Last month, BBC reported that international audit firm KPMG has been severely criticised by UK watchdog, the Financial Reporting Council (‘KPMG’s audit work unacceptable, says watchdog‘, 18 Jun).

The UK Financial Reporting Council (FRC) is an independent regulator responsible for promoting high quality corporate governance and reporting to foster investment in UK. Its board of directors is appointed by the UK Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy. FRC plays a crucial role in the oversight and development of corporate governance standards such as the UK Corporate Governance Code and standards for the accounting industry.

UK FRC said that KPMG audits had shown an “unacceptable deterioration” and will be subject to closer supervision.

Every year, the UK FRC reviews the audits of Britain’s biggest companies to ensure they meet certain standards. The FRC noted problems at other auditing firms too, but KPMG was specially singled out for the poor quality of its work.

“There has been an unacceptable deterioration in quality at one firm, KPMG,” the FRC said in a statement. “50% of KPMG’s FTSE 350 audits required more than just limited improvements, compared to 35% in the previous year.”

The increased scrutiny of KPMG will now involve the FRC inspecting 25% more audits done by the firm in the 2018-19 financial year, the first time the FRC has taken such action, BBC reported.

KPMG acknowledged the deterioration of its audit and said that it is taking “action to resolve this”. It was especially criticised over its audit of UK construction firm Carillion, which collapsed earlier this year. FRC has opened an investigation into the KPMG group under the Audit Enforcement Procedure.

KPMG was also recently fined £3.2m by FRC over its audit of insurance firm Quindell. Last year, the FRC opened an investigation into KPMG’s audit of the accounts of aero-engine maker Rolls-Royce.

The accounting industry, especially KMPG, has faced a lot of criticism in the last few years over whether their verdicts on companies’ accounts can be trusted, BBC reported.

In Malaysia last month, KPMG also retracted its audit reports on Malaysia’s 1MDB for financial years ended March 2010, 2011 and 2012. KPMG told the company not to rely on its reports over the three years as they don’t show “true and fair” assessment of the troubled state fund’s finances. This came about after the Malaysian opposition won the recent general election in Malaysia and started probing the affairs of 1MDB under the previous Malaysian government.

Temasek uses KPMG

Yesterday (10 Jul), Temasek reported that it has attained a record net portfolio value of S$308 billion and a net cash position for the financial year that ended on 31 March this year.

Temasek’s one-year Total Shareholder Return (TSR) was also reported to be 12.19%, with compounded annualised returns of 15% since inception in 1974.

Temasek Chairman, Mr Lim Boon Heng, commented, “Our journey as a generational investor is one that we take with a deep sense of purpose and responsibility; we are committed to do well as an investor, determined to do right as an institution, and inspired to do good as a steward.”

In any case, on its 2018 Financial Report, it listed Temasek’s auditor as KPMG. In the report, Temasek stated that KPMG has expressed “unmodified opinions on the audited statutory consolidated financial statements” of Temasek Holdings and its subsidiaries for the financial year ended 31 Mar 2009 to 2018:


Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Singapore probes couple over anti-death penalty shirts

A Singaporean couple who wore anti-death penalty t-shirts at a running event…

保险公司遭凯发拖欠 竟向诊所讨回诊金

本地水务公司凯发集团,因在前年首次陷入赤字、并在去年五月突然宣布停牌,令投资者震惊。 凯发在去年5月22日,向高庭申请法院监督程序,以重组债务和业务,并寻求“白武士”解救。 据《联合早报》前日报导,指莱佛士医疗保险(Raffles Health Insurance,RHI),宣称无法从凯发集团收回代该集团员工缴付的诊所看诊款项,反而向诊所追回诊金。 该公司为凯发集团提供第三方支付服务,为凯发员工看诊时代为支付诊金,之后才向凯发索讨。 根据莱佛士医疗保险发给相关合作诊所的电邮,该保险公司先是“感谢各诊所为提供保户们专业医疗服务”,并且从该公司保户得到良好的反馈。 不过随之话锋一转,“如您所知,年前本公司的客户之一凯发无力偿债,并且已与本公司终止合约。” 该公司在电邮中续指,只要索偿申请完整,RHI代看诊病患即时付款给诊所。即便未能从凯发那里收到任何款项,该保险公司仍继续提供服务。 而如今,他们要索回此前代凯发公司支付的款项。 另一方面,《海峡时报》也跟进报导此事,并引述RHI母公司莱佛士医疗集团发言人说法,后者辩称是为受影响各造“寻求友好解决方案”。 不过,他们未透露具体所欠款项,和受影响的合作诊所数量。…

Protraying the type of protectionism that back rumours of cronyism

by Ghui No one is in doubt that Transport Minister Khaw Boon…

Blogging seminar this Saturday

Participants to learn tools for better blogging.