There’s been plenty of debate these past couple of weeks about the airspace issue between Singapore and Malaysia. Singapore’s Seletar Airport started using the Instrument Landing System (ILS) for plans approaching from the north over Malaysian airspace. Since Singapore’s Selatar Airport is only about 2km from Malaysia’s Pasir Gudang, the systems strict height restrictions within the flight path area – which covers a huge area over Pasir Gudang – is a point of contention with the Malaysian government.

Painting a picture of the problem that Malaysia faces, one netizen Edwin Lam pointed out that the plant he works at in Pasir Gudang, Lotte Chemical Titan has a tower that exceeds 100m, well above the height limited that would be imposed by the new ILS system that Selatar Airport is using.

A cursory check online reveals that the plant in question is about 4km from Selatar airport which will put it above the height limit claimed by both Malaysia (54m) and Singapore (93.8m) at the 3km point. Even adjusting for the additional 1km for the height limit, the height difference is simply too little for any comfort.

One measured reply to the discussion suggested returning control of the airspace back to Malaysia as it infringes on the sovereignty of the country. After all, it is their airspace.

But another person, Izwan Jay, pointed out that the indiscriminate flaring done by the plant in question leaves a chemical smell in the air that reaches the Republic. He then suggested lowering the plant’s height to keep the odour on the Malaysian side instead – basically, you keep your business on your side of the aisle before asking me to do the same.

However, Mr Lam disagrees that the Lotte plant is responsible for the chemical smell. So perhaps that point is moot.

An a separate point, one Edmund Teo, then commented that Malaysia shouldn’t be complaining about the height restrictions as 80% of Singapore is already dealing with height restrictions. He pointed out that there are not buildings taller than 20-storeys in many areas of the island but it’s still able to comfortably house 5.6 million people. Mr Teo is suggesting that there’s no real complaint here.

To this, Mr Lam noted that land development is an internal issue and Malaysia has no reason to agree with the height restrictions that could hinder future high rise development in the Pasir Gudang area. This circles back to the point of sovereignty pointed out by a different user earlier. This is one argument that’s hard to argue with. If the Malaysian government wants to reclaim their airspace, aren’t they well within their rights to do so?

Later, Mr Lam also emphasised that the while the airport is in Singapore, the airspace is over Malaysia. So even though the ILS is ‘good’ for their neighbours, it’s merely a luxury system that would only lead to bigger dispute should Pasir Gudang develop further in the future. And considering that Malaysia is still developing, there’s a good chance that if not resolved amicably now, the issue will continue to haunt both nations.

This conundrum is basically a case of two nations learning how to be good neighbours and right now, it’s not going very well.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

印尼警方逮捕185涉非法烧芭人士 迄今为止已封锁42种植企业

印尼国家警察总局发言人普拉塞蒂奥(Dedi Prasetyo)昨日称,已逮捕185名,涉嫌在印尼苏门答腊和加里曼丹岛烧芭垦荒而导致林火的人士。此外,也有四家企业被调查。 普拉塞蒂奥称,印尼警方将严厉打击放火毁林开荒的行为,并呼吁当地居民和企业提高守法意识,预防林火发生。 他指出,固然目前是干旱季节,不过警方强调造成林火的因素有99巴仙都是人为的。 若罪名成立,这些嫌犯可在环境保护法令下,最高被判10年监禁。 截至目前为止,已有至少42家种植企业被封锁。 根据印尼抗灾署(BNPB Indonesia昨日发布的消息,截至16日下午4时,可侦测到的着火点多达2153处,自今年1月至8月份,被林火波及土地面积逾32万公顷。印尼政府已投入超过九千人力扑灭林火。 在本月13日,印尼政府也宣布封锁多达29家种植公司,其中有四家马来西亚企业,以及Hutan Ketapang Industri,一家母公司总部位于新加坡的企业。 Hutan…

School outdoor programmes to go on, expert panel to advise on safety: MOE

Outdoor adventure and learning programmes organised by schools will continue, but more…

PTE Dominique Sarron Lee's brother decries the inadequacy of 'punishments'

On the 4th anniversary PTE Dominique Sarron Lee’s passing, his brother, Daryl…

PMD in fatal Bedok collision was unregistered and did not comply with regulations on weight and width limits, says LTA

The Land Transport Authority (LTA) has revealed that the personal mobility device…