Dover Forest a.k.a Ulu Pandan Estate (Source: Environmental baseline study for Dover / Ulu Pandan for HDB by AECOM)

After several weeks of public outcry about the reclassification of the Clementi Forest for redevelopment, the Dover Forest has now come under the spotlight as well, sparking more calls for conservation.

While the government said recently that it has no immediate plans to redevelop the Clement Forest, it appears that the Dover forest, earmarked for residential use, may be developed into new flats in the next few years.

On 15 January, the Nature Society Singapore (NSS) made public its feedback to the Dover Forest-Ulu Pandan Baseline Study prepared by infrastructure firm AECOM for the Housing Development Board (HDB) which was released in November 2020.

The 13-page report proposes that the area be designated a public/nature park instead—based on the information reported in the HDB study as well as the NSS’s cumulative data on birdlife in since 2007.

According to the HDB study, the Dover forest is home to over 200 species of wildlife including threatened and endangered species. In fact, the NSS feedback notes that there are more threatened species in that 33-hectare patch of lush greenery than the study found back in 2017, for a total of 103 species of birds. This includes about 12 nationally near-threatened or threatened according to the Singapore Red Data Book and at least two vulnerable species listed on the ICUN Red List.

While the HDB study identified 22 species of resident and migratory birds that are dependent on the forest, NSS says 9 more were not listed in HDB’s study.

NSS noted, “This will make a combined total of 31 forest/woodland dependent species, which comes to about 30 percent—about a third—of the combined total, which is of very high conservation significance.”

Apart from serving as a wildlife habitat, the Dover forest is also an important part of wildlife connectivity in the region, said the NSS, as animals use the forest as a sort of “stepping stone” to numerous other green spaces such as the rea east of Pandan Reservoir, Bukit Timah Nature Reserve, Clementi forest and forests of the Southern Ridges.

The  non-profit organisation then suggested that the entirety of Dover forest be conserved as a public-cum-nature park.

“Such a substantial park (about 33 hectares in total, with an estimated 10 hectares for a public park section) set up in tandem with its natural assets is rather imperative for the well-being of all in this very dense and busy sector of Singapore, surrounded by schools and colleges, private housings and HDB flats as well the buzzing One-north Biotech Hub and Media complexes and offices.”

The organisation also highlighted the growing demand for more green spaces by the public, as evidenced by a rise in the number of visitors at the Central Catchment Nature Reserve’s Tree-Top Trail as well as the “simply astounding” number of people flocking to the Clementi Forest in recent times.

As an alternative, the NSS went on to suggest that the new HDB estate be developed in other areas that are “brownfield sites”—which are previously developed land not currently in use—or cleared and open areas instead of cutting down existing secondary forest that are rich in wildlife.

Some proposed sites were the roughly 3.5 hectare open patch at the junction of Ghim Moh Road and Commonwealth Avenue West, the already degazetted Warren Golf Course (also about 3.5 hectares) or the open patch at the junction of Dover Road and North Buona Vista Road which is approximately 14.5 hectares.

Netizens on the Straits Times and Mothership Facebook pages have become quite vocal about this planned redevelopment of Dover forest, reiterating the importance of having more green spaces in Singapore for the wellbeing of residents and wildlife as well as to mitigate climate change.

On that note, several people pointed out the “hypocrisy” of the government encouraging people to live a greener life and plant more trees while cutting down forests for the sake or development.

Some also support the suggest by NSS for HDB to redevelopment brownsites or other urban areas instead. A couple of people suggested building up instead of out as well.

On top of that, there were also questions on why the HDB keeps building new flats.

Despite the government’s assurances during GE2020 that it has no plans or targets for a 10 million population, many netizens are concerned that the government’s push to create more housing despite the already high supply for HDB flats and consistently low Total Fertility Rates (TFR) is a sign that the government is actually going ahead with those plans.

Others suggested that the government is more focused on money, with climate change and conservation taking a back seat.

Even so, there were several netizens who supported the plan to redevelop Dover forest into new HDB flats, noting that it is necessary in order to keep property prices.

 

Subscribe
Notify of
12 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Dr Chee Soon Juan: Multi-party system must replace one-party rule for Singapore's future survival

Dr Chee Soon Juan, the Secretary-General of Singapore Democratic Party (SDP), commented on…

明起电动滑板车不准在人行道使用!

明日起电动滑板车被禁止在所有人行道使用! 相信是基于涉及电动滑板车的事故频繁,交通部兼卫生部高级政务部长蓝彬明医生,今日在国会作出如是宣布。 他指出尽管过去两年当局已积极推广个人代步工具的安全使用,惟仍有鲁莽使用者,涉及电动滑板车的事故仍持续攀升,包括在今年9月21日发生的电电动滑板车与脚车相撞事故,导致一名65岁妇女丧命。 迄今为止,和当局注册的电动滑板车约有10万辆。蓝彬明在回应议员提问时透露,每个月平均有370名违例者,甚至还发生严重或致命事故。 不过陆路交通管理局将给予两个月宽限期,先给那些违例在人行道使用电动滑板车的民众发出警告;从明年1月1日起,违例者一旦罪成,可被罚款最多2000元或坐牢三个月,或两者兼施。 不过,脚车和电动轮椅等代步工具(Personal Mobility Aids),仍可在人行道、脚车道和公园连道使用。 此外,蓝彬明也表示目前也不会对共享电动滑板车服务发出执照。 此前,交通部高级政务部长普杰立医生在接受CNA938采访时,曾表示个人代步工具是很有用的交通工具,政府没打算因为少数不负责任的骑士,而直接打击。 随着个人代步工具普及化,相关设备的意外事故也随着增加。 陈笃生医院在上月21日公布一项数据,比起2017年,今年有高达68巴仙的个人代步工具相关意外发生。在2017年1月至2019年9月,院内共接获213个人代步工具相关意外被送入院治疗,其中有6宗是死亡案例。另外,院内也接获6宗遭个人代步工具而受伤的通报。…

疫情、马国政局波动影响 多项大型交通项目未有定数

近日,由于受到武汉冠状病毒疫情与马国政局影响,我国许多重要的大型交通项目被迫暂停。原本在今年4月底会有所定夺的新柔地铁项目,如今也仍未有定数;多个大型交通项目包括樟宜机场第五搭客大厦的落成时间可能将受影响。 针对新柔地铁项目,基础建设统筹部长兼交通部长许文远今日(5日)在国会拨款委员会辩论交通部开支预算时表示,近期由于受到马国政坛动荡影响,因此新柔地铁项目仍未有定数,尽管我国致力于与马国合作,找出相对的解决方案,但不能无限期暂停。 新马两国须在今年4月30日前签订经修改的新柔地铁双边协定,以及SMRT企业与马来西亚国家基础建设公司关于成立合资公司的协定,和特许经营协定。 他续指,尽管仍有其他替补方案能够解决长堤阻塞的问题,如扩大关卡设施,或分布长堤与第二通道的流量,但新柔地铁仍是较适合的方案,能够明显看出成效。 马来西亚前交通部长陆兆福也曾指出,马国新任部长在上任后必须迫切处理新柔地铁系统(RTS)协议的课题,以便能在今年4月作出决定,让项目有所进展。 多项大型交通项目因供应链受影响,而可能延缓落成时间 除了新柔地铁项目仍未有定数,冠状病毒的疫情也打乱了许多大型项目的落成时间。许文远表示,武汉冠状病毒仍在全球肆虐,随着中国封城,全球供应链包括许多建筑设备和材料的供应均受影响。 因此,我国多个大型交通项目包括樟宜机场第五搭客大厦、大士港口、新地铁站及新一代公路电子收费系统的落成时间恐受影响。 “我们还在看这对我们的交通基础设施项目的影响。到目前为止,项目时间表的延迟还算可以应付。但若疫情持续,可能影响建筑设备和材料的供应。例如我们的新列车是在中国制造的。” 另一方面,许文远也指出交通运输业的影响甚大,首当其冲是樟宜机场。航空公司目前已取消超过20巴仙的航班,其乘客量也下跌了25巴仙,估计还会再进一步减少。游轮和渡轮生意也均受影响。 随着疫情蔓延,本地许多企业更愿意远程办公,随之受影响的就是本地交通运输如巴士和德士等。

AG and PM Lee’s statements on 377a; Should we trust Ministers’ word in Parliament?

I refer to the article “Government has not curbed public prosecutor’s discretion…