Andrew Loh

Reading about the Venerable Shi Ming Yi being charged for 10 counts of impropriety in handling funds collected through the Ren Ci charity organisation makes me very sad indeed. (Yahoo News)(CNA)

Venerable Ming Yi’s case follows that of Catholic priest Joachim Kang and the National Kidney Foundation’s (NKF) Chief Executive TT Durai. All three were trusted by members of the public and had collected millions in donations. Ren Ci and the NKF are two of the biggest and well-known charity organisations in Singapore.

While the monk’s guilt is yet to be ascertained, Durai and Kang were found guilty and were given prison sentences.

What is happening to our society, when even such men fail?

On 7 July 2008, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong called for more Singaporeans to “donate according to their means and from their heart”. He revealed that charitable donations to non-profit organisations (Institutions of Public Character) increased by more than 50 per cent to S$820 million last year. (PMO)

PM Lee said this tradition of philanthropy and volunteerism is needed to “keep our social fabric strong and vibrant”. However, with these recent cases of impropriety by the heads of charity organisations, one wonders if the ‘social fabric’ is being torn apart. Will Singaporeans’ generosity now be curtailed voluntarily? Will Singaporeans be more stingy in giving? Can we blame them if they are?

Part of that ‘social fabric’ is the trust and faith which the public places on the people who are responsible for handling public donations – donations which are meant for the needy.

Perhaps what is more significant, and which we should pay attention to, is whether these cases indicate something more deep-seated – that we have become a society where money is cherished above all else, even above the trust and faith which is freely and readily given.

But looking at things in perspective, there are many charity organisations in Singapore who are doing selfless work in helping the needy, the sick and the poor. Thus, it would be sad and inappropriate to tar all these organisations with the failings of the few.

Singaporeans should continue to give and support these organisations.

At the same time, the government and the relevant authorities should be ever vigilant in keeping an eye on these Institutions of Public Character. Here, I would like to commend the Health Ministry for its timely intervention and investigations into the affairs at Ren Ci last November, leading to the present charges against Venerable Ming Yi. The Health Minister, Khaw Boon Wan, should also be commended for his impartial handling of the case in its earliest stages. He had called for patience and fairness for Ren Ci and the individuals involved until the investigations were completed.

“It is important to let the investigators do their job. Let’s not speculate or jump to conclusions because that would not be fair to Ren Ci and the individuals involved”, he said. (Straits Times)

“I wanted to get to the bottom of it because if you leave it hanging and leave questions marks, it’s not fair to Ren Ci. Then people would jump to their own conclusions.” (Today)

Ren Ci’s two medical facilities – one at Buangkok View and the other at Jalan Tan Tock Seng – have a total of over 400 beds. A third hospital, being built near Tan Tock Seng Hospital, is due to be completed in September. The hospital is reported to be $4 million short of its target for the funds needed for this third hospital. The Straits Times said that “MOH is funding $21.04 million of the hospital’s construction costs, which come up to $30.8 million, according to previous reports.” (Straits Times)

While we may feel betrayed or angry over these cases, let us not forget the very good work which the other volunteers and staff at these organisations are doing, and there are many of them.

Yes, the heads of these institutions may have failed and abused the trust of the public but let us not forget that when we give or donate to these organisations, it is the needy, the sick and the poor that we are thinking of.

The onus is on the government to correct the shortcomings in the system which allows such abuse. For us, the public, we should question those who ask for our donations when we are approached.

But we should not stop giving.

For even if these few men fail, we ourselves must not fail those who need our help still.


Notify of
1 Comment
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

第四日搜救行动仍无果 泛舟失踪者家属盼狮城搜救队介入

趁着连假到马来西亚柔佛丰盛港参与泛舟活动的我国男女,至今已失踪超过四天,马国搜救队昨日扩大搜寻范围,并出动六单位108人展开海陆空搜救行动,惟截止昨晚仍然一无所获。这令失踪者家属心急如焚,认为马国搜救行动人手有限,盼望能让我国搜救队参与搜救行动。 马国海事局、警方、水警、民防部队和皇家海军等六单位联手于昨天早上展开搜救行动,救援队伍从早上的87人增加到下午的108人。 他们分别展开海陆空搜救行动,马国消拯局(BOMBA)和海事局一共出动了四架直升机和一家小型飞机进行空中搜寻,将搜救范围从原本的500平方海里扩大到900平方海里。 陆路上,当局出动了两辆休旅车、一辆罗厘和一辆救护车展开沿岸寻人行动,而在海上也有两艘海军军舰和五艘船只进行搜索,并将原本的150平方海里搜寻范围扩大到600平方海里。 马国海事局未接获出海申请 据悉,马国当局事前并没有接获泛舟一行人的出海申请,因此也无法在天气情况有变时给予提醒。 该国海事执法机构丰盛港主任哈里兹提醒民众,若要乘船登上其他岛屿或出发到公海,必须向当局做出通知,而当局也会在接获通知后,于巡逻时多加注意,并且在天气情况有变时给予建议。 我国驻新山总领事馆代表昨日也到丰盛港彭加梦码头,对失踪者家属进行慰问。 团友出发前察觉海浪很大 失踪的两人是同乘一艘双人独木舟的女商人潘玉珍(57岁)和退休律师陈永顺(62岁)。他们是和另外的13名团友一起,趁着国庆日和哈芝节,配合周末的连假,到柔佛丰盛港外岛泛舟,岂知遭强风吹散,自上周四(8日)傍晚5时40分失踪至今。 随同团员之一的一名工程师,56岁的郑先生于12日首次向媒体细说事发经过时指出,他们当时仅在岸上沟通会前行方向,但是在海上泛舟时确实没有沟通的。 他指出,用过午餐从小岛出发时,他就注意到海水波浪很大,船身不断遭两米高大浪拍打,以致划行变的困难。在努力朝向目的地划行中,他和队友根本无暇顾及他人,所以在成功登岸后才发现有两人没有跟上队伍。当时他们也因为海浪太大而受困岛上长达两个小时,惟最后都没有等到失踪的两人。…

9个月内73起个人代步工具火灾! 民防部队吁民众提高警惕

数据显示,今年1月至9月份,共发生了73起因个人代步工具引起的意外,民防部队呼吁民众应该提高警惕,谨慎使用个人代步工具。 对于民众而言,尽管经常发生因个人代步工具引起的火灾,但有者仍不以为意,因为总会有“一定不会发生在自己身上”的想法。 为能引起民众的警觉,民防部队周日(15日)发布视频,并以“总不会发生在自己身上”(It won’t happen to me)标题,希望能借此提高警惕。 视频中,民防部队促请用户要定期检查电池是否出现任何损坏,并勿将个人代步工具长时间充电或在使用后立即充电。 与此同时,民防部队也表示勿将个人代步工具随意更换不合格的电池,避免造成爆炸事件发生。 民防部队也借此公布一项数据调查,截至9月前,共已发生73起交通工具所引起的意外,而自2016年起至2019年9月,伤亡人数多大71人。 换言之,平均每个月至少有8起相关意外发生。 相较于过去,发生意外的案例明显增多,从2017年49起火灾意外,攀升至2019年9月间的74起。…

AGC drops case against teen responsible for fake LKY death announcement

The Attorney-General’s Chambers (AGC) has decided not to prosecute the male Singaporean…

MOH should keep eye on immigration-related health issues

The following is a letter to the Today newspaper which was rejected…