The following is an excerpt of an article posted on blog Give Life A 2nd Chance.

M Ravi in Second Chances in the Park

Published at East Asian Law Journal, Vol. 1 No. 2

By M. Ravi, Practitioner at L.F. Violet Netto, Lawyer for Yong Vui Kong and Alan Shadrake; Co-author Choo Zheng Xi

Overview: harsh substantive law unsupported by criminological statistics

Systematic penalogical data is hard to come by in Singapore, which has led the immediate past president of the Singapore Law Society to lament that “Singapore is sadly lacking a principled and transparent penal Policy because Government has not published detailed statistics of crime and punishment”.[1]  Neither of Singapore’s two universities offering law degrees have a department of criminology in their law faculties.

This statistical lacunae of general criminological data is alarming, but is rendered exponentially more egregious when one considers the most controversial application of the death penalty in Singapore: that trafficking in more than a quantity of drugs prescribed in the Schedule of the Misuse of Drugs Act is sufficient for a man to hang. The uniquely draconian nature of Singapore’s “Misuse of Drugs Act” deserves some elucidation.

The first aspect of the death penalty for drug trafficking in Singapore is that it attracts not just the possibility of a sentence of death, but the mandatory death penalty.

Secondly, the mandatory nature of the death penalty for trafficking is coupled with a presumption of trafficking in cases of possession.[2] This reverses the basic principle of criminal law that a charge must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt for conviction to follow.

To read on, click here.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Of eggs and baskets

If I were a PAP campaign strategist (which I am obviously not…

陈清木、李显扬等政治领袖出席网络公民募款晚宴

为应付即将来临选举的运营开销,网络公民在昨晚6时30分,于新置地大厦举办募款晚宴,获得众多在野党领袖、社运分子和本社读者踊跃出席。 出席者包括新加坡前行动党议员、新加坡前进党创党人陈清木医生,总理弟弟李显扬伉俪、工人党秘书长毕丹星、议员吴佩松、贝理安、严燕松、民主党主席徐顺全、副主席陈两裕、秘书长淡马亚、人民党蒙巴登选区潜在候选人张媛容、人民之声党领袖林鼎等政治领袖,以及知名时评人兼人民之声党影子财政部长梁实轩、人权律师M Ravi、时评人暨律师裘佐柏(Khush Chopra)、律师朱正熙、社运分子范国瀚等及本社读者,现身晚宴,令活动现场增添光彩。 本社总编许渊臣感谢各界人士踊跃出席。一开始以为反映不如预期,但后来越来越多人踊跃询问购票,且最终晚宴得以圆满成功。 他说,虽然仍未能筹足未来三个月运营的经费,惟昨晚的晚宴活动,让所有志同道合之士齐聚一堂,建立更稳健的联系。 “对于无法出席但仍购票支持的热心人士,我们致以诚挚谢意,您们的支持对于我们正在进行的工作,实在意义重大。 也感谢促使活动圆满成功的各界人士,包括提供晚宴膳食的厨房、协助登记和发出募款晚宴邀请的志愿者。” 工人党秘书长毕丹星也在脸书留言表示,网络媒体空间仍是充满挑战的领域,网媒创办人或主编往往没有主流媒体那般的丰厚资源,但是,人民对于有素质新闻报导仍有要求。 “无论大家对网络公民看法如何–它在新加坡传媒领域扮演的独特角色是无可估量的,即便是最为激烈的批评者看来,也是相当积极的。对于认真看待参与式民主的积极公民,以及意识到信息自由流通的重要,网络公民发挥着重要作用。” 他认为,网络媒体必须持续求存,特别是主流媒体可能基于某些因素不会涵盖某些课题。毕丹星指出,包括贝理安、陈立峰、 严燕松和吴佩松等工人党领袖,都慷慨解囊襄助网络公民募款活动。…

五房式组屋也可参与屋契回购计划

针对总理李显龙在国庆群众大会发表的政策,国家发展部长黄循财在昨日也作出回应,表示该部探讨推出短期计划,例如在屋契回购计划下,让住户可出售部分屋契套现,但仍积蓄住在现有组屋。 黄循财在题为《提前规划下阶段公共住房政策》的博文中,指出李显龙在国庆群众大会提出规划性提升旧租屋,意即翻新或重新规划旧组屋市镇,都是数十年推行的长期计划。 黄循财赞许我国公共住宅政策取得成功,多年来提供国人优质房屋。当前,针对现有人口年龄变化和建筑物屋龄增涨,当局也计划把公共住宅政策推向新阶段。 国家发展部则顺应现有发展,推出短期计划,特别是协助乐龄住户为他们的组屋解锁更多价值。 “今天,许多年长住户选择出租部分房间来增加收入。一些则选择卖掉现有组屋,在乐龄安居花红下该住较小型住宅。” 提升旧组屋在转售市场价值 对此,黄循财说当局正寻求如何提升旧组屋在转售市场的流通性。 当局将于公积金局局探讨,改善一些机制,提供更多弹性给想购买屋契年龄短组屋的买家。与此同时,确保他们有足够的退休金。 当前,我们可用公积金购买旧组屋,不过为了确保买家购买终身房屋,同时不影响个人退休积蓄,为此仍有设定某些限制。 住户也可出售部分屋契套现,但同时还是能积蓄住在现有组屋。 黄循财认为,屋契回购计划过去只针对四房式组屋和小型组屋。然而, 一些长者希望能在原有组屋终老,或是希望子孙来探望时,能在更宽敞的空间与家人团聚。…