ravi and roy

Human Rights Lawyer, M Ravi takes issues with press statement released by the press secretary of Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong in relation to the on-going defamation suit between PM Lee and Roy Ngerng.

It was reported in Channel News Asia that Ms Chang Li Lin, the Press Secretary to PM Lee, issued the following statement on Monday (Jan 12) in response to media queries,

“At the hearing today, the Judge ordered that the total costs to be paid by the Defendant to the Plaintiff be fixed at $29,000.  This amount is for the legal fees and related expenses incurred up to the conclusion of the application for summary judgement. The dates for the subsequent hearings are not confirmed.

“Mr Ngerng’s lawyer indicated at the hearing that Mr Ngerng did not want to be cross-examined.  The judge directed his lawyer to confirm whether he would be giving evidence by 30 January 2015. PM Lee stands ready to be cross-examined, a position he has earlier communicated to the Court”.

M Ravi, representing lawyer for Mr Ngerng in the defamation suit launched by PM Lee last year, said that the above statement by the press secretary is an inaccurate statement, and that she has been misinformed.

He said that on the issue of Mr Ngerng’s giving of evidence, his recollection is that “when asked, I would take instructions.”

He clarified that it is common and normal practice when a question as to a client’s current intention is asked by the Court. It means that a lawyer will always first verify whether his client will or will not be taking certain action. It carries no assertion either way.

“If my instructions had been that my client did not wish to give evidence and I had indeed conveyed that fact to the Court, it would have been illogical for the learned Judge to have asked me to confirm this by 30 January 2015. This  highlights the absurdity of your statement.” wrote M Ravi. “Obviously you did not intend to make this error. Indeed, it is inconceivable that you would wish, as the Prime Minister’s press secretary to be on record as misrepresenting the facts, however innocently.”

M Ravi added that the correct position for the press secretary to have taken would be “that Mr Ngerng’s lawyer indicated at the hearing that he would be taking instructions on whether  Mr Ngerng would be giving evidence.”

He also brought up a question about why is the press secretary to the Prime Minister issuing press releases on behalf of PM Lee who is filing the law suit in his personal capacity.

“Incidentally, as this is purportedly a private law suit brought by the Prime Minister in his personal capacity, can you explain why you as a Civil Servant holding the official title of Press Secretary to the Prime Minister would be issuing press releases on behalf of a private litigant? I ask this in all earnestness in order to understand whether you intend me to understand that the real Plaintiff is the Prime Minister in his capacity as Prime Minister.”

The court has ruled in a closed door hearing on Monday that Roy Ngerng to pay S$29,000 in total for legal fees and filing cost to PM Lee’s lawyer for summary judgment ruling on the defamation suit between Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong and Roy Ngerng.

Mr Ngerng, is being sued by Mr Lee in his personal capacity for a series of articles which had accused Mr Lee of “criminal misappropriation” of Singaporeans’ Central Provident Fund (CPF) monies, said Mr Lee’s lawyers, by comparing the management of CPF monies by the Government Investment Corporation of Singapore – or GIC Pte Ltd – with the corruption trial of leaders of the City Harvest Church.

Hearing of the assessment of damages for the defamation is expected to take place over 4 continuous days in late June, with cross examination of all witnesses in open Court.

Subscribe
Notify of
16 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

两车相撞毁大厦外墙! 所幸两名司机仅轻伤

今日(6日)上午,莱佛士广场地铁站的AIA大厦外发生骇人车祸,两辆轿车相撞并撞毁大厦墙壁,墙瓦脱落,其中一辆车子更是侧翻,场面如同动作电影场景。 所幸两名司机均属轻伤,62岁德士司机在意识清醒下被送往新加坡中央医院,而另为男性司机则被现场医护人员救治,惟拒绝进一步到医院接受治疗。 该起车祸发生在今早10点前,车祸发生后,立即被路人拍摄下来上传至网络,迅速引起网民疯传。 从照片上可见,一辆蓝色相信是德士的轿车与银色的私家车撞上,德士内已弹出安全气囊,而银色车子侧翻,救难人员需从车子的另一边将受害者救出。 此外,大厦的状况也可见损毁不少,墙瓦脱落,可见当时冲击力不小,但目测并未伤及大厦的主要架构。 警方表示,事故仍在侦办中。 网友EstherTan :我的天啊!我希望他们都能够平安,AIA大厦要再次检查,万一内部有裂痕呢 部分网民则形容整个场景如同香港电影般刺激,有些人更称像是看了一场成龙的电影 网友Eric Chia :很赞的场景,好像那些香港电视剧…

14 new cases of confirmed Zika-infection brings locally infected cases to 355

The National Environment Agency (NEA) stated that there were 14 new cases…

Signalling fault causes delays on North-South Line; commuters advised to make alternative travel arrangements

A signalling fault has resulted delays along the North-South MRT Line during…

Zoom releases 27-inch touchscreen display “Zoom for Home” for remote workers

One of the main transitions the world is observing in 2020 is…