From Asia Sentinel

The bull market tide goes out, leaving the lion city’s sovereign wealth firm gasping on the shore.

Nearly five months after its March 31 year-end, Singaporeans should be eagerly looking forward to the publication of the report of the guardian of so much of the national wealth, Temasek Holdings. The sovereign wealth fund run by Ho Ching, wife of Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, is not the biggest repository of money collected by the state on behalf of the people, but it is at least semi-transparent compared with its big brother the Government Investment Corp.

The lengthy wait for results could possibly be connected to issues of how to treat a series of rather spectacular disasters that Temasek faced last year, and that are continuing into the current year.

Even in 2006-07, when world markets were booming in unison, Temasek had to report a 29 percent profit fall. Neither chairman S. Dhanabalan nor Ho Ching were on hand at the press conference when these dismal results were delivered. So who will deliver any bad news for the latest year?

Of course, the bottom line for the year to March 2008 may be saved by the sale just before year-end of power station Tuas Power to China’s Huaneng Group for S$4.2 billion which should enable it to book a hefty capital profit. But selling local assets and buying foreign ones may not be such a smart idea, particularly if you are the kind of Singapore bureaucrat who has implicit faith in the masters of the universe on Wall Street.

Under Ho Ching’s leadership Temasek had supposedly been taken from being a safety-first bureaucracy to a smart, profit-oriented outfit, selling some assets and investing heavily overseas, particularly in the fast-growing emerging markets of Asia and Latin America. Almost fool can make money in a global bull market so for awhile Temasek seemed to prosper under Ho Ching’s dynamic leadership. But Temasek also swallowed plenty of bait on offer from Wall Street types.

In particular the government-owned investment vehicle vastly expanded its finance sector portfolio, buying banks and even setting up a Special Purpose Vehicle, Astrea, which borrowed US$810 million to invest in a slew of private equity and buyout funds.

It is hard to imagine that Astrea has avoided the hammering suffered by almost all buyout and private equity funds, some of which have had to close with large losses.

But Temasek seems to have compounded bull market errors by continuing to have faith in Wall Street deceptions when memory of the Asian crisis and the Japanese experience should have made it particularly aware that financial-sector problems almost always go deeper and last longer than those in other sectors. Temasek was keen to show how important it was so was among the first to jump in with equity bail-outs for distressed western banks, firstly with US$5 billion for Merrill Lynch at $48 a share.

The Merill shares are now worth about half that, and although under the terms of the deal Temasek has been partially compensated with additional shares it has had to also to put in new money – and must wonder just how long and deep the US financial crisis will be. Although it had recently increased its stake in the UK’s Standard Chartered, it also put ₤1 billion into Britain’s Barclays, a financial institution whose equity base remains perilously small compared with the weight of assorted instruments it carries and whose share price has fallen much further since the Temasek injection.

But it is not just the finance sector and in the west that gung-Ho Temasek has hit rough waters. The Shin Corp mess in Thailand may now be a thing of the past. But troubles elsewhere are many. In Indonesia it is being required to sell off its stake in Bank International Indonesia (BII) because it already owns Bank Danamon. But Malaysia’s Bank Negara (central bank) has vetoed an attempt by Maybank to buy the BII stake. Bank Negara evidently agreed with opinion in the market that Maybank was offering a silly price.

The best piece of luck Temasek has had was actually evidence of its own willingness to pay top dollar. Only the myopic greed of shareholders in China Eastern Airlines and hopes of a counter offer from China National Aviation Corp thwarted a generous joint offer by Temasek and Singapore Airlines for a 24 percent stake in the Hong Kong-listed company at HK$3.8 a share. They now trade at HK$1.80.

Real estate is not looking too hot either. Last month CapitalLand (part of the Temasek group) had to promise to inject A$300 million into its ailing listed Australian 54 percent owned subsidiary Australand Property. Without a huge capital injection, deeply indebted Australand might have gone under.

Temasek has also leaped heavily into one of China’s highest profile, and perhaps more vulnerable, property developers, Country Garden. When it went public in Hong Kong in April 2007, Country Garden was the second largest IPO in Hong Kong history, with Temasek joining local tycoons Lee Shau Kee and Robert Kuok as key investors. According to the mainland financial magazine Caijing, a subsequent S$800 million convertible bond issue in Singapore in February this year was made on terms which suggest the company is very stretched and badly needs to keep its share price from falling. It is now little more than half its initial price and down 75 percent from its peak.

Australia, once seen as a safe if unexciting location for Singapore cash, has also attracted top of the market deals from Singapore Power. Already well-established in Australia, it paid heavily in cash for the eastern Australia assets of pipeline company Alinta but with values in decline they have been unable now to flip them into their 51 percent owned local subsidiary SP Ausnet leaving SP meanwhile saddled with huge borrowings.

Even on home ground, things are looking sick for important parts of the Temasek empire. Chartered Semiconductor Industries has seen its shares fall more than 40 percent and its debt ratings have been cut so that its bond are no longer investment grade – otherwise known as junk status. Chartered has long been a state effort to make Singapore a semiconductor manufacturing leader but has never managed to keep up with the likes of Taiwan and Korea in technology and now also faces Chinese competition.

These various problems have not entirely dulled Temasek’s appetite for acquisitions. Its associate Neptune Orient Lines (NOL) is bidding to buy Germany’s Hapag-Lloyd just at a time when some commentators forecast huge problems looming for container lines. This time Temasek may be saved by German nationalism – Hamburg business is ganging up to keep it in local hands.

It remains to be seen who, if anyone, takes responsibility for Temasek’s blunders. Last year it was chief investment officer Jimmy Phoon who found he had better things to do, as did Jackson Tai at DBS, Temasek’s main banking investment, and the finance director of SembCorp who had landed the group with US$300 million in foreign exchange losses.

Meanwhile US former food and consumer products executive Simon Israel, appointed two years ago, remains CEO in conjunction with Ho Ching. And, despite everything, faith in Wall Street types is as strong as ever – Michael Dee from Morgan Stanley was last week been appointed managing director for international investments.


Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like


国家发展部长黄循财在博客发贴文,建屋发展局将提供公共组屋买家另一选项,从今年中开始,买家可透过“剩余组屋再销售活动”(Re-offer of Balance Flats,简称ROF),随时上网申请该活动中未售出的组屋,并在下一个工作日就订购。 届时,将有120个剩余组屋单位可供申购。该销售活动采先到先得制,买家可随时上网申请,并在下个工作日预订,让买家等候订购组屋的时间减少至一日。 黄循财也表示,每年约有两万新加坡家庭向建屋局买房。当中有许多是透过预购组屋(BTO)或剩余组屋销售活动(SBF)申购。 他指出,在2017年,建屋局推出ROF,将所有剩余组屋单位进行集中抽签,让买家在申购阶段无须注明想买的组屋屋型和地点。这有利于那些不太在意地点及其他组屋特点,而是急需住屋的买家。 黄循财认为,ROF相当受欢迎,自推出以来已有2500户家庭透过此销售活动订购组屋,其中近三分之二已领取组屋钥匙。 为急需房子者提供选项 他表示,目前剩余组屋再销售活动ROF,将每年推出两次。建屋局未来仍会进行检讨更佳方案,让潜在买家能更方便地买到ROF剩余组屋。 “随着可供选择范围的增加,我希望潜在买家能够更轻松,更方便地找到能满足他们不同需求、喜好和预算的公共组屋。” “剩余组屋再销售活动”对于正在找房子的国人来说,无疑是一项好消息,不过也有些网民也提出,过去申请预购组屋,也等了很久,如今建屋局却要开放申购剩余组屋。…

英相“放任式防疫”反其道而行? 英国民众吓到不敢出门

武汉冠状病毒(COVID-19)疫情肆虐全球,各国对于抗疫过程也绷紧神经,丝毫不敢松懈,采取颜值控管出入境、限制边境、甚至封国封城防疫,然而在英国却选择另类的防疫方式,一开始开启“放任式防疫”,即只有症状严重者才需要做筛检,不再计算感染人数,也不禁止大型集会活动,随即引起各界批评。 直到两天前(16日),英国首相鲍里斯·约翰逊才肯呼吁当地民众,减少非必要外出和与人接触;昨天宣布英国需像“战时政府”一样应对疫情,以及公布经济纾困计划。 目前英国已知确诊病例超过1960例,死亡人数60人。而当局以武汉冠病死亡率仅1巴仙为由,使用的“群体免疫”策略也引来医学界炮轰,但相信此举有助缓解因果医疗系统压力。 然而,在这样“放任式的防疫”下,有居住在英国的网友观察发现,这样的方式可能对英国民众反而凑效。 网友表示,他是从台湾搬到英国,所以也在观察两国的防疫设施,他发现两国的防疫措施上采取截然不同的方式。 对于台湾而言,在疫情开始时便积极准备,步步紧盯,对于每一例都紧密追踪,所以在过去两个与内,其防疫控管做得滴水不漏。 英国不停课、各行业照常营运、不检测 反观英国,在过去几周内确诊病例突然激增,却开始选择不作为的形式来选择防疫,即不取消任何聚会活动、不停课停班、各行各业照常营运、不做检测停止计算感染人数、生病自己在家休息不要到医院也不用通报的方式。 此言一出,也引发了英国陷入大恐慌,也掀起当地的抢购潮。 虽然招来很多的斥责但网友却表示,对于“耳朵一向很硬”,嘴里不停说该来的就会来、keep calm &…

半年来13工地接停工令 玛格烈通道工地爆56骨痛热症病例

女皇镇玛格烈通道一组屋工地内,有56名工人相继感染骨痛热症,承包商据悉已经被罚款扣分。此外,有13个工地在过去五个月,因有黑斑蚊滋生地而被下令停工。 环境局加强骨痛热症防疫措施,敦促建筑业给予合作,并且对没有妥善处理建筑工地环境问题,导致黑斑蚊滋生的建筑工地承包商采取严厉行动。有关的对付行动包括了发出停工指令,以及法院起诉。 被下令停工的工地,承包商必须采取必要的纠正行为,包括整理环境、清理杂草等,有效审查现场卫生和病媒控制程序后,才有可能获得撤除停工令。 截至目前为止,13个在过去五个月接收停工令的工地中,已有10个工地的停工令成功被撤除。 然而,玛格烈通道并不在撤除停工令行列内。截止星期一,已有56名来自该工地,在SkyResidence组屋工地工作并居住的外国客工的工人感染上蚊疫。环境局证实在重复稽查时,发现工地蚊虫大量滋生,因此发出停工令,要求该工地承包商采取行动。 其中一名被下令停工的工地主管表示,工地内至今已经有49人染病,接获停工令后暂停了所有工作,当前只能进行整理、收拾等防范工作。 对此,建屋局证实有关消息,并指相关承包商已经被罚款和记分,将会配合当局,一起执行严格的害虫控制和管理措施。 环境局表示在玛格烈通道被列为蚊疫黑区后,当局多次到场稽查并寻获七个黑斑蚊温床,包括在护土墙、金属模板、树洞和安全栅栏等。

TOC’s Exclusive Videos – Aware Extraordinary General Meeting

The TOC Media Team was at Suntec City to talk to participants. Here is the TOC video of the event.