Source: UN Photo / Martine Perret

States should further recognise the connection between enforced disappearance and economic, social, and cultural rights, in order to better prevent enforced disappearances in a holistic way, said United Nations (UN) human rights experts in a statement on Friday (27 Aug).

The statement was issued by the UN Committee on Enforced Disappearances and the Working Group on Enforced or Involuntary Disappearances in conjunction with International Day of the Victims of Enforced Disappearances, which falls on 30 August.

“Enforced disappearance, by its nature, is a complex crime that violates all ranges of rights, including economic, social and cultural rights, of the disappeared, their relatives, and others,” read the statement.

It stated that the lack of effective protection of economic, social, and cultural rights is also a contributing factor to enforced disappearances, adding that people living in poverty are more vulnerable and exposed to higher risk of enforced disappearances.

“In some instances, when encountering the criminal justice system, they are deprived of legal advice and assistance to challenge the conditions of their arrest, trial, conviction and detention, and thus disappear within the system.

“Victims of enforced disappearances are also mostly marginalized. When they live in areas with little or no State institutions present, their family and relatives have little access to justice and effective means to search for them,” the statement explained.

It also noted that children who lack access to education, live in poverty, or in street situation or have been displaced, face greater risk of being abducted to turn into child soldiers or trafficked for the purpose of exploitation.

“Migrants and persons with disability are also particularly vulnerable to enforced disappearances, due to the lack of financial resources, protection schemes, as well as political, social and cultural participation,” the statement added.

Enforced disappearances put family and relatives in a very challenging position

The human rights experts shared that they have observed throughout their work that enforced disappearance is used as a tool of intimidation, reprisal, and unlawful punishment against human rights defenders, including individuals who promote economic, social, and cultural rights.

Hence, they urge all States to address the fact that enforced disappearances put family and relatives in a very challenging position, especially when the breadwinner is disappeared.

“As the family structure is disrupted, spouses and children are impacted economically, socially and psychologically. Taking into account that men are usually the main target of enforced disappearances, women are particularly affected.

“They are often ostracized in the community because their partners are allegedly suspected of crimes, or because people fear associating with someone who has been the target of an enforced disappearance. The mothers may also be socially stigmatized and blamed for not taking ‘proper care’ of their disappeared children,” they elaborated.

National legislation challenges and multidimensional impact of enforced disappearances

The human rights experts went on to say that in some countries, national legislation may make it impossible to draw a pension or receive other means of support in the absence of a death certificate, revictimizing the victims, and aggravating further their vulnerability.

“Both the economic hardships and the devastation of losing a loved one may cause relatives of the disappeared great emotional trauma that can lead not only to the violation of the right to family life, but also to negative physical and psychological impacts,” they explained.

Hence, the human rights experts stressed how important it is that all States pay specific attention to the multidimensional impact of enforced disappearances on the economic, social, and cultural rights of the victims throughout the search process and the investigation.

“Moreover, States should further examine the profile and activities of those who are victims of enforced disappearances, to better respond to the collective dimension of the harm suffered by the victims and their communities,” they added.

In cases involving disappeared persons who are members of indigenous peoples or other ethnic or cultural groups, the human rights experts highlighted the need to consider and respect specific cultural patterns when dealing with the disappearance or death of a member of the community.

“When the body or remains of a disappeared are found and identified, they should be handed over to the family or relatives in accordance with the cultural norms and customs of the victims and their communities,” they elaborated.

Reaffirming support and solidarity to all victims of enforced disappearance

The COVID-19 pandemic has clearly had a devastating impact on the enjoyment of economic, social, and cultural rights in all parts of the world, and has exacerbated the impact on victims of enforced disappearances and their relatives

In this respect, the human rights experts recalled the eight key guidelines that they jointly adopted in September 2020, calling on member States to ensure the respect, promotion, and protection of the rights and obligations enshrined in the Convention and Declaration.

“We strongly reaffirm our support and solidarity to all victims of enforced disappearance and call on all States to take all measures that are necessary to avoid the additional suffering caused by the social, economic and cultural consequences of enforced disappearance,” they asserted.

The human rights experts concluded their statement saying, “In December 2020, we commemorated the 10th anniversary of the entry into force of the International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance.

“We again call upon all States to ratify the Convention and accept the competence of the Committee on Enforced Disappearances to receive and examine individual and inter-State complaints.”

Subscribe
Notify of
1 Comment
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

AWARE Op-Ed on decriminalisation of suicide

Suicide law deters treatment, not attempts Corinna Lim, Executive Director, AWARE Porsche…

NGOs in Asia Pacific show solidarity with M Ravi, suspended human rights lawyer in Singapore

12 Non-Governmental Organisations (NGOs) in Asia Pacific have issued a joint statement…

Home Affairs Minister rejects TOC application against Correction Direction for article on LFL’s allegations

Home Affairs Minister K Shanmugam on Fri (24 Jan) rejected The Online…

Journalists’ killings: UN experts urge Philippines president-elect to stop instigating deadly violence

GENEVA (6 June 2016) – Two United Nations independent experts on summary executions,…