Tan Kin Lian / Senior Writer

The Ministry of Transport is introducing a new fare system for public transport that is based on distance rather than the number of transfers. This will reduce one obstacle in the use of public transport, namely the high cost when several transfers are involved.

I hope that the change in system does not cost a large sum of money, as this will eventually be borne by the commuters through higher fares.

A simpler way is to increase the current rebate on transfers. This does not require a massive change to the fare computation system that needs to be installed on all the buses and train stations.

Feeder service

For a long time, commuters have complained about the long waiting time and the long traveling time to get a feeder bus to the train station.

Actually, feeder services are operated in only a few towns in Singapore. A large bus is used to operate this service. It has to take a winding route covering many streets in the town, to pick up sufficient passengers to collect enough fares to pay the operating expenses – leading to long traveling time.

For most parts of Singapore, there is no feeder service. The commuter has to take a bus service that happens to pass through the train station and the destination. This is usually a service that is intended to serve a larger part of Singapore. As this is a specialized service, it has a long waiting time of 7 to 15 minutes, depending on the time of day. If the bus does not keep to the schedule, the waiting time is longer.

If the bus is crowded, the commuter has to wait for the next bus, adding to the waiting time.

Mini-buses

A better system is to use mini-buses that serve an area of 1 or 2 km around a train station and bus interchange. There can be several services to serve different parts of this area, to reduce the traveling time. As the capacity of the mini-bus is small, there is no need for the mini-bus to make many stops to pick up sufficient passengers. This will reduce the traveling time.

With more mini-buses serving the commuters, the waiting time will also be reduced considerably. An accepted waiting time for a feeder service should be 3 to 5 minutes.

Many Singaporeans long for the old days, when “pirate taxis” offer a convenient low cost service in the rural parts of Singapore. These vehicles pick up and drop passengers anyway along a designated route. It is our “old day” version of the feeder service that I am now proposing.

Hong Kong

This service has been successfully operated in Hong Kong and other cities. A Singaporean friend sent this e-mail to me.

Hi Uncle Tan. I have just read your article on improving the Singapore transport system. I have been living in Hong Kong for almost 4 years and noticed that a few of your recommendations are actually live examples here, for e.g. the minibuses, trams and express buses….

I must say that the Hong Kong transport system is very good. Of the two offices I used to work in, scheduled buses brought me to work with door-to-door convenience… minibuses gave me short traveling time at a fraction of what a taxi ride would cost.

And the express buses are great…. not to mention the cheap trams (at less than SG 40 cents) which give you the ease of hoping on and off along the main arteries in Central….

And there is one more thing that I should add… something that was not in your article…. condominiums here have their own shuttle bus services… they are affordable and provide express transport for residents who live further away from the main centre of activity such as Central.

My baby is one year old and I decided to move to Lantau for its open spaces and greenery… the distance is long… (i am almost at the HK airport) …but the shuttle bus brings me to work within 45 minutes … when i was living in Mid-levels… it was even better… no more than 30 minutes… and if its winter… i could even use the escalator…which is free!

Express bus

I wish now to talk about the express bus service that I have proposed. An express service makes only a few stops along the journey. This will reduce the traveling time considerably. The express bus does not have to make many stops to pick up individual passengers, as this function can be left to the feeder service.

When I was in New York twenty years ago, I learned that there are express trains that stop every 3 to 5 stations and local trains that stop at every station. This reduces the traveling time for people taking the express train. A commuter can take the express train for most of the journey and switch to a local train for the final leg. As the transfer is made on the same platform, it is quite convenient for the commuters.

Some of the express bus services can operate on the same routes as the train to offer an alternative to the commuters. This will increase competition and spur the train operator to improve its customer service, such as providing more frequent trains and avoid over-crowding. They can serve as a backup to the train service in the event of a breakdown or accident involving the train.

Other express services can connect the towns directly and offer a shorter traveling distance for the commuters.

Transfers

It is important that the transfer should be made at the same platform or involves a short walking distance. The feeder bus should bring commuters directly to the train station or to the boarding point of the feeder bus.

I hope that these suggestions, which are simple and relatively inexpensive to implement, can improve the public transport in Singapore considerably.

—————-

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Chiam See Tong: We have no ill intentions towards the ex-CEC members

the following is a public statement by Mr Chiam See Tong: Some…

我国连任最适合孩童生活国家 惟网民提醒仍有压力、生活成本等挑战

新加坡连续第二年被评为世界上,最适合孩童生活的国家,但是并不是所有网民都认同。 据非政府组织,“拯救儿童会”(Save The Children)今天发布的《全球年度报告》(Global Childhood Report),我国成功击败八个西欧国家和唯一一个进入前十名的亚洲国家–韩国后,成功从176个国家中,凭着为孩童提供的医疗保健、教育、营养和保安等方面脱颖而出。 我国在儿童年终指数的1000分中取得989分,在所有的八项指标,即根据五岁以下儿童死亡率、发育迟缓、剥夺教育权利、儿童劳役、早孕、童婚、儿童凶杀率以及因冲突致流离失所中,获得标青成绩。 去年,我国和斯洛文尼亚并列第一。 国家数据显示,2017年我国儿童死亡率为每千名活产婴儿中的2.8人,2016遍的儿童凶杀率为每10万名19岁以下人中有一人死亡。 新加坡“拯救儿童会”的亚洲区域主任哈山莫哈玛(Hassan Muhammad Saadi…

Always stand up for your rights: MRT hero who stood up to bully

The video which showed him standing up to a Caucasian bully has…

职总探讨设工作小组 助被裁PME更快找到工

全国职工总会秘书长黄志明称,职总将探讨设立一个工作小组,研究如何协助中年PME(专业人士、经理和执行人员),被裁退能更快找到工作。 他指出,有鉴于经济不确定因素下,40-50岁的PME对失去工作的焦虑增加,职总将设立一个工作小组,为年长雇员提供更好的保障。 也是总理公署部长的黄志明告知记者,尽管上述群体人数不多,但他们对就业前景感到担忧,若被下岗他们可能难以再寻到与之前相似的工作,结果有者只得成为德士或私召车司机。 为解决上述问题,黄志明表示工作小组将寻求与雇主合作,确保雇员能匹备必要的关键技能。 “我们能否重新思考保障的模式,包括与雇主合作看看如何在裁员前帮助那些员工,我想是可行的。”他说,企业仍信任工会,一些企业裁员前也会先通知职总,以安排雇员适应过渡期,配对到同产业领域工作,或培训后转行。 此外,他指出职总放眼在2025年招到150万会员,以巩固职工运动作为重要经济与社会支柱的角色。目前职总有95万名会员。 前日,总理李显龙则在职总四年一度全国代表大会上称,人民行动党政府重申对工友们的承诺,将一直与工友站在一起,保障他们的福祉。 他提及香港现今的处境,他认为全球化的新加坡面向世界不可能完全免疫于这类潜在的分裂力量。如果发生在我国,后果不堪设想,对新加坡的信任将毁于一旦。 而我国如何避免这种结果?其中一个关键基础是行动党和职总之间的紧密关系,而许多行动党议员,也是来自职总。再者,行动党致力促进工友的福祉和未来,包括房屋、医疗保健、教育、交通等等。