State Court of Singapore

Facebook users were rife with disbelief and disapprobation when the news of a lorry driver who killed three may evade due punishment because he “blacked out” behind the wheel.

State Coroner Kamala Ponnampalam released her findings on Wednesday (15 July) stating that Xu Kai Xiang’s congenital heart disease could have led to his black out at the time of the accident on 23 April 2018.

Xu is a Chinese national who became a Singapore permanent citizen.

On 3 Oct 2019. he was issued a discharge not amounting to an acquittal pending the coroner’s inquiry. The findings came nine months later.

It was an “unfortunate road traffic misadventure,” Ms Ponnampalam said in her findings, adding that there is “no basis to suspect foul play”

The users on social media called issues on mainly three premises: driving without a relevant licence at the time of the accident, a light sentence dealt after causing the death of three people, and being able to ‘evade’ punishment for medical reasons.

Driving without a relevant licence

Netizens such as Max Chionh and Xlent Low who commented on Today Online’s Facebook post of the case, questioned the licensing rules of allowing people with medical conditions that could cause accidents to drive.

Others felt the offences of driving without a valid licence and insurance should be the main focus of preventing road accidents.

 

Injustice over light sentence

Another group chastised the injustice over the judgment. A small fine and a short one-year ban from driving did not seem to fit the crime of killing three people. 

Outcry over the way the law and justice system in Singapore works was a point of contention among the discussion too.

 

Appropriate punishment not feted out due to medical reasons 

The circumstance of the accident declared by the coroner also provoked fervent furore.

Many challenged the notion that an offender can go ‘scot-free’ over medical reasons, and demanded stricter laws on the entry of foreign talent. 

Some went further to question the truth of his medical condition.

Subscribe
Notify of
14 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Netizens comment on PM Lee’s statement that founding fathers were ‘passionate about multiracialism’

In a Today report dated 29 September, it is reported that the…

Online users raise privacy concerns with the soon-to-be implemented satellite distance-based ERP

Come 2020, the old Electronic Road Pricing (ERP) system will be replaced…

FAS’s Bernard Tan under fire: Netizens slam blame shift onto players for lackluster performance

Addressing Singapore’s recent 0-7 loss to Malaysia at the SEA Games, Bernard Tan, acting president of the Football Association of Singapore (FAS), admitted room for improvement and promised a thorough review. Amid public calls for accountability, Tan acknowledged fan frustration and accepted responsibility for on-field results. However, fiery debates questioned FAS leadership, with critics pushing for top management to be held accountable, sparking calls for a comprehensive overhaul.

HDB clarifies CPF Housing Grants are disbursed into account holder’s own CPF account after flat is sold; Netizens ask HDB not to call it “grants” as it is not a free loan

On 15 September (Sunday), the Housing and Development Board (HDB) took to…