In a landmark decision, the Singapore High Court ruled on Monday (Dec 17) that a gay Singaporean man was allowed to adopt his five-year old biological song who was born by way of surrogacy in the United States.

In-vitro fertilisation is not an avenue available in unmarried couples in Singapore. The procedure is only allowed to be administered to a married woman with her spouses consent. Add to that the fact that same-sex marriage is not legal in the Republic and homosexuality is still criminalised, this decision seems like a step forward for the modern nation for the LGBT community.

The man in question, a 47-year old pathologist in a long term relationship with his partner, reportedly paid a sum of US$200,000 (S$274,440) for a woman in the US to carry his child via in-vitro fertilisation after learning that his chances of adopting a child in Singapore as a gay man was very slim.

In the three-panel judge decision, Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon noted that while granting the adoption in this case would “violate the public policy against the formation of same-sex family units”, this concern is does not supersede that of the welfare of the child, which is paramount. The judges found that the child’s welfare is better preserved with his biological father.

Once the judgement was release, Social and Family Development Minister Desmond Lee wasted no time reiterating the government’s policy against the formation of same-sex family units. In a statement, Mr Lee noted that the ruling has raised concerns about the implication of the case and the precedent it sets for the formation of same sex facilities in Singapore. But with the ruling, he says gay couples seeking to adopt children in the future will find it harder.

This is because one of the main reasons behind the High Court judgement’s ruling in favour of the parent in this case is that they had found little evidence to show that the man has set out to deliberate violate the government’s policy.

As such, Mr Lee asserts that it would be more difficult for future applicants in the same situation to argue that they did not intentionally set out to violate the policy. Mr Lee said, “After the publication of this judgment, since the courts have recognised that the adoption violates the public policy against the formation of same-sex family units, it may be harder for future applicants doing the same to argue that they did not intentionally set out to do so.”

Mr Lee continued by saying that the Ministry of Social and Family Development (MSF) will be studying the grounds of the decision and review their adoption laws and related policies to see if they should be amended or strengthened.

Mr Lee emphasised, “the Government supports and encourages parenthood within marriage, and does not support the formation of same-sex family units…This is the position that MSF takes in assessing adoption applications. The High Court has recognised that this public policy is a relevant consideration in adoption proceedings.”

He also said that while that is the current policy, the LGBT community still has a place in Singapore’s society.

If that sounds hypocritical to you, then that’s because it is. How can you tell an entire community that you think they are criminals for who they are attracted to and limit their freedoms in their own country while still saying that they have a place in your nation?

Responding to the news and Mr Lee’s statements, former Associate Dean of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy(LKYSPP) Donald Low said that this isn’t progress. He described the High Court decision and subsequent statement from Mr Lee as “two steps forward, and two steps back” for Singapore.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

【冠状病毒19】全球疫情正恶化 谭德塞忧一些国家出现自满

世界卫生组织本周一称, 全球新冠疫情正在恶化,过去10天中有9天各国向该组织报告的新增确诊病例数超过10万,7日新增病例数为疫情暴发以来最高。 各国向世卫组织通报的病例多达700万例,近40万人死亡。 6月7日,7日新增病例中近75巴仙来自10个国家,其中大部分集中在美洲和南亚。 但他也警告,在情况好转的国家,“最大威胁就是自满”。 研究结果显示,全球大多数人仍易感染新冠病毒。世卫组织继续敦促各国密切监测疫情发展,特别是在一些国家开始恢复举行各种大规模集会的情况下,以确保疫情不会反弹。

前进党内部进行重组 宣布成立青年团、妇女团与国会秘书处

新加坡前进党对内部进行重组,宣布成立青年团、妇女团以及国会秘书处。 前进党本月3日晚间在脸书上发文宣布,将会对党内进行重组,日前成为非选区议员的前助理秘书长梁文辉,与前副主席潘群勤宣布卸下党职,由阮健平接替助理秘书长。 另一方面,前进党也成立青年团与妇女团,分别由年轻党员孙俊伟担任青年团团长,以及律师刘韦伶负责妇女团。 而媒体联系人则由独立媒体《独立新加坡》的前发行人比尔莱(Kumaran Pillai)担任; 资讯科技与数据安全:哈里仕·皮莱(Harish Pillay),他也是软件公司红帽新加坡的首席科技官;而郑财成则负责行政与后勤工作。 组织的秘书处则由组织秘书兼中委蔡德龙负责,通讯媒体则由成员,Ong Seow Yong负责。

COVID-19: HK has zero locally transmitted cases 17 days straight while SG struggles with 788 new ones

The Hong Kong’s government will be relaxing restrictions on public gatherings and…

Temasek releases preliminary result of negative 2.3% return 11 days after GE

Eleven days after GE 2020, Temasek Holdings reported today (21 Jul) a…