Yesterday (12 Feb) in Parliament, Health Minister Gan Kim Yong tried to explain why Mikhy Farrera Brochez, the American who allegedly leaked information from Singapore’s HIV Registry, was not charged under the Official Secrets Act (OSA) 3 years ago, back in 2016.

Brochez was only charged with offences under the Misuse of Drugs Act, Penal Code and Infectious Diseases Act.

Brochez’s partner, Ler Teck Siang, however, was charged under OSA together with the other charges. But Ler’s OSA charge is currently being stood down, which means it has been put aside until proceedings on his other charges have been concluded.

So, that means to say, back in 2016, the public wouldn’t know about private sensitive HIV information had already been leaked to non-authorised person like Brochez.

The only thing the public would know back then with regard to the OSA charge would be the information on Ler’s charge sheet, which stated that Ler had access to the HIV Registry as part of his former position as NPHU head, and had failed to take reasonable care of the information by failing to retain possession of a thumb drive on which he had saved the HIV Registry. It certainly didn’t say much about information being leaked to 3rd parties.

Gan: AGC decided on the charges for Brochez

In any case, Gan explained that Brochez was already facing other charges that carried heavier penalties.

Gan said that it was the Attorney-General’s Chambers (AGC) who decided on the charges. “AGC decided not to charge him (Brochez) under the OSA because they assessed that he would likely be sentenced to a fine only, or at most a few weeks in jail,” Gan said.

“He was already facing numerous fraud and drug-related charges, which carried far heavier penalties. AGC also assessed that any jail term under the OSA was likely to be concurrent with jail terms that he would serve under the other offences.”

Also, there had been no wide dissemination of the information at that stage, Gan added. Still, Brochez did possess official information which he was not supposed to have.

The government only issued a “stern warning” to Brochez with regard to his OSA offence.

Said Gan, “So that there is no doubt, let me say again that the OSA charge against Ler is still ‘live’. AGC will decide on the OSA charge after proceedings on his other charges have concluded. This is the usual course.”

MOH only disclosed to the public early this year (2019) about the leak after sensitive HIV information began to appear online publicly, 3 years after the information was leaked to Brochez.

AGC decided to charge driver for both corruption and contravening OSA

Indeed, it is the AGC who would decide who, what and when to prosecute on a case-to-case basis.

For example in 2017, driver Lim Sua Huat, a middleman for a gang leader, was charged with 4 counts of corruption together with 3 other charges of contravening the OSA.

Lim gave bribes to a police officer who showed him photographs of a group of men arrested for rioting.

Lim eventually pleaded guilty to three of the seven charges – two for giving bribes and one for receiving information in breach of the OSA. The police officer was subsequently also dealt with.

Lim was later given a jail sentence. In Lim’s case, the heavier sentence carried by the corruption charges compared to the OSA charges had not stopped AGC from prosecuting Lim with corruption charges together with OSA charges.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Employee “did not deceive” agency in job application: IDA

The Infocomm Development Authority (IDA) of Singapore says its investigations have shown…

Sex and the seduction of money

Alex Au, aka Yawning Bread, gave this talk as part of interesThink2 in Feb 2008. Alex spoke on “the pros and pros of prostitution”.

选举局公开招标 邀供应商提供150个投票亭设施

选举局昨日在政府电子商务采购网站GeBIZ,向供应商公开招标约150个投票亭(polling booth)设施。 供应商需下周四透过GeBIZ提交报价,并且须在下月31日交货。 投票亭需要一個垂直支架和书桌,均为纯白色,不应有任何補丁或色調。而其桌桌面需高1米,垂直支架约长1.75米。 其次,垂直支架和书桌,均需由轻便简易的瓦楞纸板或其他相同的纸板搭成,而且必须具有环保效益。该纸板还必须能够在一分钟内完成组装。 除了招标150个投票亭,供应商也可选择竞标供应50至350个不同数量投票亭,惟须在得标后六周内交货。 上周三选举局宣布,总理已召开选区范围检讨委员会,该委会的成立,旨在于选举前划分选区,也是迈入大选前进行的例行工作。 另外,选举局也在近数个月内,提出其他招标的要求,如:8月23日招标笔记本电脑供应;于9月2日截止招标。 而6月期间,已向公共汽车运输服务提出招标,最终授予ComfortDelGro Bus,在选举期间为投票者提供运输服务。 今年7月,也招标邀请承包商提供印刷、包装和文件运送服务,合约期限为期三年。


武装部队召开新闻发布会,陆军总长吴仕豪少将告诉媒体,根据武装部队初步调查结果显示,本地艺人冯伟衷是在维修155毫米榴弹自走炮炮管时,被移动的炮管困在炮车内部,并碾压至重伤。 陆军部队也决定,即日起暂停所有高风险军训,武装部队也将全面降低军训密集度,把更多精力放到军训安全上。 吴仕豪少将说,冯伟衷是经训练的军备技术员,负责维修自走炮。事发时,他和另一名技术员和一名炮塔指挥官在场,为炮管故障进行检查。 “为了给炮管进行维修,他们必须把炮管先从高位下降,恢复到待机状态的位置。” 但是在这过程中,位于炮塔内的炮管后端,会往后延伸。冯伟衷相信当时因为来不及逃脱,被往后延伸的炮管卡在车内,严重碾压至重伤。 吴仕豪说,炮管降下后,炮塔内空间减少,但仍有空间给技术人员工作。 吴仕豪也在记者会上展示,从炮塔内观察,正常炮管降下时,炮管后端的往后延伸动作: 吴仕豪说,这是一起不幸事件,在自走炮投入服务15年来,未有类似的严重辗伤事故。 目前,陆军需要完整调查,国防部也会召开独立调查委员会, 以深入调查事故的真正起因。 三军总长王赐吉中将,今午率吴仕豪少将、作战后勤支援指挥部司令陈君有上校、陆军军医长卢宏一上校,和人力司司长李忠伟召开记者会,交代初步调查结果。 作战后勤支援指挥部司令陈君有上校,在针对媒体询问时指出,当炮管要降下,炮塔指挥官需口头预警,也需回头视察炮塔室的情况,才按下降炮管的按钮。…