Mr Eugene Thuraisingam (Photo by Ariffin Sha)

A tribunal appointed by Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon has ruled that a poem penned by criminal and human rights lawyer, Eugene Thuraisingam, “is more likely to have been an authorial misstep than a deliberate assault upon judicial integrity.”

The tribunal, comprising of Senior Counsel Cavinder Bull and Lawyer Teo Weng Kie elected not to refer Mr Thuraisingam to the Court of Three Judges – the apex disciplinary body to deal with misconduct in the legal profession – and recommended a fine to be imposed on Mr Thuraisingam instead.

The tribunal recommended a fine of no less than $18,000 in April, but the Council of the Law Society ultimately decided to reduce the quantum of the fine from $18,000 to $5,000. The tribunal reasoned that the meaning of the poem would not have altered significantly if the reference to the judiciary had been removed.

The poem in question was published by Mr Thuraisingam on 19 May 2017. It was published few hours prior to the execution of his client, Ridzuan Bin Md Ali. On 29 May 2017, the Attorney General’s Chambers (“AGC”) requested the Law Society to refer Mr Thuraisingam to a disciplinary tribunal.

“Our five stars dim tonight.
Our son will be no more.
Killed at the hands of strangers.
At the orders of those who do not care.

Our five stars dim tonight.
For a cruel and unjust law.
The fate of a life, in the hands of one.
Who himself doesn’t really care.

Our five stars dim tonight.
With our million dollar men turned blind. 
Pretending not to see.
Ministers, Judges and Lawyers. 
Same as the accumulators of wealth.
Hiding in the dimness, like rats scavenging for scraps.
When does the new car come?

Our five stars dim tonight.
For a law that makes no sense.
A law that is cruel and unjust.
Just as its makers, executors stand.
Jeffrey has died. Ridzuan is next.
Killed not in our names, but by the decree of one.

Fear not my friend, we tread through this darkness.
The sons of this soil have spoken.
Regardless of race. Regardless of language. Regardless of religion.
As our lungs shout as one, the stars will shine again!

The people have spoken.”

On 7 August 2017, the portions of the poem that are in bold underline were held to be in contempt of court by Justice See Kee Oon. Mr Thuraisingam was fined for the poem that “scandalised the judiciary.” During that hearing, the AGC had submitted that the Court should impose a fine of $10,000 on Mr Thuraisingam.

Senior Counsel Ang Cheng Hock, who represented Mr Thuraisingam, highlighted Mr Thuraisingam’s long and unblemished record before the Courts and his public service in his submissions. Ultimately, a fine of $6,000 was imposed on Mr Thuraisingam by the High Court. In addition to the fine imposed by the Law Society, this brings the total quantum of fines faced by Mr Thuraisingam in relation to the poem to $11,000.

In its report, the 2-men tribunal concluded that the “most compelling” point of mitigation were his efforts to remedy and apologise for the contempt.

Mr Thuraisingam publicly apologised for the poem on 5 June 2018 on his own accord.

Mr Thuraisingam has provided pro-bono legal services to accused persons for more than 17 years under the Criminal Legal Aid Scheme (“CLAS”). He has also volunteered with the Legal Assistance for Capital Offences (“LASCO”), a scheme that was “the closest to his heart.”

Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon (left) presenting the LASCO Award to Mr Eugene Thuraisingam (right). TNP PHOTO: OH XING YEE

Over the past six years, he has handled no less than 17 cases where his clients faced the death penalty. Ridzuan, the subject of the poem, was also one of Mr Thuraisingam’s clients. Mr Thuraisingam, in his affidavit, explained that the anguish he faced after walking away from his last meeting with Ridzuan led to him publishing the poem.

“One of the most heart wrenching things that I have ever had to do in my 16 years of practice is to walk away from my clients at my final meeting with them after explaining that there is nothing more than can be done in Court to save lives.

I was extremely upset on the night of Ridzuan’s execution. I was demoralized that there was nothing further I could do for him as his lawyer. He was young and there was so much more that he could have done with his life. Yet, because of mistakes committed in the folly of his youth, he was set to be executed.

I was not in the right frame of mind when I published the Facebook post.” – Mr Thuraisingam in his affidavit.

Mr Thuraisingam was awarded the LASCO Award in 2016 for his work and a Silver Medal by the Law Society Pro-Bono Services Office in appreciation for his dedication to CLAS. Over the years, he has also argued in a number of high-profile cases of significant public interest. In 2014, he represented Roy Ngerng when he was the subject of a defamation suit by PM Lee Hsien Loong. He also represented The Online Citizen when we were sued by the Ministry of Defence for alleged harassment. He acted for the family of the late Dinesh Raman in relation to his death in police custody. He currently represents the applicant in a constitutional challenge against Section 377A of the Penal Code.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

25 errant motorists booked for smoky vehicle and idling engine offences

25 errant motorists were booked for smoky vehicle and idling engine offences…

NEA announces subsidies for hawkers at social enterprise hawker centers for only 2 years

NEA announced on Fri (16 Nov) that stallholders at the 7 new…

与奥巴马合照、英超球会收购风波女主角 竟也是共青团员?

因宣布要收购英超球会“喜鹊”纽卡斯尔(Newcastle),贝拉格夫维新集团(Bellagraph Nova Group,以下简称BN集团),一时引起轰动,不料却被踢爆,原本该集团中国女商人沈屮(chè)、本地商人罗尔伟和罗弥伦,与奥巴马合影竟是造假! 该集团在本月22日,承认对有关与奥巴马合影“动过手脚”作为宣传材料。奥巴马去年12月在新加坡出席一场慈善晚宴,与沈屮交谈的一张照片,背后的黑色背景竟被加上BN集团标志,以及把本地商人罗尔伟Terence Loh,也修进照片中,坐在奥巴马右侧: 据《海峡时报》报道,BN集团是今年6月成立的投资集团,由沈屮(evangeline shen)的贝拉格夫集团(Bellagraph Group)以及本地商人堂兄弟罗尔伟和罗弥伦的Lohs Dorr Group合并而成。 被卷入篡改照片风波,BN集团称照片是“一名犯错的个人所为,而且这人可能存有恶意”,并委任独立律师调查这起事件。 中国女商人沈屮,毕业自名校复旦大学和人民大学,2011年通过律师资格考试,2012年取得律师资格;在2017年的一次采访,沈屮被形容来自具影响力家庭,丈夫与家人从事宝石生意已有时日。…

NUS and SFA investigate latest gastroenteritis incident in student residence, suspends food stall

The National University of Singapore (NUS) and the Singapore Food Agency (SFA)…