Today (25 November), political activist Brad Bowyer was asked by the government under the Protection From Online Falsehoods and Manipulation Act (POFMA) to post a correction on a Facebook post he published on 13 November.
In a separate Facebook post today, Mr Bowyer who is currently a Progress Singapore Party member said that he amended the earlier post to include a correction with links to the government’s ‘factually’ website which states the administration’s position on the statements Mr Bowyer made.
In his own statement, Mr Bowyer said, “I have no problem in following that request as I feel it is fair to have both points of view and clarifications and corrections of fact when necessary.”
He added that he does his best to use public facts and make informed statements of opinions based on the details he has access to, saying that he does not have anything against being asked to make corrections or clarifications, especially in the public interest.
Mr Bowyer also then cautioned those who comment on Singapore domestic politics and social issues to use care and attention, “especially if you speak from a place of influence”.
He went on to express his personal feelings that POFMA was rushed through parliament and poses many opportunities for misuse, despite the government’s assurance that they will not misuse the Act and that subsequent legislation will address any gaps in the original legislation.
Mr Bowyer said, “Indeed they said as much at the time in their public statements and I take them at their word although I still feel the situation was not that urgent that a more considered piece of legislation could have been enacted after more vigorous debate and evaluation.”
He then added, “This will in no way impact my resolve or desire to do what I feel I can to improve our social and political discourse and how Singapore is governed and develops both now and in the future.”
“A responsible and vocal citizenry is as much a vital part of our democratic nation as is a responsible and listening government,” concluded Mr Bowyer.

The offending post and subsequent corrections

The post that required to be corrected under POFMA was a lengthy Facebook post in which Mr Bowyer talked about various issues from GIC investing in the Indian telco Bharti Airtel which he talked about in his accountability speech at Hong Lim Park earlier this year to Temasek’s investment in debt-ridden Salt Bae chain of restaurants and the fines that Singapore’s Keppel Corp was slapped with for its involvement in the Brazillian corruption scandal. He also mentioned the recently scrapped Amaravati city project in which Singaporean companies have invested heavily in.
In his post, Mr Bowyer had raised the question of financial accountability, saying “Is any of this wise investment by the primaries (Temasek and GIC) or fiduciary responsibility of those overseeing them as it involves public funds directly managed or indirectly injected into them?”
He added, “And this is all from the combined team we are asked to trust our futures with and the PAP claims that investors and others will lose confidence in and run away from Singapore if not resoundingly re-elected causing all sorts of disasters for us.”
On the Gov.sg Factually site, a list of corrections was made available. The site starts off by saying, “the Facebook post by Mr Brad Bowyer contains false statements of fact and misleading statements”.
One of the statements that the government corrected relates to Mr Bowyer’s apparent implication that the Singapore Government is involved in the investment decisions by Temasek and GIC which the government asserts is “false”.
The correct says, “The Government does not influence, let alone direct, the individual investment decisions made by Temasek and GIC. Which companies they invest in, or divest from, is entirely the responsibility of their respective management teams. The Government likewise does not interfere in the commercial decisions of Temasek’s and GIC’s portfolio companies.”
“Temasek and GIC are run on market principles, independent of the Government. Many of their portfolio companies are publicly listed. The Government’s role is to ensure that Temasek and GIC have competent boards, which ensure that their respective mandates are met. The Government also holds the boards of Temasek and GIC accountable for their respective overall performances.”
Regarding Mr Bowyer’s assertion that Temasek invested in the debt-ridden parent company which owns Salt Bae, the government also asserts this is “false”.
They said, “The Salt Bae chain of restaurants is owned by a company called D.ream International BV, which operates 60 restaurants throughout the world via four operating subsidiaries. Temasek invested in D.ream International BV, and not in one of D.ream International BV’s shareholders called Doğuş Holding A.Ş. The company that is reportedly in difficulties according to the article cited by Mr Bowyer, is Doğuş Holding A.Ş., and not D.ream International BV.”
Other additional clarifications the government made were that they said Mr Bowyer “Mr Bowyer uses false and misleading statements to smear the reputation of Temasek and GIC” and that his suggestion that Keppel Corporation or its subsidiary has suffered a loss due to the fine imposed is also “misleading”.
With regards to the Amaravati Project, the statement simply said that Mr Bowyer made a “sweeping statement” that the S$4 billion investments by GLCs and related parties in the project have been doing poorly “but gave no basis for it”.
To read the full corrections, click here.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

NEA to co-fund half of centralised dishwashing costs borne by stallholders at new SEHCs starting January next year

The National Environment Agency (NEA) has included the co-funding of centralised dishwashing…

人民行动党五中委卸任 让路第四代领导接班人

人民行动党昨天举行中委会选举及干部大会,最高决策组织大换血,包括副总理张志贤和尚达曼五名资深中委卸任,让路第四代领导接班人。 任满将卸任的中委领导包括该党主席许文远、副主席雅国博士、第一助理秘书长张志贤、第二助理秘书长尚达曼和党财政林瑞生。 总理李显龙自身也形容此次中委选举,是第三代团队交棒第四代的重要一步。他认为第四代领导团队需“负起重任,不辜负人民对行动党的期望,在来届大选以令人信服的方式胜选”。 新届中委会将再几周内开会,选出新中委职务,李显龙表示也会选择恰当时机,改组内阁。 剩两年时间为下届大选备战 李显龙称,新届领导将在党内担任关键职位,和他一同备战来届大选。他透露,该党最多只有两年时间为下届大选作准备。 视来届大选与2015年相比,挑战截然不同,是“新一轮考验,新一次考试”,大环境瞬息万变,人民对生活要求提升,也面对新的生活挑战。 人民行动党第35届中央执行委员会 党秘书长:李显龙 副财政:尚穆根(内政部长兼律政部长) 组织秘书:颜金勇(卫生部长) 陈振声(贸工部长)…

Expect less wet days with afternoon thundery showers in second half of Nov

The Meteorological Service Singapore (MSS) under the National Environment Agency said that…

忧客工宿舍感染传播迅速 陈清木吁改善卫生、为所有客工检测

新加坡前进党秘书长陈清木医生,担忧客工宿舍爆发感染的情况,呼吁政府应立即着手改善客工宿舍的健康、卫生和福利问题。 周日(5日),S11榜鵝客工宿舍(S11 Dormitory @ Punggol )和卓源东路的Westlite客工宿舍(Westlite Toh Guan)确诊病例激增,两座客工宿舍被列为隔离区,多达两万名客工受影响。回利阁宿舍也在较后被列为第三个隔离区。 对此,陈清木医生在昨日发文表示,“12至20名客工被放置在一间房内,客工还共用厕所和用餐区,如此拥挤的居住环境下,只怕将会导致客工间迅速感染。” 他亦质疑,若客工间无法落实社交距离(Social Distancing)、养成勤洗手的习惯,他们又该如何打破感染链。 陈清木因此强调,客工宿舍的感染问题必须迅速处理。 陈清木医生,除了是新加坡前进党秘书长,也是一名医生,行医逾半世纪。对此,他也提出如下建议:…