Yee
Yee
Yee

In a letter to the Prime Minister on Saturday, a group of members of the public, which include parents and prominent members of the community, have expressed concerns over the “harsh treatment” of 16-year old video-blogger Amos Yee.

“We are writing to register our deep concern as citizens and as parents, teachers and other adults who work with children and young people, over the State’s prosecution of Amos Yee,” the letter, endorsed by 77 signatories, said.

“Besides the negative impact on his well-being and that of his family, the harsh treatment he has faced creates a negative environment for all younger members of our society.”

They also urged Mr Lee “to honour Singapore’s commitments under the Convention on the Rights of the Child to always act with the best interests of the child as a primary consideration in all actions undertaken by public institutions.”

“We are aware of the negative aspects of Amos’ communications,” the letter said. “Nonetheless, we are troubled by the State’s harsh reactions to them, including the prosecution’s request for reformative training lasting at least 18 months.”

The group said it hopes the letter “will be received in good faith – as a demonstration of our commitment to just and reasonable processes, and our shared concern with the State toward the safe-guarding and nurturing of our young.”

The letter is also copied to Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Home Affairs Teo Chee Hean, Education Minister Heng Swee Keat, and Attorney General VK Rajah.

The letter is the latest to join in the call for the release of the teenager or to express concerns about his treatment by the State. The United Nations, Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International have all called for the youth to be released immediately, and protests in Taiwan, Hong Kong and Malaysia have also taken place in support of the boy.

Singaporeans will also be taking to Hong Lim Park tomorrow (Sunday, 5 July) at 4pm to lend their voices to the call to free Amos Yee. (See here.)

The teenager would have been in remand for a total of 55 days by the time of his next appearance in court on 6 July. It is expected that he will be sentenced then.

Here is the letter to PM Lee in full:

The Prime Minister

Mr Lee Hsien Loong

Republic of Singapore

CC: The Minister for Home Affairs

The Minister for Education

Attorney General

04 July 2015

Dear Prime Minister,

We are writing to register our deep concern as citizens and as parents, teachers and other adults who work with children and young people, over the State’s prosecution of Amos Yee. Besides the negative impact on his wellbeing and that of his family, the harsh treatment he has faced creates a negative environment for all younger members of our society.

We trust and hope that this statement of our concerns will be received in good faith – as a demonstration of our commitment to just and reasonable processes, and our shared concern with the State toward the safe-guarding and nurturing of our young.

In considering our letter, we also urge you to honour Singapore’s commitments under the Convention on the Rights of the Child to always act with the best interests of the child as a primary consideration in all actions undertaken by public institutions.

We are aware of the negative aspects of Amos’ communications. Nonetheless, we are troubled by the State’s harsh reactions to them, including the prosecution’s request for reformative training lasting at least 18 months.

Many of us have been working to nurture our young to take ownership of and participate in matters concerning the wellbeing of Singapore society. As reflected in changes in our education system and programmes targeted at young people in recent years, we want young Singaporeans to be empowered to articulate their thoughts and to present and defend their ideas, even if we disagree with them. As you said only this week, “You want people to stand up, not scrape and bow.”

To learn to conduct themselves, including to forge norms around mutual respect and civil disagreements, young people need to feel safe. Likewise, to continue to encourage our children or students to think creatively, to be active participants in their learning journeys, to enthusiastically stake their claims on social matters, we too have to be assured that such parenting and pedagogical practices will not bring them harm.

The prosecution of Amos Yee has already undone some of the progress we have witnessed among young people, and the prosecution’s call for reformative training threatens to undo even more. Growing up with access to rich sources of information as well as outlets for expression, young people have great potential for being engaged citizens. While we may not agree with everything that they say or do, we must ensure that they continue to feel safe in venturing out, and that making mistakes will not mean they will be punished in ways that compromise their well-being and/or stigmatise their futures.

We are deeply concerned by information circulating in social media that Amos has been shackled and subjected to treatment that is generally meant for mature offenders charged with more serious offences.

Moreover, whether or not Amos Yee has mental illness and/or autism, we are concerned that the use of physical restraint and institutionalisation in response to his alleged condition(s) will contribute to the stigmatisation of young people with mental illness and/or autism. Mental health and autism-related needs should be met on a welfare-centred basis, not treated as inherently threatening or violent.

As Amos’ sentencing is due to take place imminently, we ask that the State discharge its prosecutorial functions with caution, sensitivity and generosity in its position and treatment of the child.

While all persons, including young people and children, should learn to respect other members of society, prosecution and detention is not the best way to teach/learn. Witnessing the severe consequences faced by Amos and his parents, many young people will hold back from genuine engagement and exploration; parents, teachers, and other adults who work with our youth will be wary of encouraging young people to be courageous and unafraid of making mistakes. We can make every claim to encourage independence of thought and creativity, but if our actions reveal an inability to tolerate non-conformists, young people will view our exhortations to speak up as mere platitudes. This will be a deep loss not just for Amos and his family, but also for the future of Singapore society.

Yours Faithfully,

Adlina Maulod Denvy Lo Priscilla Chia
Aishah Othman Dickson Su Rachel Zeng
Alfian Bin Sa’at Elaine Ee Ranjana Raghunathan
Alvin Tan Cheong Kheng Elia Corina Dorine Shelley Thio
Andre Goh Eng Kai Er Sheena Kanwar
Annamalai Kokila Parvathi Faeza Sirajudin Siew Kum Hong
Audrey Wong Foo Jong Soon Siew Meng Ee
Aw Yang Xun Georgina Lee Soh Seok Keim Shirley
Bernard Lim Chee Guan Goh Li Sian Stephanie Chok
Braema Mathi Indira Arumugam Sun Koh Boon Luang
Carlyn Law Jialiang LIm Sudhir Vadaketh
Catherine Lim Suat Hong Jolene Tan Tan Joo Hymn
Chan Wei-Yin Jaclyn Jolovan Wham Tan Pin Pin
Cheng Seow Wee Michael Kevin Chua Tan Tarn How
Cheng U Wen Lena Lim Siauw Chong Teng Qian Xi
Cherian George Little Ong Teo Liak Theng
Chong Ja Ian Lau Seok Yee Teo You Yenn
Chiong Ai Ni Irene Liew Kai Khiun Thiagarajan Kanaga Sabapathy
Chng Nai Rui Lo Dening Thirunalan Sasitharan
Chng WeiJie, Ivan Low Peter Cuthbert Thum Ping Tjin
Choo Zheng Xi Lynn Lee Wee Sheila Moira nee Wilson
Christina Lee Mandakini Arora Wong Pei Chi
Colin Goh Yong Ping Malvina Tan Woon Tien Wei
Constance Singam Ngiam Su-Lin Yogeswari
Damien Chng Ong Keng Sen Zubaida Ali
Dana Lam Yoke Kiew Prashant Somosundram
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Mixed reactions from netizens over enforcement officer’s action of kicking errant rider off his PMD to stop him

On Tuesday (10 December) a video captured by a vehicle’s dashcam saw…

国大采纳检讨委会建议 未来严重性犯罪者或立即开除

国大采纳检讨委员会提出的十项建议,加重处置措施,其中针对严重罪行者立即开除。 国大校董会董事郭运光,今早以委员会主席发出电邮给学生、教师以及教职人员,透露最新调查结果,表示委员会针对犯罪行为探讨研究国际最佳范例、向各个学生、教职人员进行15个一对一的对话以及委聘独立调查机构向全校师生进行网络调查,最终制定出更完善的新处置框架。 处置框架含将在送往实习公司或聘雇公司的成绩单上注明停学记录;而记录将在毕业后延续一段时间;停学至少一年以上,同时将以“犯下严重罪行”为由,禁止进入校内及不允许与受害者接触;罪行严重者将会被开除。 另外,犯罪者需经医疗专业者或辅导者的检定,才能重返校园,每一名犯罪者都需配一名个案负责官员全程监督过程,并在康复治疗提供支持。 而针对受害者的支持系统,调查委员会提议国大应加强相关资源介入,建立受害者关怀中心,聘雇辅导、社工、心里相关的专业人士及时提供受害者紧迫的需求;加强受害者支持网络,在同侪、宿舍、学院、学系之间建立支持网络系统,及时提供相关讯息、建议。 此外,委会认为近年来性犯罪案件层出不穷,故呼吁国大需提升校园安全性如加强校内的淋浴间的保护措施,也增加了宿舍的保安人员人数,而在全校宿舍洗澡间内也会安装新的洗澡间锁扣,同时至少安装300架新的监视录像。 国大董事会表示全面接受调查委员会提供的意见,而国大校长陈永财教授下来将在未来重新审视委员会提出的意见,并公布落实上述建议的具体计划。为了确保有关框架的有效性,国大也会两年后重新检讨,确保框架合适性。 国大校长陈永财教授下来几天内会公布落实上述建议的具体计划。国大董事会两年后也会重新检讨纪律框架,确保有关框架有效且合时宜。 4月18日,受害者马芸在Instagram分享了她对国大没有对于去年11月,在尤索夫宿舍厕所偷拍她的Nicholas Lim给予更多处罚,感到沮丧。此事很快在国大学生和社会界中引起热烈议论,认为涉事者未获得应有的处罚,而没给予受害者足够的保护。 国大校长陈永财教授随后向国大校友发函道歉,坦言没有第一时间为受害者提供足够协助,而教育部长王乙康则表示有关的处罚“明显不足”。 也有国大学生群组公开,国大三年内有超过20起涉及非礼、偷拍等违规行为;国大也在4月25日,于校内举办与学生对话会,逾700学生挤爆现场,其中包含多名受害者出面叙述及抨击国大在不当性行为处置上过轻,要求重新调整处分制度。同时,国大校方成立检讨委员会检讨惩处框架。

Media freedom – a bid for trust in policy making

~ By Howard Lee ~ As Singaporeans – or perhaps only those…

傅海燕:国家美术馆发展项目未涉舞弊

工人党后港选区议员方荣发今日在国会提问,根据2018/2019财年审计长报告,新加坡文化、社群及青年部 (MCCY)在国家美术馆发展项目上,有1千300万新元因为合同条款中不当的豁免,多支付给承包商,为何被审计长报告指要收回可能已太迟? 对此该部部长傅海燕则回复,在检讨审计长报告后,认为有关合约条款中的豁免未涉及舞弊。她说,该部直接拨款给新加坡美术馆公司(NGS)管理,以达到效率和节约成本效果。 她解释,新加坡美术馆公司及时完成项目,且未超过5.32亿新元预算。 “1千300万元,并不是多支付的款项,而主要是“罚款豁免”(waiver of penalty),特别是针对承包商逾时完工。” 针对审计署报告,她表示文社青部会与新加坡美术馆改进其财务和采购政策。 对此方荣发询问,是否会收回1千300万元的金额?傅海燕则再次澄清,有关款项不是多付款项,而是针对大型项目的豁免。 她称,在和新加坡美术馆仔细检讨审计署报告后,认为“没有理由进行主要的索回款项,且该部也满意有关索讨和合约变更指示,是基于良好理据。” e审计署报告指出,美术馆擅自同意改变总建筑合约中的一些条款,涉及款额1300万元。不过,拥有这个项目的文社青部迟至去年9月,也就是账款结清后的一年才向美术馆提出质疑。 审计署则责难,到那时候,即便向承包商追讨款项也太迟了。虽然这个项目由美术馆以“担保有限公司”的形式管理,但文社青部仍应设立监管机制。…