Residents divided over gardening plots’ “cemetery-like” design in Choa Chu Kang

A cluster of gardening plots at Block 672A Choa Chu Kang Crescent has sparked mixed reactions among residents, with some drawing comparisons to cemetery grounds due to the layout’s resemblance to burial plots.

The plots, which were recently constructed, have attracted attention after a local resident expressed discomfort with their “cemetery-like” appearance.

The 60-year-old, reportedly so spooked by the site, claimed he would purposely take a detour to avoid passing the area at night, according to a report by Shin Min Daily News.

The gardening plots gained further traction online when a member of the public posted a complaint on Facebook, criticising the design as incongruent with the surrounding environment.

The garden consists of 21 plots, which are situated on a concrete base and surrounded by grass patches.

The walls of the plots are made from concrete, and one horizontal plot is noticeably larger than the others. Additionally, a storage space resembling a pavilion sits adjacent to the garden.

A resident told Shin Min that the construction of the plots was completed just a few months ago, while another resident, who has lived in the area for 25 years, explained that the plots were added following a renovation of the estate.

The intention was to provide residents with the opportunity to cultivate plants right outside their homes.

TC Defends Gardening Plots Design, Citing “Careful Planning”

In response to the criticism, a spokesperson from the Marsiling-Yew Tee Town Council defended the design, stating that it was the result of “careful planning”.

The spokesperson explained that the intention was to optimise the limited space available and bring more greenery to the community, particularly in an urban environment where land resources are constrained.

The gardening plots were designed by an experienced professional who has worked on numerous local projects.

The spokesperson noted that the design maximises gardening space, providing more and larger functional gardening areas for residents.

Additionally, the garden includes gardening boxes of various heights to accommodate wheelchair users, ensuring accessibility for all.

Looking ahead, the town council plans to run community activities, such as gardening and painting sessions led by volunteers, starting in early 2025.

Residents are encouraged to visit the garden once it is fully completed, with the hope that it will become a well-integrated and vibrant part of the community.

Mixed Reactions to Design: Some Criticise, While Others Call for More Sensitivity

Observing the comments on Lianhe Zaobao and Mothership’s Facebook posts, some sarcastically referred to the designers as “brilliant,” while others suggested that the Town Council should be more sensitive to the design.

One netizen commented: “Actually, there are many styles that could have been designed, but the concern is how much space would be needed. It’s really inauspicious and unattractive.”

Another comment noted that similar designs by NPark have been used in other neighbourhoods without complaints. he suggested that as plants grow, the plots will no longer resemble graves.