On Wednesday, 21 January 2015, the Government announced an increase in public transport fares by 2.8 per cent.

As with previous increases, the news was met with anger from the public, especially given the fall in oil prices by 50 per cent worldwide.

On Saturday, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong was asked about this in a Facebook chat session.

Ms Alanna Si Jia Tan had asked Mr Lee “why is it that our transportation cost keep on increasing?” [Sic]

“Every year they increase and we do know that sbs transit earn huge profits for their pockets,” Ms Tan said.

To this, Mr Lee replied:

LHL

First, Mr Lee made two points:

  1. It is not true that SBS Transit earns huge profits.
  2. SBS Transit’s bus operations have been losing money.

SBS Transit runs a fleet of some 3,200 buses, and it also manages the North-east and Downtown MRT lines.

It has indeed been reported that its bus operations have been bleeding red for some years.

However, Mr Lee’s first statement – that it is not true that SBS Transit earns huge profits – is not borne out by the facts.

Over the years, in fact, SBS Transit has been making healthy profits.

Here are its earnings (after tax) for the years from 2001 to 2010. Figures from its annual reports:

sbs 2001 to 2010

They look pretty huge and healthy.

Its profits from 2011 – S$36,676,000:

sbs 2011

Its profits from 2012 – S$18,557,000:

sbs 2012

Its profits from 2013 – S$11,176,000:

sbs2013

 

And how did SBS Transit do in 2014? Here are what the news reported, of the first 3 quarters’ financial results:

SBS Q results 14

Here’s what the Straits Times said:

sbs 2014

Even its parent company, ComfortDelgro, has been breaking profit records:

comfortdelgro 2014

The question which should be asked, therefore, is why are its bus services making losses when its other services are not.

And also, should taxpayers subsidise, through government grants and higher fares, one part of a company if it does not make money while its other parts do?

In any case, contrary to what Mr Lee says, SBS Transit itself is and has been making healthy profits all this while.

Subscribe
Notify of
10 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Straits Times publishing Alfian Sa’at posts on LKY: “Because it’s newsy”

By Carlton Tan On Friday, The Straits Times published an article, titled…

飞雪连天射白鹿 笑书神侠倚碧鸳 金庸走了 侠骨长存

笔名金庸的知名武侠小说巨匠、知名报人查良镛,于昨日下午五时许在香港养和医院逝世,享年94岁。大侠挥袖离开人间,但他创造的武侠世界观,却将在全球说华语的地方永远流传。 与金庸交往较密切的一些朋友称,老先生已逾九旬高龄,近几年来身体健康不佳,一般是卧床,而且精神状态也不好。如今辞世,身边的亲友虽心中悲痛,但并不感觉意外。金庸生于1924年3月10日,浙江海宁人,曾经创作《射雕英雄传》《神雕侠侣》《倚天屠龙记》《天龙八部》《笑傲江湖》《鹿鼎记》等家传户晓的小说。1945年抗战胜利后返乡,曾在杭州《东南日报》暂任外勤记者。 1946年秋,查良镛进入上海《大公报》任国际电讯翻译,1948年调往香港分社。1959年,查良镛等人于香港创办《明报》,后来推出包括《明报晚报》、《明报月刊》和《明报周刊》。 《明报》刊登的由金庸撰写的社论也影响深远,特别是中国大陆正经历动荡不安的1960、70年代,《明报》成为报道中国消息的权威,也满足了香港人对大陆资讯的诉求。 1967年在新加坡创办《新明日报》 《明报》见证了金庸武侠的一段全盛时期。《神雕侠侣》扭转报纸初期的亏损状态,之后《明报》又连载了1961年的《倚天屠龙记》、《鸳鸯刀》、《白马啸西风》,1963年的《天龙八部》等作品。一直到1972年完成《鹿鼎记》之后,金庸宣布封笔。香港一家媒体称,金庸“在退出侠坛时仍称霸武林”。在迈入经济繁荣时代的香港,金庸与小说家倪匡、文化人蔡澜及词曲作家黄霑并称香港“四大才子”。 1967年,金庸和本地驱风油大王梁润之,在新加坡合资创办《新明日报》,在该报独家发表他的武侠小说《笑傲江湖》,深受读者青睐,也刺激报纸销量。他还曾空邮最新的小说到新加坡,让《新明日报》比香港《明报》提早三天刊登。 跨地域的华语文学泰斗 金庸著作影响深远,是几代华人的集体回忆。其中《雪山飞狐》、《射雕英雄传》等篇章节录也被编入本地中学华文文学课程内容,让新生代也领略金庸大侠的文学风采。今年二月,《射雕英雄传》也推出英文版,开始进驻英语文化圈。 金庸和古龙、梁羽生、温瑞安,并列四大武侠小说宗师。大侠的武侠小说著作,描绘的不仅是侠骨豪情,笔下人物栩栩如生,也在影射着现实生活中面对的人情世故。金庸深厚的文学造诣,成功构筑豪情万丈、波澜壮阔的武侠世界,读着小说里的奸妄小人令人愤慨;但同时让我们透过郭靖、陈家洛、乔峰和胡一刀等人物,看到为家国舍身的侠义精神。 在金庸的武侠世界,他让我们知道,有人的地方就有江湖,有江湖的地方就有是非。若《连城诀》描绘的江湖人心险恶,却也告诉我们“多行不义必自毙”,不如快意江湖,拼搏人生几十年不留白,既有儿女私情,也有家国情怀,习得一身好武艺,只为行侠仗义胸怀社稷。 金庸走了,但他是华人文化世界不可取代的丰碑,但他笔下的江湖,却已经活在每个人都心中。…

MINDEF refutes claims that acquisition of F-35 fighter jets by RSAF is to align itself with US

The Ministry of Defence (MINDEF) stressed that the acquisition of F-35 fighter…