Image from Google Map

Blogger Philip Ang posted a write-up on Sunday (‘PAP ministers lie about recycling land to provide affordable public housing‘, 16 Sep) highlighting that some of the HDB lands were not recycled to build affordable public housing but sold for profits to developers to develop private condominiums instead.

“PAP ministers have repeatedly told Singaporeans that public land will be recycled after 99 years to construct affordable public housing. Unfortunately, they are being economical with the truth. In reality, PAP has been taking back HDB flats – even before the end of the 99-year lease – but did not subsequently construct public housing: the land was sold to private property developers,” said Mr Ang.

Mr Ang pointed to a netizen’s post talking about HDB flats in Alexandra/Tiong Bahru area being taken back by government under SERS. The land was then divided and sold to private developers. There are now 5 condominiums sitting in the land vacated by HDB dwellers:

Indeed, before the condominiums, there were blocks of HDB flats sitting adjacent to the Delta Swimming Complex. But now, 5 new condominiums are built in the area:

According to information from, these condos are going for:

  1. The Metropolitan Condominium (Capitaland) – $1,200,000 to $5,000,000
  2. Ascentia Sky (Wing Tai) – Up to $2,988,888
  3. Echelon (Freshview Developments) – $970,000 to $7,806,400
  4. Alex Residences (Singland) – $900,000 to $2,500,000
  5. Artra (FEC) – $1,287,000 to $4,591,000

Then, there is Margaret Ville to be built on where HDB flat Block 6C used to sit on Margaret Drive:

Now, the block had been demolished and Margaret Ville is being developed by MCL Land on the vacated plot of land:

Breaking promises on HDB flats at Hillview estate

The most famous case where the government went back on its words saying that they wouldn’t acquire the HDB flats but ended up doing so anyway, would be the HDB flats at Hillview estate:

In 1988, Hillview estate was under Bukit Gombak constituency. Rumors were circulating that government might proceed to acquire the flats at Hillview using the excuse that it was too close to MINDEF. There were other rumors circulating that MINDEF wanted to acquire the blocks for “office use”.

During the GE 1988 period, then Education Minister Tony Tan accompanied Dr Seet Ai Mee, PAP candidate for Bukit Gombak, to go door-to-door to assure the residents that their flats would not be acquired. Subsequently, Dr Seet won the Bukit Gombak seat. In 1991 GE, she lost Bukit Gombak to SDP. But in 1997 GE, PAP won back. Two years later in 1999, HDB flats at Hillview were put under SERS.

Today, Hillv2 mall and condominium has replaced the HDB flats at Hillview:

“Hundreds of plots of public land meant for recycling to provide affordable housing have been sold to private developers,” noted Mr Ang.

“PAP profited billions from this while HDB flat buyers suffered when property prices shot up and are now forced to move to as far as Jurong or Punggol instead of having a home in, say, Alexandra or Tiong Bahru.”

Meanwhile, after converting HDB flats into new condos to be sold by private developers at sky-high prices, the younger generation who proceed to buy them will end up in heavy debt for the next 35 years of their working lives.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Freak result? What do you fear?

The following is sent to us by a TOC reader. Tan Hui…

选举当天状况百出 选举官员社媒诉苦选举局朝令夕改

虽然大选已落幕,但针对当天投票的情况一直被人诟病,如排长龙、居家通知的选民遭遗漏等等,最让人印象深刻的相信就是大选当天临时延长投票至晚间10点。如今也有网友在社交媒体上爆料有关当天的情况,为许多出乎意料的情况作出解答。 社交媒体Reddit上周六(11日)有网友u/hosehliao分享自己在当选举官员(Election official)的经验。 网友Hosehliao在长帖文中先解释选举官员的职责,选举官员并非是志愿者,是被分配,而且任何被指派为选举官员的人只有怀孕或请病假时才能退出。 “首先,没有谁是志愿者,我们只是被分配。只有当你怀孕或请病假才能被允许(无论是真还是假),我们会获得250至300元的报酬,听起来很棒吧,但工作时间真的很糟糕。 网友Hosehliao补充,在投票日前,他们也必须参加训练,并被告知将在投票日前一天必须花四个小时布置投票站。然而,投票日当天,网友说一般都是从早上6点半开始,但部分投票站必须在凌晨4点45分抵达,而且一同站台到晚间10点。 投票是保密的 针对选票是否能够保密,网友Hosehliao也作出回应,他澄清,尽管选票上有序列号吗,但在不知道的情况下,其实难以追踪每位选民的选票。 人民行动党在投票站监票?网友:必须待在特定的地方 至于当天谣传人民行动党派人驻守在投票站前,网友Hosehliao也解释,每个竞选政党都允许派人见证投票的过程,但他们是必须待在特定的地方,确保无法看见选民投票,或认不出所有进去的人。 “人民行动党确实有人在见证投票过程,但可能在野党并没有派人驻守所有的投票站。即便如此,他们还是必须待在特定的地点,他们看不见你投了什么,也认不出所有进去的人。” 其中最引发争议的是投票时间延长两小时和传出选举官员并未获得全套个人防护装备(PPE),对此,网友Hosehliao表示,当时情况相当混乱,就连他们的长官也无法确定。…