Last Wed (16 Jan), a member of the public, Albert Tang, wrote to ST Forum asking why SP Group didn’t offer the heavily discounted electricity rates, which many of the electricity retailers are currently offering to the public, in the first place.

“Given that electricity retailers are looking to make a profit, have spent a significant amount on marketing costs and are still able to offer consumers electricity rates that are a good 20 to 30 per cent lower than SP Group’s, why doesn’t SP Group just offer consumers these lower rates in the first place?” he asked.

Indeed, according to moneysmart.sg, one can get a fixed discount of as much as 25% off the regulated tariff from SP Group for floating rates. For fixed price plans, it can be even higher at 30% discount.

Mr Tang continued, “Many of the 13 or so retailers participating in the OEM do not generate their own power, instead claiming to buy in bulk from power plants to sell to consumers. As the largest bulk buyer of electricity, SP Group should benefit the most from economies of scale, and be able to pass the savings on to consumers.”

“It is hard to understand the logic behind creating the OEM and getting so many retailers to compete for consumers, when SP Group is in a position to bypass this step to sell electricity directly to consumers at more competitive rates,” he added.

Indeed, many netizens are also wondering if SP Group has overcharged the public all this while.

EMA: Current lower prices offered by retailers due to electricity production capacity exceeds demand

In response to Mr Tang’s letter, Ms Dorcas Tan, Director of Market Development and Surveillance Department of the Energy Market Authority (EMA), replied on ST Forum today (‘Why electricity retailers’ rates are better‘,23 Jan).

She said that the regulated tariff, charged by SP Group and approved by EMA, reflects the “long-term costs of producing and delivering electricity in Singapore”.

Such long-term costs include the costs of building and operating the power plants and maintaining the power grid, she added.

“On the other hand, the electricity rates offered by retailers typically reflect the current market conditions, level of competition and short-term costs of producing electricity,” she said.

“Under current market conditions where electricity production capacity exceeds demand for electricity, we can expect market prices to be lower than the regulated tariff. However, this may change over time based on market demand and supply.”

That is to say, the current low prices offered by the electricity retailers are due to over-capacity supplied from SP Group.

But she cautioned that retailers, like all businesses, may adjust their prices and discounts over time.

So, the question remains, if SP Group — which is owned by Temasek — has been over-generating electricity all these while, why didn’t it lower the electricity tariff for Singaporeans in the first place, instead of allowing them to suffer with the high cost of living in Singapore for the last many years?

Indeed, according to blogger Philip Ang after he combed through every SP Group’s annual report since 2005, he has discovered that SP Group has been making an average of almost S$1 billion for some 13 years. From 2005 to 2017, its annual net profit averaged almost S$1 billion.

Subscribe
Notify of
1 Comment
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Lawyer M Ravi: Section 35 of CPC does not empower the police to seize note book

Human Rights Lawyer, Mr M Ravi has delivered a letter to the…

Getting to know what is monetary policy in Singapore & the S$NEER

On Monday (30 March), the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) stated that…

Lawrence Wong tells students at NTU forum that Govt and people are on the same side

At a forum organised by the Nanyang Technological University’s (NTU) student union…

我国空气污染指数逼近不健康水平

印尼多处山林着火,烟霾已袭我国与邻国马来西亚。今早我国24小时空气污染指数逼近不健康水平。 根据环境局的网站24小时空气污染指数指出,我国昨日截至今日早晨10点,我国空气污染指数已达84至96点间,仍属于中等水平,其中南部的空气污染指数最高为96点,而其他地区则介于84至93点。空气指数一旦突破100点,将进入不健康水平。 环境局表示,尽管我国在接下来24小时内都属于中等水平,而其空气质量则达一小时pm2.5值,处于正常水平,但由于无法预测苏门答腊烟霾会持续多久和未来风向,因此可能会一直恶化,进入不健康水平。 印尼森林火灾一直各界关注的问题,烟霾经常袭击印尼周围的国家包括我国,但其中深受其害的是邻国马来西亚,导致400所学校必须停课,甚至掀起外交问题。 今年的烟霾问题因干旱而加剧火灾蔓延,导致烟漫严重侵袭邻国。在一个负责监督森林火灾和烟霾的气象中心侦测到,印尼苏门答腊和加里曼丹已有1619个“热点”(hotspots,即可能正在发生火灾的地方)。东协专门气象局数据亦显示,印尼的热点也加剧上升。 对此,印尼部长矢口否认印尼为肇事元凶,而深受其害的马国亦表示将通过一切外交渠道,以向印尼政府施压,对现有烟霾问题采取行动。 尽管我国并不如邻国深受其害,但环境局依然呼吁民众尤其是老人、孕妇、小孩、患有心肺疾病之患者减少外出活动,若身体不适,尤其是老人和小孩或心肺疾病患者,应立即寻求医疗协助。