Recently, food guru KF Seetoh from Makansutra published a series of blogs highlighting the dire situation those hawkers operating under the Social Enterprise Hawker Centre (SEHC) operators are in.

In particular, he published an open letter to Senior Minister of State Dr Amy Khor last Tuesday (9 Oct) imploring her to preserve Singapore’s public hawker centres. In essence, Mr Seetoh is against the government appointing 3rd-parties, the so-called “social enterprise” operators, to run publicly funded hawker centres.

In his letter, Mr Seetoh also shared many unfair commercial practices adopted by SEHC operators against hawkers, making it hard for hawkers to survive.

In an interview with ST today (‘Teething problems with new hawker centre model‘, 14 Oct), NEA told ST with regard to letting 3rd-party operators running hawker centres, “It is still at its early stage, and we should give it time to evolve.”

NEA added that it “monitors” the operators closely. For instance, the operators are not allowed to vary the charges to hawkers at any time during the tenancy term, it said.

Defending the SEHC operators, NEA said, “None of the operators has raised the rental or operating costs, including service charges that they had said they will charge the tenants at the start of the tenancy.”

NEA is currently run by a former SAF general – BG (NS) Tan Meng Dui.

NEA: Terms on premature termination in line with standard industry practice

With regard to some of the unfair tenancy termination clauses in the agreement signed between Koufu’s subsidiary and hawkers, as highlighted in a recent Mr Seetoh’s blog, NEA said,”We note that the terms on premature termination are in line with standard industry practice.”

“Notwithstanding (this), we note Hawker Management’s (Koufu’s subsidiary) clarification that in practice, it exercises compassion and flexibility on a case-by-case basis, including not charging rents for the balance of the tenure in the event of premature termination.”

The agreement from Koufu’s subsidiary mandates that the hawker would need to continue to pay for the monthly stall rental until another suitable hawker is found for replacement, should a hawker decides to quit his stall half-way. If no hawker deemed suitable by the operator is found, the hawker who quits his stall would need to pay the monthly rental till the end of the tenancy term.

This so-called “standard industry practice” surfaced after a hawker selling noodles at Koufu’s subsidiary told Mr Seetoh about his plight. After a year of running losses, the hawker decided to quit and give up their $4k a month stall as they could not sustain the business.

“To my horror, they are made to pay up the remaining years and months of rent and fees left in their contract, or till another tenant is found,” Mr Seetoh wrote.

Since then, the hawker has moved out and started running his stall at a coffeeshop. “They now have to pay up the monthly ‘penalty’ fees in the SEHC and also for rents (at) their new stall,” Mr Seetoh highlighted.

As this particular hawker is still paying his monthly ‘penalty’ fees to Koufu’s subsidiary, it could only mean that the hawker, for unknown reasons, did not fall under Koufu management’s criteria for fee waiver during its “case-by-case” basis of determination process.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Transport Minister, is pragmatism more important than values?

"Public transport concessions are given to different groups of individuals such as…

何晶:不应下定论群聚拥挤 造成客工宿舍疫情扩散

总理夫人何晶又发表“伟论”!她在周六(5月30日)发文,指出我们不应武断地定论,客工宿舍“群聚、拥挤”的情况,就是造成客工宿舍疫情爆发的主因之一。 何晶也是淡马锡首席执行长。淡马锡控股在疫情爆发后,也与盛裕控股集团寻找并确认博览中心,设立为社区护理设施。 何晶在贴文中解释,例如豪华游轮即便乘客都有独立的客房,但还是造成了疫情爆发;疗养院也不拥挤,监狱同样把囚犯区隔开来,但这些地方都出现了疫情。 社区护理设施(CCF)分为红黄绿区。一些隔离设施的“黄区”仍转变为感染群。她指出,在经过调查后,当局发现这可能是因为他们习惯把食物集中在一起,集体进食的社交习惯。 何晶提及分享食物的社交习惯存在于不同文化,也指她也认为防疫应着重在防止飞沫传播。 故此,她认为在大家反对拥挤客工宿舍、在仓促落实应对疫情的改变前,应先理解病毒的传播途径,以及人们社交习惯的本能。 “听起来像精英口气?” 不过,也有网民留言对何晶这番言论嗤之以鼻,“听起来像精英居高临下的口气,客工群体对我国经济社会作出重大贡献,这种论述似乎严重缺乏同情心。” 网民认为,即便客工的习俗可能造成疫情传播,但暗示这就是主要原因是谬误的,也缺乏基于事实的证明,反而促成分化我者与他者(因文化等)的区别。 杨莉明曾指工地共用工具也可能是传播途径 事实上,人力部长杨莉明在4月25日接受《联合早报》直播访谈, 曾提及专家研究也得知客工之间感染不仅是宿舍问题,他们也有共同工作场所如建筑工地等,而工地中工友间共用工具也可能是传染渠道之一。

India begins mega-rollout of COVID-19 vaccine

by Abhaya Srivasta India begins one of the world’s biggest coronavirus vaccine…

High-flying ex-Dty Police Commissioner to head new food agency despite being “motivated” at SPF

The government announced on Thursday (26 Jul) that a new statutory board…