It has by now been widely reported that Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong (PM Lee) is suing long time blogger Leong Sze Hian (Leong) for alleged defamation over Leong sharing an article on Facebook (FB) that has allegedly defamed PM Lee.

Leong has clarified that he was not behind the offensive article and nor did he add to it via captions or commentaries. He merely shared it. Just like millions of other FB users worldwide. Leong has clicked “share” on his FB page.

Does this mean that anyone who shares any article (without commentary) that the authorities deem defamatory will be potentially guilty of defamation? That sets a dangerous precedent for possible misuse. It also leads to uncertainty because invariably, it will be unevenly applied. There are just too many people sharing articles and information daily on a global perspective.

Also, does “blank sharing” (ie sharing articles without commentary) an article constitute defamation?

The government has criticised FB recently over its refusal to take down a certain article from the States Times Review (STR)  which had implied that Singapore and PM Lee were somehow involved in the 1MDB article. While the contents of the STR article have been debunked, the government has used FB’s refusal to comply with the government’s request as a reason for why harsher regulations were necessary.

This apparent displeasure at FB and now suing Leong over an article on FB would lead one to think that the government has grave concerns over FB. If this were the case, why are certain prominent members of the government (PM Lee included) still active on FB? Surely, they should lead by example and shun FB?

At the end of the day, it cannot be one rule for the government and another rule for the rest of the country.

In other words, while decrying the dangers of FB, they are also still active users of FB. Could this send the message that the government is happy to harness the powers of FB for its own agenda but are not happy with others to do the same?

Further, could this create the impression that the government is more ready to take down individuals and not big powerful entities such as FB because individuals are more vulnerable and easier to get at? Could this (perhaps unwittingly) give off the “bully” image? Does the government want to come across as an entity that is prepared to cow its own citizens with lawsuits while allowing big corporations such as FB to “get away”?

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Mt E Doc says some COVID-19 patients from India have no antibody response despite being vaccinated in India

A case of a 45-year-old PR who has already been vaccinated with…

MOM should also capture, record, and publish data on employees retrenched from micro-SMEs for greater transparency

by Professor Sattar Bawany The Ministry of Manpower’s (MOM) advance labour market…

与去年同期增加五倍 上周骨痛热症病例创四年来新高

我国当前面对骨痛热症疫情挑战,上周就有499人被诊断患有骨痛热症,这是自2015年以来,在这四年里的每周最多病例记录。 除此之外,上周的数字也显示了,与去年同期相比,今年上报的病例数量增加了五倍。 由此可见,今年感染骨痛热症的患者人数已超过6200人,超过了过去两年的总和;2017年的病例哟2767宗,2018年有3285宗。 由于骨痛热症患者三人中有一人需要住院三、四天,显示了上周就平均每天有24人因此病症而入院。尤其严重的是,有44名病患出现了更严重的骨痛溢血症,今年迄今死亡人数也与2018年的总数相同,即5人。 新加坡环境局(NEA)指出,蚊子检测仪显示,与3月份相比,身为骨痛热症主要传播媒体的伊蚊数量在5月份增加了56巴仙。 当局官网上写道,“持续性增加的伊蚊数量,增加了骨痛热症的传播风险,需要采取紧急行动以消除潜藏于社区中的蚊子繁殖地”。 6月份没病例飙升现象 当局指出,由于湿热天气缩短了蚊子的繁殖周期,6月至10月份的骨痛热症比例若有所飙升,实属正常。但是,从环境局的病例图表中可发现,自3月以来病例一直呈现上升趋势,在6月份却没有出现飙升的现象。 据《网络公民》消息来源显示,环境部也不确定导致病例飙升的原因,目前仍然在研究中。 本部曾与当局联系,以征求他们对导致病例暴增原因的看法。 菜市通道组屋染病居民最多 据当局官网消息指出,我国目前有125个活跃的骨痛热症病例集中区,最大涵盖区域出现在我国东部。…

年仅24岁 原定月底完婚 印度庙骚乱中遇袭消拯员不幸逝世

上月底,马国苏邦再也一家百年印度庙发生骚乱,消拯员受莫哈末阿迪在执勤中被殴打致伤,但在和死神搏斗20多天后,于昨晚咽下最后一口气,在国家心脏中心与世长辞。 阿迪现年仅24岁,原定于月底和未婚妻完婚。阿迪是在上月27日凌晨时分,与同僚赶赴位于苏邦再也的印度庙,准备扑灭一辆燃烧车子时,遭情绪激烈人士猛砸消防车,他被拉出消防车外殴打。 阿迪受伤后,立即被送往苏邦再也森那美议员和国家心脏中心治疗。 尽管治疗期间,其伤势曾一度好转,但在两天前突然恶化,肺部组织出现硬化现象,导致肺部无法有效换气,病情转危。 院方为他安装叶克膜(ECMO,即体外膜氧合机器)来协助他呼吸,可惜仍不敌死神召唤,阿迪终在昨晚9时41份离世,与未婚妻和家人阴阳永隔。 马国房屋及地方政府部长祖来达发文告证实了阿迪的死讯。 死者遗体也在今早7时30份,运往苏邦再也机场,通过雪州消拯局安排的直升机,将阿迪运返他的老家吉打。 首相副揆发文哀悼 副首相拿督斯里旺阿兹莎表示,她对於莫哈末阿迪的离世,感到十分悲痛,並形容他是一名真正的英雄。 她在文告中向死者的家属和未婚妻致哀,並强调,如今大马人必须团结一致,共同反抗这种罪行。 “我们须谨记,这不是宗教或种族罪行,而是无情人类所犯下的罪行。让我们一起祈祷,罪犯能尽快绳之以法。” 马国社运艺术家也在脸书为阿迪创作哀悼作品:…