Ng Teng Fong General Hospital (Image by ZDL / Shutterstock.com)

A member of the public raised her concern over the lack of air-conditioning in subsidised wards in a letter published by the Straits Times on 3 June.

The letter written by Lily Ong noted that patients in Class C wards are left to the mercy of the sweltering heat that is blanketing Singapore as those wards are not air-conditioned.

Noting that many of the patients in Class C wards are elderly, the author suggested that such wards be equipped with air-conditioning unit, arguing that it is a basic necessity in a country as hot and humid as Singapore and in the wake of global warming.

Ms Ong also raised concerns of health complications that would result from patients lying next to open windows in the hospital considering that the Singapore Institute of International Affairs has projected the return of severe haze in Singapore this year.

MOH reply: Going green and keep costs low

In a reply which was published by ST (8 June), the Ministry of Health Director of Infrastructure Planning & Policy Division Low Chian Siong said that ‘patients who prefer air-conditioned accommodation may opt for A or B1 ward types’.

Mr Low elaborated that public hospitals in Singapore provide “safe, affordable and effective care to patients” and in order “to keep subsidised wards affordable for patients, they are designed to cater to essential patient needs.”

Mr Low also highlighted that improvements have been made to the design and infrastructure in subsidised wards of newer public hospitals, noting that these hospitals meet the Building Construction Authority’s Green Mark Platinum certification which “requires naturally ventilated spaces, including subsidised wards, to meet thermal comfort requirement such as air temperature, air movement and humidity.”

As for older hospitals, mitigating measures have been taken such as spot cooling to bring down ambient temperature, he says.

Addressing concerns on the impending haze, Mr Low said that all public hospitals will take additional measures when necessary.

Is denying air-conditioning to subsidised wards a form of classicism?

The thing is, hospitals in Singapore boast beautiful design elements from articulated facades (Sengkang General Hospital) to lush rooftop gardens filled with verdant greenery (Singapore General Hospital). Clearly, no expense was spared in creating a beautiful, well-equipped healthcare infrastructure.

But imagine just for a moment how much it would cost to maintain those gardens? How much would it have cost to create a beautiful outer façade and include balconies in rooms? And yet, there seems ot be a need to skimp on additional cost of installing and running air-conditioning for Class C wards?

Chance are the cost for landscaping and maintenance for Jurong Hospital, for example, would be more than the cost required to air-condition Class C wards. We’re talking about hospitals here. Comfort should be prioritised over aesthetics.

The reply from MOH on the lack of air-conditioning clearly noted that the reason subsidised wards don’t get air-conditioning was due to budget concerns and wanting to keep costs low. If that’s the case, they should be consistent.

On top of that, given that Singapore is already capable of generating much more electricity that it needs, thus lowering costs, it really wouldn’t burden hospitals much at all to provide air-conditioning to all wards.

Even so, let’s say MOH is motivated by the goal of being environmentally friendly and wanting to meet the mark for the Building Construction Authority’s Green Mark Platinum certification. If that’s the case, then shouldn’t they scrap air-conditioning from all wards completely and not just Class C?

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

SCDF issues warning to Jurong-Clementi Town Council for malfunctioning hosereels that were discovered after fire

Jurong-Clementi Town Council (JCTC) has been issued with a warning by the…

21 new cases of COVID-19 infection in S’pore; all cases are imported

As of Thursday noon (8 Apr), the Ministry of Health (MOH) has…

骗订金被揭发 男子假冒建屋局承包商面控

涉嫌假扮建屋发展局承包商,到组屋向居民骗取装修订金的男子,今日(3日)被控上庭。 据警方文告指出,他们在去年3月至今年3月,13个月期间接到多起有关该一名男子假冒建屋局承包商,骗居民组屋要进行维修,因此向他们收取100元到300元不等的订金。 文告指出,调查显示,嫌犯并没有受到建屋局委托进行工程,至今已经有超过19人被骗。 勿洛警署警员是在4月1日确认了56岁嫌犯身份后,展开逮捕行动。一旦嫌犯的欺诈罪成,将可面对长达10年的监禁以及罚款。 不甘被阻,打人吐口水 此前,有网民也分享了有关嫌犯干案经过,识破和阻拦嫌犯进行欺诈,被嫌犯吐口水的经过。 72岁的网民罗锺柏(Low Chong Bak译音)于3月23日下午,在其脸书贴文指,看到一名中年男子上门,表示“在建屋局批准下”,会在隔天和团队上门维修天花板。 机灵的网民当时就询问嫌犯,“代表什么机构来的”,对方不答,但是晃了晃胸前的名牌。但是网民表示因为对方一直摇晃名牌,导致他根本看不清楚名牌上写些什么。 有关的事件发生在大巴窑。 网民当时拒绝了嫌犯的提议后,就见转而敲响邻居的门,还和邻居聊了约15分钟。这名76岁的邻居质疑嫌犯,因此询问网民嫌犯所言是否属实。…

Two persons arrested for pickpocketing in Lucky Plaza

The Singapore Police Force (SPF) announced that they had arrested a 36-year-old…