By Singapore Kopi Tok

Peering at the storm around Singapore recently, is it all about envy? MP Ho Geok Choo’s question in Parliament on 12.2.2007 about the “Politics of Envy” attracted reactions both domestically and in the region.

From the transcript, it appears that even Speaker of Parliament had trouble comprehending her question. Ho has since clarified that she was “in substance and intent” asking “whether unhappiness with Singapore‘s ability to offer help to bigger and better-endowed neighbours was the driver behind the recent ban on sand exports by Indonesia. Therefore, would a different tactic and approach work better? Our neighbours could be feeling ‘low’ and may experience ‘loss of face’ when we talk so often about offering help.”

After careful reading (and re-reading) both her question in Parliament and her letter of clarification, I still have trouble discerning what her question or point is. Is she saying that Indonesia banned sand exports because Singapore had offered help? What is the “different tactic and approach” she is suggesting? The most charitable conclusion I can arrive at is that Ho would like the Singapore government to talk less often about the help we provided to our neighboring countries, since this leads to “loss of face.”

But are Singapore‘s aid efforts too heavily publicized? I think not. First, I think that the Singapore‘s government’s level of direct monetary assistance to foreign countries following disasters (from what I read anyway) appears to be quite minuscule. It’s usually $50,000 here and $100,000 there. Nowhere near the millions that Japan, the US, Australia and some European countries would give. What is probably the more significant contribution is the sharing of resources like manpower and equipment at short notice.

And there are several good reasons for publicizing such efforts. First, it mobilizes further contributions from the public. Second, since public funds/resources are being used, there is an obligation (moral or otherwise) to keep the public informed. Third, the media report such contributions simply because it is newsworthy and people want to know.

Ironically, while Ho’s intent is presumably to help Singapore improve ties with its neighbours, the airing of her question has been counterproductive. Malaysian DPM Najib’s response was that Malaysia had never been envious of progress made by other countries, and it was more important for Malaysia to focus on its own national development and progress. NST columnist Syed Nadzri noted that Ho’s suggestion “sounded highly presumptuous … it’s everybody else’s fault then” and recapped Singapore‘s recent bilateral boo-boos vis-à-vis the Indonesians and Thais. I’m sure that the vernacular press in Thailand and Indonesia have more colourful responses.

Even in Parliament, some questions are better left un-asked.

Read also:

S’pore MPs’ Remarks On “Politics Of Envy” Criticised
Politics of Power and Complacency

Minister George Yeo’s reply
A relationship built on sand


Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

男子号召个人代步工具骑士 “见人就伤”遭警方逮捕归案

一名34岁男子涉嫌在社交平台Telegram电动滑板车群组内,公开号召骑士暴力伤人,而且“见人就伤” ,目前已被警方逮捕。 新加坡警察部队发文表示,警方于12月30日接到报案,指有人在Telegram群组号召个人代步工具骑士于当晚9点,到榜鹅公园随意伤人。 警方在接获通报后,立即介入调查并掌握嫌犯身份,于12月31日早上10点时将他逮捕。警方也在嫌犯身上起获两部手机。 警方也表示,将以通过电子记录煽动暴力起诉嫌犯。目前案件仍在侦办中. 根据刑事法典第267C节条文,一旦罪成可被判最高五年监禁,或罚款,或两者兼施。

Netizens question NEA’s motives behind granting subsidies for centralised dishwashing costs at new SEHCs

Following the announcement by the National Environment Agency (NEA) last Friday (16…

与日本韩国齐名 新加坡护照重夺全球最强

新加坡护照重新夺得全球最强护照冠军,与日本和韩国护照并列为全球最好用、通行自由度最高的护照。 英国伦敦咨询公司亨利(Henley & Partners)昨日(28日)公布最新护照指数显示,我国和日韩两国的护照一样,能在190个国家和地区免签证。 韩国护照是在去年10分,经由与印度签署新的签证协议,才取得了190个国家和地区的免签证。 德国则以188个国家屈居第二。而第三则由丹麦、芬兰、法国、意大利和瑞典共享,他们的护照能在187个国家取得免签证。 卢森堡和西班牙夺得第四,英国受到脱欧影响,夺得第五。美国紧接在后,夺得第六。 东南亚国家方面,与我国毗邻的马来西亚夺得第13,汶莱夺得第21,而缅甸殿后,夺得第91名。 我国护照曾在去年10月和今年1月的排行榜中被日本赶超了,屈居第二。 根据数据分析公司FutureMap创办人康纳指出,全球最强护照都是来自亚洲国家,说明了在全球进化进程中,亚洲地区已经逐渐成为焦点。


根据新加坡外交部声明,外交部长维文今日(2日)致电缅甸国务资政翁山淑枝,表示我国将赠送2万5000个冠病19试剂盒,协助缅甸防疫。 除了试剂盒,我国也会捐赠100万片手术口罩和20万瓶消毒洗手液。 早前我国已捐赠一批防疫物资予该国。维文在电话中也重申两国良好关系,并强调双边合作对于战胜疫情尤为重要。两国也同意继续强化供应链,保持经济开放和互通,确保后疫情的经济复苏。