Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong on Tuesday emphasised the need for Singapore’s legislature to have a “much more cautious approach towards social issues” – such as LGBT equality and same-sex marriage – compared to the US, whose recent Supreme Court (SCOTUS) ruling made same-sex marriage legal across all states.

“It is nine men. And the nine men decide the important issues. And in this case it was 5 to 4. So actually one man decided the issue. But that is their system. … It is how they resolve social, political, economic, racial, all kinds of important issues. Congress, the parliament, doesn’t have the last word, it goes to the Supreme Court,” he said of the SCOTUS ruling while speaking at the Ho Rih Hwa Leadership in Asia Public Lecture Series organised by the Singapore Management University.

“It is not our system. Our system the parliament decides. The executive, through the Parliament, takes the lead, legislates, and legislates on behalf of the population,” he added.

PM Lee then reiterated his previous stance on LGBT equality, saying that Singapore is “really a conservative population” and that it is necessary to “let the views evolve with time.”

“I think that we have to have a good sense of the ground, a good sense of how people feel, and reflect the values and attitudes of the population, rather than try to impose your own on them,” he said.

“I think he was able to say this because the courts have hitherto been reluctant to engage in a robust form of judicial review, preferring instead to defer to the political branches of government (the executive and legislature),” said Dr Jack Lee, an assistant professor of law at SMU.

“It comes down to how the court sees its role. [The ruling for the constitutional challenge to Section 377A] shows the court feels that its job is only to find the most egregious breaches of fundamental liberties to be unconstitutional. So long as the government comes up with at least one reason for a law which the court regards as not arbitrary (a standard very favourable to the Government), the law will be regarded as constitutional,” Dr Lee added.

“Personally, I think the court ought to play a larger role in protecting minority rights, and subject legislation and executive action to more stringent scrutiny. After all, it is theoretically a co-equal branch of government, and supposed to exercise judicial review to ensure that the Constitution is upheld. This is particularly important for minorities as the Government arguably has less interest in enacting laws that would benefit them,” Dr Lee said.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Indian national air-con repairman from ST Synthesis with S$800 monthly salary gets 10 days’ jail for negligently causing fire at police HQ

A 30-year-old air-conditioner repairman from India has been sentenced to 10 days’…

阿兹敏否认涉及性爱短片 两小时后再传出次轮“爆料”

马来西亚男男性爱短片传出后,原产业副部长三苏依斯干达的高级机要秘书哈兹阿兹(Haziq Aziz)昨天凌晨在脸书上承认自己是其中一人,更指经济事务部长阿兹敏是另一人。阿兹敏较后于昨午5时否认了有关的指控,但是在他刚刚做出否认的两小时后,第二轮的性爱短片和照片又在WhatsApp群组中散布。 在面对众多争议后,阿兹敏终于在昨日下午5时20分发表文告,强烈否认涉及有关短片,更怒斥这是一场政治阴谋。 怒斥为政治阴谋 他指出,有关诽谤是一场策划了数个月的恶意阴谋,旨在破坏其声誉,推翻并摧毁他的政治生涯。 他在有关文告中也提到,他和家人的安全在斋戒月的最后一周频频受到威胁,不断被他人指责涉及贪污。因此他有理由相信,这项阴谋在数个月就已经展开了。 他表示将通过正当法律途径对付并揭发涉及此阴谋的人士,已经指示律师对作出有关恶意指责人士采取行动。 他也表示,相信警方和反贪会会采取必要的行为,并认为类似手段应该杜绝于新马来西亚时代。 至于目前,他将不会对任何要转移其视线的人认输,仍然会注重在推行稳定经济发展政策。 安华同情阿兹敏经历 人民公正党则针对此事件,于当天下午5时30分召开了政治局会。此外,公正党领袖都促请各界及党员们,停止散播和议论有关的短片。 多名政党领袖都抵达公正党总部,惟阿兹敏没有现身。…

Heng Swee Keat: Singapore must make sure government spending remains sustainable even as needs grow

Finance Minister Heng Swee Keat in his speech at the Straits Times…

The 5 stars of our flag

Defining the values reflected on our flag. What do these value mean to you? How would you interpret democracy, peace, progress, justice and equality, represented by the 5 stars on our flag?