nsmen22e_0Two Indonesian citizens who are Permanent Residents in Singapore are currently under investigation after it was discovered that they had participated in a joint military exercise earlier this month in Magelang, Central Java.
The Jakarta Post also reported that they have been “deported” to Singapore following the incident.
The discovery posed an issue as under Indonesian law, it is an offence for citizens to serve with a foreign military, at the risk of losing their citizenship.
However, Indonesian law does take into consideration Indonesians in countries that adopt mandatory national service, such as Singapore.
Under Singapore’s Enlistment Act, all male PRs are liable for National Service (NS) when they reach 16 ½ years of age, and have to register for NS. This includes those whose Singapore citizenship is a second citizenship and to male children who are granted PR status under their parents’ sponsorship.
“Going forward, Singapore will not send Indonesians to a joint exercise here. We have asked them that, and they are agreeable,” Major-General Fuad Basya, spokesperson for the Indonesian Armed Forces (TNI), told The Straits Times.
The issue, however, is not new.
In 2008, then Foreign Minister of Indonesia Hassan Wirajuda has asked Singapore to exempt Indonesian citizens who are PRs from NS, citing the same law that affects their citizenship.
In 1999, then Indonesian President B J Habibie had apparently called for the citizenship of Indonesians living in Singapore who served NS be revoked, as the country does not recognise dual citizenship.
Earlier this year, Singapore announced the formation of the SAF Volunteer Corps (SAFVC).
The SAFVC was first proposed by the Committee to Strengthen National Service (CSNS) to “enable women, first generation Permanent Residents and new citizens to contribute to national defence and strengthen support for NS (National Service).”
It is not clear if such issues with citizenship in the home countries of PRs and foreigners might affect the SAFVC.

Subscribe
Notify of
110 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Tharman praises France for supporting its youth in developing football talents while MINDEF rejects SG youth in NS deferment

DPM Tharman Shanmugaratnam congratulated France on his Facebook page today (16 Jul)…

Ministry of Defence acknowledges seized armored vehicles in Hong Kong belong to SAF

Ministry of Defence (MINDEF) has announced that the shipment of Terrex Infantry…

年迈小贩因伤休业一周被罚款3500元 富食客辩称曾给机会免罚款

早前,一名小贩女儿向媒体申诉,自己年迈父亲在职总富食客管理的机场食阁开档营生,因受伤而找不到替代员工,想休息数日,却被管理层罚款3千500元。 有关不愿具名的小贩女儿是在日前,向英文时事网站《独立》媒体爆料。小贩的父亲在富食客管理的樟宜机场第四航空楼食客开档,担任主厨。今年六月,由于父亲在工作时受伤,由于伤势严重,被迫休息一周。 女儿解释,由于不能聘请客工,越来越少国人和永久居民肯在食阁摊位工作,父亲一直面对人手不足问题。父亲甚至要轮早晚班连做,才不会被富食客管理层罚款。 “由于父亲伤势较严重,我们被迫休业一周。我致函职总富食客解释父亲的状况,指出我们一时找不到头手来顶替父亲,希望对方能通融。然而,富食客不接受我们的解释,却开出3500元的罚款。” 女儿也向媒体揭示与富食客的电邮往来截图,也附上医生开出的病假单和父亲骨折的X光扫描图: 然而, 女儿收到富食客零售部助理运营经理Aaron Chia,在回绝对方取消罚款的请求时说: “请注意,作为摊位管理者,若员工因无法预知状况无法工作、又没人能顶替经营摊位,我们不能纳入考量。更重要的是,摊位不应只有一个人来经营。” 女儿对于对方的答复表达失望,也很遗憾这个声称是非营利的官联餐饮机构,无法弹性处理和罔顾旗下摊贩的健康。   富食客:曾献议休业一周后三天内开档,可免罚款…