Connect with us

Government

Factually or half truths to sidestep actual salaries by PM and ministers? Why the lack of transparency?

Published

on

In a post published on the Factually website, the Singapore government seeks to address two “falsehoods”, one being the Prime Minister gets $4.5 million in annual salary and it is not upfront about how ministerial salaries are calculated.

The post on Factually is correct on both counts to say that the government is upfront with how the ministerial salaries are calculated and that the Prime Minister is not paid $2.2 million as base salary.

In the two review reports (2012 and 2017) on ministerial salaries, the Singapore Government clearly states the amount of salary the Prime Minister and the political appointment holders get annually and how the figures are derived.

As for the PM’s pay, the $2.2 million is a total of 12+7 months of bonuses, (12 months salary, 13th-months bonus, AVC and a six-month national bonus instead of three months as the PM does not get a performance bonus), which works out to be $110,000 per month or $1.43 million a year for his basic annual salary. So it is also right to say that PM Lee doesn’t get $4.5 million a year.

But what the post does not address or trying to sidestep with its half-truths, is the reluctance by the Government or the Prime Minister to reveal the total amount of bonuses received by the ministers.

Non-constituency Member of Parliament, Leon Perera had asked Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong in a written question in September’s Parliamentary sitting:

To ask the Prime Minister in each of the past five years, what has been the bonus paid to Cabinet Ministers in terms of (i) the average total number of bonus months (ii) the highest total number of bonus months paid to an individual Minister and (iii) the lowest total number of bonus months paid to an individual Minister.

In PM Lee’s reply to the NCMP, he merely revealed the average performance bonus received by the political appointment holders over the past five years. Noting that the bonuses are computed with the four components, PM Lee failed to reveal the amount of National Bonuses received by the political appointment holders which then can be used to calculate the total number of bonuses for the past five years.

So to find out the total annual bonuses that the PM and other political appointment holders get, TOC calculated the national bonus based on the KPIs set to determine the bonus months to be paid out.

Based on the calculated figures, we see that the political holders get at least 10 months of bonus on top of their annual salary for the past five years. And note that the Performance bonus is an average so some may get more. 

As for the Prime Minister, as he is not paid performance bonus but instead given a maximum of 12 months instead of 6 months of National bonus, this means he would get 13 months of bonus in 2017 instead of 11.85 months like the other ministers and political appointment holders.

Which translate to PM Lee getting about 2.75 million in 2017 (25 months) and 2.83 million in 2013 (25.75). (Note that the basic pay has increased due to adjustment with the top 1000 earners)

But as much as the PM may be reluctant to share who is being paid the highest amount of bonus, we ought to have complete transparency in the matter and full disclosure, as salaries of the Cabinet are being borne out of public monies.

Continue Reading
1 Comment
Subscribe
Notify of
1 Comment
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Government

PSD announces mid-year bonuses of 0.3 months and one-time payment of up to S$400 for civil servants in Singapore

Singapore’s civil servants will receive mid-year bonuses, with a 0.3-month Annual Variable Component (AVC) and junior grade officers to get an additional one-time payment of up to S$400.

The Public Service Division (PSD) said the decision “takes into consideration the weakened economic outlook, and significant downside risks that remain in the global economy.”

Published

on

SINGAPORE — The Public Service Division (PSD) revealed on Monday (19 June) its decision to grant mid-year bonuses to civil servants in Singapore.

The government has allocated a mid-year Annual Variable Component (AVC) of 0.3 months for all civil servants. Additionally, junior grade officers will receive an extra one-time payment of up to S$400 (US$298).

The specific amount of the one-time payment depends on the civil servants’ respective job grades.

Civil servants in grades equivalent to MX13(I) and MX14 will receive an additional S$200, while those in grades equivalent to MX15 and MX16, along with those in the Operations Support Scheme (OSS) Grades III and IV, will receive a higher one-time payment of S$400.

PSD said the move comes after close consultations with public sector unions.

“This mid-year payment takes into consideration the weakened economic outlook, and significant downside risks that remain in the global economy.”

According to the PSD’s statement on Monday, Singapore’s economy experienced a modest growth rate of 0.4 percent year-on-year in the first quarter of 2023. This expansion represents a slowdown from the 2.1 percent growth observed in the previous quarter.

The Ministry of Trade and Industry has maintained its GDP growth forecast for 2023, estimating a range of “0.5 percent to 2.5 percent.” The government expects growth to settle around the mid-point of this forecast range.

However, there are concerns about the weakened external demand outlook and increased downside risks, including the potential impact of tighter global financial conditions and geopolitical tensions.

“The labour market continued to expand in the first quarter of 2023, albeit at a more moderated pace compared to the previous quarter.”

Total employment expanded for the sixth consecutive quarter, and unemployment rates remained low.

Given this backdrop, the government, in close consultation with public sector unions, has decided to provide all civil servants with a mid-year AVC of 0.3 months.

“In deciding the year-end AVC payments, the Government will continue to monitor the economic situation closely, and take into consideration the guidelines by the National Wages Council which will be released later in the year,” stated the PSD.

Continue Reading

Government

After transport minister’s spot-check at LRT, Malaysia’s health minister too conducts a spot-check at Klang Hospital

Published

on

SELANGOR, MALAYSIA —  Malaysia civil servants now may need to have a stronger heart as well as being constantly alert, as some of their ministers might just decide to conduct spot checks at their workplace anytime to check their performance.

After the newly appointed Transport Minister Anthony Loke went incognito on LRT system for a spot-check, netizens also spotted Health Minister Dr Zaliha Mustafa making an unofficial visit to Hospital Tengku Ampuan Rahimah(HTAR) in Klang on 28 December night.

Twitter user Ianiske shared a photo, showing that the minister did make a visit to the hospital, and spoke with some patients there to understand the issues on the ground regarding the public health services.

“Ok, I have checked, ” Ianiske wrote, “the health minister was at Tengku Ampuan Rahimah Hospital last night. HAHA.”

“Who would even notice her when she came by like a patient? No wonder she seems like asking people around. No one even realizes that she is the health minister.”

https://twitter.com/ansaleya/status/1608284539729678336

In the subsequent post, Ianiske also suggested that the minister should visit the hospital during peak hours, “Please.. just like my parents often refer to the government hospital. This govt issue has many critical issues.”

The Twitter user added that there are also other problems such as long patient waiting time and parking issue at hospital, hoping that the new Health Minister will look into these issues.

Zaliha: I wish to hear feedback from patients

On Thursday (29 Dec), Dr. Zaliha Mustafa confirmed that she had gone down to monitor the situation at the emergency department of HTAR hospital.

“I wish to hear feedback from patients about the services at HTAR, including the issue of long waiting times in the emergency department. ”

She said during the spot-check, she also heard suggestions from the emergency department workers to improve health services. They also expressed their concern for the issues raised.

“I will also strengthen the initiatives that are already implemented by HTAR before, and will see if they can be used in other emergency departments.”

She added that among the HTAR initiatives include arrangement for a short stay ward for stable patients who are expected to return after two or three days, and manage sick bed usage via digital technology and communication between hospital and public health clinic.

Dr Zaliha also promised to bring back all feedback that she received to the health ministry meeting to further improve the patient waiting time at the hospital’s emergency department.

Continue Reading

Trending