Screengrab of FDW abuse story

Singaporean employer, Chong Sui Foon claimed that her obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) led her to starve her Filipino domestic worker, however, District Judge Low Wee Ping ruled on Thursday (22 December) that her preoccupation with cleanliness would not have led her to restrict the quantity of food given to the victim.

In March 2016, Chong and her husband, Lim Choon Hong, both 48, were found guilty of starving Ms Thelma Oyasan Gawidan.

Lim, a freelance trader, faces one charge under the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act, which requires employers to be responsible for the maintenance of their foreign employees, including providing them with adequate food.

While, Chong faces one count of abetting her husband in committing the offence.

Ms Thelma, 40, had worked for the couple for almost 1.5 years before she escaped from the condominium. She lost 20kgs from her intital weight of 49kg in January 2013 to 29kg. when she escaped from the condominium she worked in and sought refuge at HOME, a non-profit organisation (NGO) in April 2014.

HOME then reported Ms Thelma’s conditions to the Ministry of Manpower (MOM), who directed the NGO to send Ms Thelma for a medical check up with a general practitioner (GP) and later at the hospital.

Ms Christina Quek, the investigation officer in charge of the case told the court that Chong only allowed Ms Thelma to shower once or twice a week at the condominium’s public toilet and how she was given two meals a day, with each ration consisting of instant noodles and a slice of bread.

Ms Quek also shared that although Lim footed the GP’s bill, he refused to pay for Ms Thelma’s hospital bill as he said she “is not sick”.

Dr Lim Huiyu, senior resident at Tan Tock Seng Hospital’s department of gastroenterology and hepatology who examined Ms Thelma in April this year, testified in court today that she suffered “significant weight loss due to insufficient intake of food”.  The doctor added that Ms Thelma was so malnourished that she did not have her period for a year.

Ms Thelma weighed merely 43kgs at a review conducted in June, two months after her escape in April. She was later allowed to be re-hired as a domestic worker under a new employer after months being taken care by HOME.

The couple was later decided to plead guilty after a highly publicised three-day trial in December last year. It revealed that their domestic worker was provided with two meals a day.

The court heard that the first meal consisted of two to three slices of white bread and one to two packets of instant noodles, and at times, a slice of tomato or cucumber and a small piece of meat. The second meal would include just five to six slices of white bread.

A three-day Newton hearing was held in October for psychiatrists from both sides to testify as to Chong’s mental condition. This hearing was held to resolve disputed points for sentencing

Both parties agreed then that Chong suffers from OCD. This results in an obsession with cleanliness and a fear of dirt and contamination. The hearing also concluded that she also retains a residual dysfunctional attitude towards food and nutrition after she was diagnosed with anorexia nervosa as a teenager.

However, District Judge Low found that Chong’s OCD or attitude towards food did not bear any causal link to her committing the offence. It also did not impair her ability to understand the nature of her actions.

He then noted that there was also no evidence that her OCD extended to the obsession and compulsion to restrict the quantity of food for the victim.

The Judge remarked that Chong’s preoccupation with cleanliness would have affected only the type of food she chose to provide, such as foods that did not require much cooking, saying, that it does not explain why she restricted both the type and quantity of food she gave to her victim.

Judge Low stated that there is no evidence of a scientific nature that Chong’s underlying mental disorder can manifest in completely different treatment and outcomes for different parties, which was starving and depriving Ms Thelma of food while feeding more and nutritionally better food to her family.

He added that the contrasting manifestations of (Chong’s) conduct stem from and reflect a selective and discriminatory perception of the victim, and are not related to an underlying disorder.

Judge Low said that some “closure” could be obtained from the remarks made by the Institute of Mental Health’s psychiatrist Stephen Phang during the Newton hearing as members of the public then question what could have caused Chong’s offending behaviour.

Dr Phang, who testified for the prosecution, said, “If I may venture, that the starving of the maid probably emanates from what would likely have been essentially very ordinary, non-pathological. Normal emotions such as normal frustrations and normal anger, so on and so forth. But this is in the realm of speculation.”

Chong and Lim are expected to be sentenced on 23 February. If found guilty, the couple could be jailed up to 12 months and/or fined up to S$10,000.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

受害者包括我国少年 旅居狮城澳洲男子性侵47男童

一名旅居本地的澳大利亚籍男子波利斯(Boris Kunsevitsky),于昨日在澳洲墨尔本维多利亚高庭承认多项罪状,包括25宗在澳洲以外多地与孩童发生性行为,以及12项诱拐儿童发生性行为、拍摄儿童色情等罪状。 当地媒体谴责波利斯为该国迄今为止最严重的性犯罪者,将面临数十年的监禁,目前仍待法庭判刑。 波利斯2000年至2017年在新加坡工作,也以公干名义频繁到东南亚各国走动。他被指16年来,向至少47名男孩伸魔爪。 其中他还拍摄3千300张照片以及和至少25名受害者发生性关系的视频,并将之放上网。 波利斯今年52岁,波利斯出生于俄罗斯,在12岁迁居澳洲。 受害的儿童年龄介于10-15岁,大部分受害儿童来自菲律宾贫穷阶层、一名来自印尼、澳洲、甚至还包括本国男童。 德国警方在网上发现波利斯的视频,通知澳洲警方,后者于2016年展开调查。 2017年,波利斯回国探亲时遭当局拦截,并从其手机搜出证据,为此警方不准被告回到新加坡,并决定将他在新加坡的个人物件运回澳洲。 警方从被告的笔记型电脑和两个硬盘,发现被告最早从2001年开始摄录视频,此外,还下载3万7000其他受害者遭性虐的视频与照片。 借公干为名展开“性旅程” 当地法庭被告知波利斯被捕后确诊有恋童癖,一开始以销售工作为由,之后代表医疗设备公司到东南亚多国公干,实则进行“性旅游”。…

NSP on the Safety of Public Transport

MEDIA RELEASE ~ National Solidarity Party’s Letter to the Ministry of Transport…

【选举】阮建平:应设社会安全网 收入不均致使国人贫穷

前进党蔡厝港集选区候选人阮建平指出,虽说我国是第一世界的国家,但是从资产角度来看,遗憾的是有好一部分国人,却形同“第三世界国家”公民,更指数据显示,我国有超过10万户家庭、约30万人生活在贫困中。 “基本上,这是不对的。一个繁荣的国家,怎么会这么贫困呢?” 他指出,新加坡有严重的收入不平等问题,而且没有强大的社会安全网。 该党认为,应该花更多的资金来“投资”一个强大的社会安全网。“我们本来可以采用政府所提供,诸如医疗保险配套之类的配套。这有助于缓解并给他们更多的机会,让他们实际上有资源去实行其他东西。” 最低薪金增加社会流动 工人党盛港集选区候选人林志蔚指出,“社会流动(social mobility)中很大一部分”正在确保政府照顾那些已经为国家经济和社区做出多年贡献的人们。“对我们来说,看到年长者必须工作才能(保持)收入平衡,是一种罪过。” 他重申,类似最低薪金般的要素将促使国内社会流动的增加。 增加社会流动的另一种方法,就是确保“非精英学校”的学校,能够获得不成比例的更高教育支出。他也质疑减少学校班级规模的措施,因为这简直就是好像在惩罚大班的学生,因为他们被迫报名私人补习班。 奋斗和就业是最好的解决方案 针对其他候选人的观点,行动党武吉知马候选人维文表示,政府已经努力在减少贫困家庭。“我们不相信阶级斗争,不相信阶级斗争应由富有人家吸纳,我们坚信透过奋斗,尤其是较贫困、最贫困阶级的人们,才能实现你们所渴望的机会平等景象。” 至于教育和学校课题,他认为“精英等称号”并不是问题,要是所有学校都是好学校才是焦点。“那不是一个口号,而是看我们对学校做出的实际投资。”…

公司要享有全年招聘奖励? 杨莉明:需保有超过10本地员工

人力部长杨莉明昨指出,若公司希望享有12个月的招聘奖励计划(Jobs Growth Incentive),就必须保有超过10名本地员工。 有关奖励计划,是由副总理兼经济政策统筹部长及财政部长王瑞杰,于周一发布,这项总值10亿元的计划,旨在鼓励有潜能、前景的企业聘用本地员工。 谈及企业获得有关奖励计划的条件,她举例,一家公司在1月至8月期间,平均要保有10名本地员工。若该公司在9月份新招聘两名员工,那么在首5000元的新员工薪金中,公司将会获得长达12个月的25巴仙薪金援助。若员工年龄在40岁或以上,有关的薪金援助将增加一倍,至50巴仙。 但是,在获得有关奖励计划的公司,必须确保本地员工数量超过10人。 员工流失将影响奖励巴仙率 她在脸书帖文中指出,奖励计划也会随着原本团队中的10名本地员工流失,而出现变动。“这很公平,因为公司不会从替换员工中受惠。” 杨莉明解释道,若原本的10名员工中有人被解雇,而公司聘请新员工替代,奖励计划的薪金援助将会减少。公司仍可享有新员工的薪金援助,但是对新员工的薪金援助巴仙率将有所减少。 “我们将在本月内发布更多详情,以帮助雇主了解招聘奖励计划。” 她指出,随着新加坡逐步开放经济和边界,某些行业的复苏会比其他行业来得快,而某些行业则有可能完全转型。“这意味着,即使某些领域会出现失业者,某些领域会出现新空缺。在增长领域中,我们希望雇主招聘和培训新加坡人。” 而有了招聘奖励计划,相关领域的公司还可以从中省下客观的金额,让他们在扩大人力和提前招聘上取得优势。“毕竟这是我国自冠状病毒19对经济领域带来重创后,有史以来最大的推动计划。”