Press release by the National Solidarity Party (NSP).

Response to “NSP’s white-collar job idea won’t work: Gan” in the Straits Times, 23 April 2011


23 April 2011

I refer to the article “NSP’s white-collar job idea won’t work: Gan” in the Straits Times, 23 Apr 2011.

Responding to our proposal to increase the Employment Pass (EP) threshold salary to $4000 from the current $2800, Mr Gan said that “many better educated Singaporeans, especially at the higher-income level, are in jobs that don’t face local competition, but competition with companies and enterprises around the world.”  He seemed to be confused.  It is the companies that face competition with other companies around the world, not the jobs themselves.  Whether Singaporeans face local or global competition in employment is determined purely by our manpower policies on foreign employees.  I shall presume he meant the companies.

Our  proposal to increase the EP threshold affects jobs paying between $2800 to $4000.  It ensures that 75% of the jobs at these salary levels go to Singaporeans.  The Minister implied that by doing so, the competitiveness of the companies would be compromised.  Why would he think that?  Is he implying that Singaporeans are unable to do these jobs as well as foreigners?  If so, he should have a good chat with the Minister for Education.   If it is a matter of not enough Singaporeans wanting to fill those jobs, then we have provided for a higher quota upon application and assessment.   Foreign talents would not be affected since they would presumably be paid above $4000.

Mr Gan reiterated the stand of using training to enhance earnings.  We have had training for blue and white collar workers for many years but have not seen any improvements in our national wage levels.  If we are wrong about this, we would love to see statistics on the number of people trained under the various approved training programmes over the last 10 years, the amount of money spent, and how all their wages have progressed over the past 10 years, not just anecdotes of success cases.

It is our view that the incentives for productivity-enhancement would have limited success and the tightening of EP requirements does not go far enough.  We disagree that our current approach is “comprehensive”, nor is it “more effective”, as stated by Mr Gan.

The pain felt by many Singaporeans is real, and should be taken more seriously.  We cannot hide behind an unemployment rate of 2.2% and adamantly overlook underemployment.  With little social safety net in place, most Singaporeans would be forced to take up any job just to pay bills.  The so-called “full employment” situation could actually be the result of the cost pressures we are facing.  We need to look further into the situation and not be blinded by one single piece of statistics. Only then could we have a truly “comprehensive” approach. The NSP regrets that it is currently unable to do more than raise the issue due to a lack of publicly available data as well as a lack of resources to launch further, comprehensive studies to investigate the extent and severity of the underemployment situation.


Hazel Poa

CEC member, Spokesperson,

National Solidarity Party


Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Kim Jong-un’s half-brother takes refuge in S’pore and Malaysia

Kim Jong-nam, the elder half-brother of North Korean supreme leader Kim Jong-un,…

6th death from COVID-19 infection confirmed by MOH; 88-yr-old patient was admitted on 30 March

The Ministry of Health (MOH) has confirmed that a patient has passed…


卫生部在昨晚(27日)发声明,指截至昨日下午2时,该部确认本地再一起新型冠状病毒病例,患者为一名56岁中国籍女子,目前已在国家传染病中心隔离,情况稳定。 这意味着迄今为止本地累积的已知确认病例多达五宗。 根据卫生部文告,上述女子是在本月18日,与家人一同飞抵新加坡,当时未出现任何症状,直至本月24日出现新型冠状病毒症状,并在26日送往陈笃生医院,先被列为疑似病例,并且立即在国家传染病中心隔离。 至本月27日,当局经调查确诊该名女子为第五起病例。不过他与此前四起确诊病例都没有任何关联。 入院前该名中国女性曾入住家属在锡兰路(Ceylon Road)的住家。自24日出现症状以来,该名女性都留在家中,直至26日才送往医院。据了解当局已启动追踪曾与病例接触的人士。 另一方面,卫生部也称截至27日中午12时,有62宗疑似病例经测试得阴性反应,仍有57宗疑似病例仍待调查结果。 卫生部已确认多达115人曾于确诊病例有近距离接触。其中86人仍在新加坡,当局已联系其中75人并予以隔离。当局仍持续寻找其余11人。 当局早前劝国民避开前往中国湖北或中国大陆的非必要行程;此外如返回狮城后出现不适症状,应立即就医。如出现发烧或出现呼吸道症状(例如咳嗽,呼吸急促),则应戴口罩并在就诊前致电诊所。 旅客和公众应始终采取以下预防措施: 避免接触、食用生禽、野味等家禽和鸟类,特别是食用生肉和未煮熟的肉; 避免与身体不适或有疾病症状的人密切接触;…

Do Singaporeans actually not want a non-Chinese PM or is it the PAP that’s not ready?

Based on a survey conducted in 2016, Deputy Prime Minister Tharman Shanmugaratnam…