装修和添购中心的雪柜、培训课室、厨房器材等等。 据厨尊描述,“Dignity Bloom”是林学芬在阻断措施期间的创作,欲向人们传达不同正能量,其被子以大片渐层蓝色为主色,其他颜色如绿色、紫红色为辅呈现,丰富的蓝色调包括海军蓝、钴蓝和宝蓝色。而蓝色代表诚实和可信。 “这些颜色跳脱以往郁郁葱葱的花朵的设计,如果你仔细观察,可以发现有一只鸟、一只蝴蝶、一直瓢虫和一只蜜蜂藏在花瓣中。” 此外,该被子也将有长与宽均为106cm,据厨尊表示,将可以成为赏心悦目的壁挂。 “Dignity…