The High Court granted approval for the Attorney General’s Chambers to carry out the committal proceedings against Mr Li Sheng Wu the son of Mr Lee Hsien Yang and nephew of Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, for contempt of court over comments made in a private Facebook post.

Earlier in a warning letter to Mr Li on 21 july, AGC claimed that Mr Li made “false and baseless allegations” about the lack of independence of the Singapore Judiciary in his private Facebook post made on 15 July 2017, asking him to “purge the contempt” by deleting the post from his Facebook page and other online platforms by 5pm, 28 July. He was also asked to “issue and post prominently” on his Facebook page a written apology and undertaking drafted by the AGC.

On 28 July, AGC wrote to the press, noting that it went ahead to file an application for leave in the High Court to commence committal proceedings for contempt against him as Mr Li has failed to purge the contempt and to apologise by the deadline.

According to Senior State Counsel Francis Ng, permission was granted by Justice Kannan Ramesh on Monday (21 Aug) in a closed door hearing. The AGC has now 14 days to file an order of committal against Mr Li. A hearing can go on whether or not Mr Li or his lawyers are present.

Following the news that the High Court has granted its approval to AGC, Mr Li went on his Facebook to share two letters, one a letter from AGC to Mr Li dated 8 August and the other, a letter from Mr Li to AGC on 18 August.

In the letter from AGC to Mr Li, AGC demanded him to apologise and undertake not to repeat the allegations or make further similar allegations and that his assertions were wrong, and are in contempt of the Singapore Judiciary. In exchange for his compliance, it expressed that it is prepared to discontinue the legal proceedings it has filed against him.

In the other letter by Mr Li to AGC, he contests the claims made by AGC.

Mr Li noted that AGC has relied on an unverified screenshot of his private facebook page in making its allegations and demands. He highlights that he had already made clear in a public post on 4 August that his private post, if read in context, did not attack the Singapore Judiciary.

“Any criticism I made was in good faith, and was aimed at the Singapore government’s litigious nature and its use of legal rules and actions to stifle the free press. I said I had amended my private post so as to clarify my meaning.”

He further notes that he had explained in his response letter to AGC of 4 August, that AGC took what it believed, without verification, was his private post completely out of context and attributed to him statements he did not make.

Mr Li wrote, “I did not make any assertions in contempt of the Singapore Judiciary. AGC’s latest demands require that I make statements that are untrue and contradict my public post and my response to AGC of 4 August, and require that I apologise for assertions that I did not make. ” and emphasised that he cannot confess to a crime he did not commit in return for a discontinuance of the legal proceedings against him.

He notes that AGC also continues to ignore that his post on 15 July is private and what he said in it is meant for his friends only. “My amendment to the post is also private: it remains inaccessible to anyone other than my friends. I am not responsible for the widespread and unauthorised public publication of the contents of my original post, which AGC complains is in contempt of the Singapore judiciary.”

Mr Li pointed out that AGC had sparked widespread publication and republication of his post by making public comment on on 17 July based on an unverified screenshot from an anonymous source. “Even on 4 August, when I made a public post, I did not repeat the words in my private post that AGC complains are in contempt: I instead made it clear that I did not attack the Singapore Judiciary and had amended the post to clarify my meaning. AGC however in its press statement thereafter made public the words it complains of. ” And though Mr Li’s response letter was delivered to AGC before its press statement, AGC did not make his response public.

It was also pointed out that AGC changed its stance from demanding Mr Li to delete and remove his 15 July private post from his “Facebook page and any other social/online media and other documents in your possession, custody or control” to not having to delete his private post as since he has amended it.

Mr Li argues, given that AGC prosecutes him over a private post which he had clarified and amended, AGC should prosecute Singapore’s mainstream media, and require that they take down their unauthorized publication and republication of the contents of his original post.

Mr Li also found fault with AGC’s statement that his response letter was only received by AGC after 5pm on Friday, 4 August. “That is incorrect. My response letter was hand-delivered to AGC at 4.40pm on Friday, 4 August. This will be borne out by the footage from AGC’s security cameras. I request that AGC correct the false statement that it made to the media.”

 

Reply letter 18 Aug

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

一家三口骑摩托车“三贴”超载!网民都替他们担心

近日,一段摩托车“三贴”超载视频流出,从视频可见,黑衣骑士骑着蓝色黄蜂摩托车(Vespa),后坐着一名白衣女士,视频开始看似正常。 然而,可以隐隐约约看见一名身穿黄衣的小孩夹在两人间。最后,该名骑士便往公寓的方向拐去。 该视频由 Sg Road Vigilante释出,上传时间为12月8日。 视频出来后,也引起网民的讨论,部分网民认为这样的行为会危害孩子的生命安全。 尽管大家都知道这是违法的行为,但除了在其他国家常见,其实在本地也会遇到一些类似较危险的骑行行为。对此,新加坡政府也有明文规定,希望民众能够为安全考量,杜绝这种行为。 根据《道路交通法》第73条,两轮电动摩托车上,除司机外,不得超载多余一人的乘客。若出现超载行为,将被视为犯法。

张玮凌谋杀案凶嫌 续还押三周接受精神评估

因涉嫌在13年前杀害失踪少女张玮凌,35岁的阿默达尼尔(Ahmad Danial Bin Mohamed Rafa’ee),在上月月17日被提控上庭。 上月31日,达尼尔由Shashi Nathan律师团队辩护,透过视讯出庭。警方检控官成功申请,将嫌犯继续还押一周以作进一步调查。在今日(7日)的续审,嫌犯将继续还押三周,以接受精神健康评估。 他将在本月28日,再次回到庭上接受审讯。今日警方告知法庭,已完成对嫌犯的调查,此后嫌犯将在樟宜监狱医疗中心接受精神评估。 案件背景 达尼尔此前曾在知名电子游戏配件制造商雷蛇(Razer)公司上班,担任创意经理。他被指控于2007年6月30日凌晨,与另一32岁男子拉吉(Ragil Putra Setia…

黄志明弟弟黄志平卸任公积金局长 网民推测“好事将近”?

根据人力部文告,在公共领域服务30载的中央公积金局长黄志平,将在4月1日卸任,其职务将由人力部副常任秘书李东阳(Augustin Lee)接棒。 不过,文告未交代黄志平卸任后的去向。 人力部称,黄志平在公积金局期间,积极落实公积金局咨询团建议的政策调整,为会员提供更好退休保障、让会员累计更多退休储蓄、可满足退休需求的入息,以及能较灵活地把公积金积蓄转移给亲人。 同时,推动公积金服务数码化,例如该局成为首个使用电子支付服务的政府机构、2017年3月推出通话认证服务,通过电话安全处理个人事务、提升My CPF手机应用程序等。 人力部表示感谢黄志平的服务和领导,指出在其带领下,为会员们提供更大退休保障和改善服务体验。 接棒的李东阳曾在卫生部和贸工部等部门任职,也是荣誉国务资政吴作栋任国务资政期间的首席私人秘书。他在2010年加入人力部担任副常任秘书。 黄志平曾任海军总长 黄志平是1989年总统奖学金和武装部队海外奖学金得主,赴英国牛津大学深造,获哲学、政治与经济系一等荣誉学士学位,以及美国哈佛大学公共行政硕士学位。 他在1988年12月加入新加坡武装部队,初期任飞弹炮艇基层军官,随后获委海虎号主管军官、英勇号反潜作战军官。他在胜利号飞弹驱潜快艇首次担任指挥官,随后在国防部连续担任海军作战处处长和三军总长府长期参谋处处长。 2004年1月起:兼任第一分遣队司令…

Character assassination of the most uncharitable kind

Therapist Anthony Yeo responds to the Straits Times’ article on Chee Soon Juan