Economics
WP’s Jamus Lim: WP’s pro-labour economic position a key difference from PAP’s pro-capital policies
While the People’s Action Party (PAP) “leans on the side of capital”, the Workers’ Party (WP) aims to help Singaporean workers have a larger share of the national income, said economics professor Jamus Lim in the second segment of a CNA political debate on Wednesday night (2 July).
Dr Lim, who is also one of the WP candidates for Sengkang GRC, made the point in response to PAP’s Vivian Balakrishnan’s assertion that WP is “PAP-lite” due to the similarities in the two parties’ proposed policies as outlined in their manifestos.
“It’s almost a position where whatever line or stand the PAP has taken, you basically use that as your reference point, then take a half step to the left,” said Dr Balakrishnan.
In response, Dr Lim highlighted that where WP and PAP “fundamentally differ is where we think those trade-offs actually should occur”.
Noting that Singaporean workers receive 42 cents for every dollar of national income compared to their counterparts in Japan who receive 55 cents, Dr Lim said that in WP’s view, Singaporean workers receive “an insufficient amount”.
“And we think the rebalance of that kind of share of the income is ultimately necessary,” he added.
Dr Lim was responding to a question from Dr Balakrishnan on how WP intends to “deal with the trade-offs” with regards to costs and how to allocate such costs in taking “all the little steps to the left” — referencing WP’s position as a centre-left political party. In contrast, the PAP is an ideologically and socially conservative centre-right party.
The WP, said Dr Lim has “actually done the math behind it” and stressed that “it actually is budget-neutral”.
“We do not necessarily object to policy just because of the sake of objection. Ultimately what we want is the right policy. I think the fact that we’re having a debate and agitating toward an answer is a positive step in that direction,” he said.
In return, Dr Lim asked Dr Balakrishnan on the extent to which the PAP has “actually evaluated the efficacy of its policies”.
“And I ask this in the context of things that were already raised [during the debate],” he added, referencing points raised by Singapore Democratic Party secretary-general Chee Soon Juan and former Republic of Singapore Air Force colonel Francis Yuen of the Progress Singapore Party on productivity and rising unemployment.
Dr Lim noted as an example that the PAP has “unsuccessfully” tried to raise productivity “since 1972” and raised concerns on whether the PAP’s “big budgets might actually do the job”.
Dr Balakrishnan replied that PAP funds its policies not by “passing the burden to our children or grandchildren”, but from Singapore’s reserves.
“And you have asked yourself: How come we have reserves? It is a question of values,” he said.
The Pioneer and Merdeka generations, said Dr Balakrishnan, materialised the country’s reserves by “spending less than they earn on a recurring basis”.
“That is why we can deploy that for a rainy day,” he said.
In terms of productivity, Singapore as a city-state needs to bring in “high-capital, high-tech, high-intellectual property” investments.
Such investments, however, “will not generate the same labour share of much of the last Industrial Revolution”, said Dr Balakrishnan.
In the Q&A moderated by CNA editor Jaime Ho, each panellist was allocated one minute to pose a question, and one and a half minutes each to give their answers.
However, the alternative parties’ representatives were each allocated only one and a half minutes to wrap up their arguments at the end of the debate, compared to the four and a half minutes given to Dr Balakrishnan.
Economics
Thailand’s household debt reaches record high amid slow economic growth
Thailand’s household debt has surged to a record 606,378 baht per household, driven by slow economic growth and high living costs. A UTCC survey found 71.6% of households struggle to meet repayments. The government is working on measures to alleviate the burden.
Thailand’s household debt has soared to a record high, with many citizens struggling to manage loan repayments due to weak economic growth, declining incomes, and rising living costs, according to a recent survey.
The study, conducted by the University of the Thai Chamber of Commerce (UTCC) in early September, revealed an average household debt of 606,378 baht (S$23,600), marking an 8.4% increase from the previous year. This is the highest level of household debt recorded since the survey began in 2009.
The survey highlighted that 69.9% of this debt is attributed to formal lending, a decrease from 80.2% last year, while informal lending has risen to 30%. This shift is largely due to many individuals reaching their borrowing limits from formal financial institutions, forcing them to seek credit from informal sources such as loan sharks.
The study also noted that a significant number of households are facing difficulties meeting their financial obligations, with monthly debt payments averaging 18,787 baht, up from 16,742 baht the previous year. The delinquency rate stands at 71.6%.
The growing household debt is placing pressure on Thailand’s economy, the second largest in Southeast Asia, which is already grappling with high borrowing costs and sluggish exports amid a slow recovery in China, its main trading partner.
Both the government and the Bank of Thailand have raised concerns over the country’s total household debt, which reached 16.4 trillion baht, or 90.8% of gross domestic product (GDP), at the end of March 2024—one of the highest levels in Asia. The central bank has introduced measures aimed at reducing this ratio to 89% by next year.
For comparison, International Monetary Fund (IMF) data from 2022 shows household debt as a percentage of GDP at 67% in Malaysia and 48.6% in Singapore.
The UTCC survey, which polled 1,300 respondents from 1-7 September, found that the majority had experienced challenges repaying debt over the past year and expected to continue facing difficulties in the coming year.
UTCC President Thanavath Phonvichai expressed concern over the long-standing debt problem, stating that household debt is primarily incurred for daily expenses, housing, vehicles, and business operations, and does not necessarily undermine the overall economy. He added that the situation would improve once the domestic economy returns to strong growth.
In response to the debt crisis, the Federation of Thai Industries has reduced its 2024 target for domestic vehicle sales by 200,000 units to 550,000, citing high household debt and stricter lending conditions as key factors reducing demand.
Finance Minister Pichai Chunhavajira emphasized the urgency of addressing household debt and urged the Bank of Thailand to provide more support to retail borrowers. He also mentioned plans to engage with banks to explore further assistance measures for debtors.
Thailand’s newly appointed Prime Minister, Paetongtarn Shinawatra, has pledged to stimulate the economy immediately.
On Monday, the government announced plans to distribute 145 billion baht to state welfare cardholders starting next week.
This is part of a broader “digital wallet” program aimed at providing financial relief to up to 50 million people, although it now appears much of the support will be disbursed in cash.
AFP
Top rice supplier India bans some exports
India, the world’s largest rice exporter, bans non-basmati white rice exports to ensure domestic availability and tackle rising prices amid global food crises, potentially impacting rice-dependent nations.
MUMBAI, INDIA — The world’s biggest rice exporter India has banned some overseas sales of the grain “with immediate effect”, the government said, in a move that could drive international prices even higher.
Rice is a major world food staple and prices on international markets have soared to decade highs as the world grappled with the Covid pandemic, the war in Ukraine and the impact of the El Nino weather phenomenon on production levels.
India would ban exports of non-basmati white rice — which accounts for around a quarter of its total — the consumer affairs and food ministry said.
The move would “ensure adequate availability” and “allay the rise in prices in the domestic market”, it said in a statement late Thursday.
India accounts for more than 40 percent of all global rice shipments, so the decision could “risk exacerbating food insecurity in countries highly dependent on rice imports”, data analytics firm Gro Intelligence said in a note.
Countries expected to be hit by the ban include African nations, Turkey, Syria, and Pakistan — all of them already struggling with high food-price inflation — the firm added.
Global demand saw Indian exports of non-basmati white rice jump 35 percent year-on-year in the second quarter, the ministry said.
The increase came even after the government banned broken rice shipments and imposed a 20 percent export tax on white rice in September.
India exported 10.3 million tonnes of non-basmati white rice last year and Rabobank senior analyst Oscar Tjakra said alternative suppliers did not have spare capacity to fill the gap.
“Typically the major exporters are Thailand, Vietnam, and to some extent Pakistan and the US,” he told AFP. “They won’t have enough supply of rice to replace these.”
Moscow’s cancellation of the Black Sea grain deal that protected Ukrainian exports has already led to wheat prices creeping up, he pointed out.
“Obviously this will add to inflation around the world because rice can be used as a substitute for wheat.”
Rice prices in India rose 14-15 per cent in the year to March and the government “clearly viewed these as red lines from a domestic food security and inflation point of view”, rating agency Crisil’s research director Pushan Sharma said in a note.
India had already curbed exports of wheat and sugar last year to rein in prices.
— AFP
-
Comments7 days ago
Christopher Tan criticizes mrt breakdown following decade-long renewal program
-
Comments3 days ago
Netizens question Ho Ching’s praise for Chee Hong Tat’s return from overseas trip for EWL disruption
-
Crime2 weeks ago
Leaders of Japanese syndicate accused of laundering S$628.7M lived in Singapore
-
Current Affairs2 weeks ago
Chee Soon Juan questions Shanmugam’s $88 million property sale amid silence from Mainstream Media
-
Singapore7 days ago
SMRT updates on restoration progress for East-West Line; Power rail completion expected today
-
Singapore1 week ago
Chee Hong Tat: SMRT to replace 30+ rail segments on damaged EWL track with no clear timeline for completion
-
Singapore5 days ago
Train services between Jurong East and Buona Vista to remain disrupted until 1 Oct due to new cracks on East-West Line
-
Singapore5 days ago
Lee Hsien Yang pays S$619,335 to Ministers Shanmugam and Balakrishnan in defamation suit to protect family home