Last Tue (15 Jan), an elderly doctor, Dr Wong Kai Peng, 71, wrote to ST Forum complaining about the shocking fee charged by NUH (‘Shocking fee quoted for quick surgery‘).

He shared that he had an operation at the Singapore National Eye Centre (SNEC) recently.

“Though I am fully covered by private insurance, I find the cost of medical care in Singapore ridiculously expensive,” he said.

“On recommendation I first went to the National University Hospital (NUH) to have my glaucoma and cataract condition looked into.”

He was then recommended by NUH to get a day-surgery for his eye operation so as to have his cataract removed. He was also recommended to have a pump inserted into his eye to relieve the pressure inside to treat his glaucoma condition.

Dr Wong revealed, “The fee quoted was a staggering $19,000. I was very uncomfortable with what I would be charged and decided to seek a second opinion at the SNEC, which quoted me a fee of $9,000.”

He wrote to ask publicly:

  • Why are the surgical fees that high, given that the operation was not complicated and would take only 40 minutes? Perhaps it is due to the expensive implants?
  • Why is there such a huge disparity in prices between NUH and SNEC?

“This episode is highly relevant given the recent fracas at the SNEC concerning MediShield Life payout, even though my case is completely private and has no government subsidy,” he said.

NUH CEO: Difference in pricing due to different treatment options

Today (24 Jan), NUH CEO, Dr Eugene Liu, finally responded on ST Forum (‘Surgery charges depend on treatments offered‘).

NUH CEO replied that the senior eye surgeon who treated Dr Wong was of the opinion that the treatments recommended were suitable for Dr Wong.

With regard to the estimated fees quoted in Dr Wong’s case, they were based on “a complex procedure performed under general anaesthesia by a senior consultant that included both a laser procedure for cataract extraction with implant and glaucoma surgery with another implant”, the NUH CEO said.

“We understand that SNEC had recommended a different treatment option, without a laser procedure and with a different glaucoma implant. This resulted in lower charges than NUH’s estimate.”

But the CEO also noted that while professional opinions in what constitutes the most appropriate treatment for an individual patient may vary, the senior surgeon should have informed Dr Wong about other treatment options, as well as the associated costs.

NUH CEO apologised for the shortcoming.

“We apologise for this and have counselled our surgeon on this matter,” he said. “We would like to assure the public that treatment options are available to patients based on their conditions and needs.”

Notify of
1 Comment
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

国庆献词承诺打造负担得起生活 遭网民批与社会脱节

在今年国庆日,总理李显龙于兀兰海军部村庄,致国庆献词。根据8频道新闻报导,李总理以英语发表演说,表示国家经济成长维持在3至3.5巴仙,政府也一直致力优化住房、医疗保健和教育等重要政策,提升国人生活素质,加强社会安全网和强化社会凝聚力。 “每年8月9日,我们都会庆祝新加坡取得的成就,并誓愿团结一致。从独立到现今,53年新加坡克服万难,取得成功。” 他说,新加坡充满活力、繁荣昌盛,经济稳步成长、生产力提高,国人收入也有所增加,比世界许多国家来得好。 不过,李显龙指出,国际局势充满变数,例如世界两大经济体贸易关系恶化,将影响我国经济成长;朝鲜半岛局势、无核化也有许多待克服挑战。 他也提及,新加坡作为亚细安轮值主席国,将继续加深与他国包括马来西亚和印尼的合作。马国在5月大选产生新政府,两国将在互惠互利、互相尊重的基础上,和马国维持良好关系。 李显龙说,兀兰海军部村庄乃是创新组屋区,是为特别乐龄人士涉及,这里许多设施包括超市、医疗中心、社区花园、托儿所和熟食中心,这里的组屋都安装了扶手和防滑砖设备,让乐龄人士住得安心。 描绘幸福晚年生活 他尝试描绘当地居民的生活:这里当了祖父母的年长者,孩子就住在附近,孙子每天早上由父母送到这里的托儿所,再由祖父母接他们回家。 “老人家可以和朋友们一起打打太极拳、到社区花园种种花,到医疗中心做定期检查。祖父母带着放学后的孙子到熟食中心用餐、到游乐场玩耍。”如果下雨,孩子能到又该社区广场玩乐获上楼到祖父母家午睡。傍晚家长下班后,到附近平价超市(Fairprice)购物,再到父母家用餐。 李显龙说,在海军部村庄,教育、 医疗保健和住屋政策相辅相成,为居民提供完善服务。有设施良好的托儿所;医疗中心提供优质和负担得起医疗服务。 “为了缓解国人对医药费的担忧,我们推出终身健保计划(MediShield…

MOM to reject all new work pass applications for those from Hubei China

The Manpower Ministry (MOM) issued a press release yesterday (28 Jan) saying…

DPM Heng Swee Keat warns public on fake reports using his name to scam people

Deputy Prime Minister Heng Sweet Keat has warned the public on fake…

选区范围检讨委会报告终于出炉! 国会议席增至93席

千呼万唤始出来,选区范围检讨委员会报告今日终于出来。根据最新的报告,国会议席将从现有的89增至93席;六人集选区则缩减为五人集选区。 我国来届选举最迟必须在明年4月前举行。选区范围检讨委员会的成立,旨在于选举前划分选区,也是迈入大选前进行的例行工作。 上述委会划分出14个单选区,17个集选区,一个新的四人集选区–盛港集选区成立,纳入现有盛港西和榜鹅东单选区,以及白沙-榜鹅集选区的一部分。 盛港西的现任议员是交通部兼卫生部高级政务部长蓝彬明医生,榜鹅东则是张有福。 当局重设两个单选区:即从义顺集选区重新划出哥本峇鲁(Kebun Baru)、以及从宏茂桥集选区重新划出杨厝港。 当局增设的两个单选区:玛丽蒙(Marymount)则是从碧山-大巴窑集选区划出;榜鹅西从现有的白沙-榜鹅划出。 被取消的单选区是榜鹅东、盛港西和凤山。 至于白沙-榜鹅和宏茂桥六人集选区,缩减为五人集选区。 原本是四人集选区的东海岸和西海岸,则扩大为五人集选区。这两个选区过去都是兵家必争之地,东海岸也曾受到工人党强攻,取消的凤山单选区将纳入此集选区。 至于早前前进党大阵仗访西海岸,引起各界揣测该党有意强攻此区。根据选区范围委会划分,该区扩大为五人集选区后,也纳入丰加北单选区,和蔡厝港集选区的一部分。 丰加北单选区是环境及水源部兼卫生部高级政务部长许连碹博士的选区。…