Amos Yee

By Dr Ang Yong Guan

Amos Yee
Amos Yee

I find the whole saga of “managing Amos” baffling.

First, months ago, Amos’ mother told the court that Amos was assessed on 2 separate occasions before the trial began, by IMH psychiatrist(s).

Weeks later in court, when Amos rejected probation, he was remanded in prison for 3 weeks to assess his suitability for RTC (Reformative Training Centre).

What was the diagnosis given to Amos by the team of psychiatrists and psychologists who assessed him? Did they agree with Dr Munidasa Winslow, who assessed Amos’s suitability for RTC, that Amos might have ASD (Autistic Spectrum Disorder)? Was their report tendered in court yesterday (23 June 2015)?

If they had concluded that Amos is NOT suitable for RTC, couldn’t they also comment whether Amos is suitable for MTO (Mandatory Treatment Order) because after all, all psychiatrists, besides diagnosing a patient, are also supposed to provide a treatment plan (which will include medications, counselling, treatment (e.g. MTO as an outpatient or an in-patient in an institution such as RTC or IMH) and support for caregivers.

Now, is the remand at IMH for a further 2 weeks to assess his suitability for MTO (Mandatory Treatment Order) necessary?

Especially after spending a gruelling 3 weeks at RTC, also for the purpose of assessment?

Hence, in total, we are saying Amos needs 5 weeks for assessment, first for suitability for RTC and now, for MTO!

Instead of remand at IMH for 2 weeks, shouldn’t Amos be assessed as an outpatient regarding suitability for MTO?

Moreover, shouldn’t the psychiatrist(s) who had previously seen him at IMH also provide a report to the court to state a) their diagnosis of Amos, and b) whether he is suitable for MTO?

Essentially, what the judge needs to know are:

  1. What is the diagnosis? (Thus far, at least 3 sets of psychiatrists have seen him: IMH, prison and Dr Winslow).
  2. What kind of “treatment” (if needed at all) is best for Amos given the diagnosis of these psychiatrists – RTC or MTO or etc?
  3. If Amos needs further assessment can it be done as an outpatient?

Finally, conventional psychiatric treatment does not work for some teenagers with ASD.

What Amos needs are creative mental health professionals who can customise a treatment plan specifically for him so as to engage him and motivate him to have healthy ways of coping and mastering life.

For instance, the Israeli Defense Force achieved a series of operational successes recently thanks to a group of soldiers with autism who contributed their unique abilities to Intelligence Unit 9900.

Read the article here: “IDF Intelligence Unit Using Soldiers With Autism Produces Stellar Results“.

The writer is a psychiatrist who runs the Ang Yong Guan Psychiatry clinic located at Paragon Medical. He is  former president of the Singapore Psychiatric Association.

The views expressed here are his own and do not represent any organisation he may be associated with.

The article was first posted on Dr Ang’s Facebook page here.


Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like


荣誉国务资政吴作栋在个人脸书和Instagram分享,昨日早上(22日)接种了第一剂冠病19疫苗。他称接种过程顺利,仅注射部位感到轻微疼痛。 “较后我也前往动物园走了一小时,也不感到体力有减少。” 吴作栋现年79岁,他称本身也同样关注接种的潜在副作用,但也更担忧感染冠病风险,特别是在这个年纪病毒对健康的危害。 他指自己找了资料,并咨询医生后,认为预防胜于治疗,于是决定和其他年长者一样,前往接种疫苗。 他称接种过程顺利,昨日早上在马林百列民众俱乐部也有60多名年长者注射了疫苗。他也感谢卫生部、医护人员、志工和该区议员陈诗龙医生等。

555 new cases of COVID-19 infection in S’pore; 550 locally transmitted cases, 5 imported

As of Saturday noon (11 Sep), the Ministry of Health (MOH) has…

马国”复原行管令“至831 惟宴会、夜店仍被禁

马来西亚首相慕尤丁宣布,马国”有条件行管令“结束,6月10日起政府允许跨州,惟民众受促避开拥挤人群。 从6月10日起至8月31日,则落实复原行管令。大部分社交、商贸经济、宗教、教育活动将分阶段恢复,不过仍不允许娱乐活动。 夜店、卡拉OK及宴会等,依然被禁止。 至于不涉及肢体接触的运动和休闲活动重新开放。包括运动团队的准备训练,以及保龄球、羽毛球、射箭、射击等。

Govt no longer requires typhoid vaccination for food handlers including foreign workers

The Ministry of Health (MOH) and the Singapore Food Agency (SFA) has…