By Bhavan Jaipragas

The original story was written for GO-FAR, an overseas journalism programme organised by the Wee Kim Wee School of Communication and Information at Nanyang Technological University.

Landlocked and aid-dependent Bhutan may be worlds apart from Singapore and its globalised, advanced economy, but the Himalayan kingdom's unique people-centric growth model could still teach the city-state a thing or two, say two leading Singapore economists.

Bhutan embraces a development philosophy that it calls "Gross National Happiness" (GNH), which focuses on 72 "happiness indicators" including the mental health of its citizens, pollution levels, the crime rate, and income distribution. 

According to Yeoh Lam Keong and Manu Bhaskaran, this principle of looking beyond economic growth and setting meaningful targets is one that should apply in Singapore, even though the two countries' challenges and circumstances are entirely different.

"Whatever your level of opportunity, you can always raise the level of well-being if you focus on the indicators that matter," said Yeoh. "The development options that Bhutan has are completely different from ours. But what they do which we don't is to focus on key indicators."

Bhaskaran said Singapore should not view GDP growth "as the be all and end all".

"Are we really building the kind of economy that really services the needs of the citizens?," he added. "At the end of the day economics…is all about whether you can deliver things to the average guy and make his life meaningful."

Yeoh and Bhaskaran are adjunct senior research fellows at the Institute of Policy Studies, and were part of the team that penned a groundbreaking policy paper on the need for a new social compact in Singapore.

They were speaking earlier this month to a team of student journalists who are on their way to Bhutan to report on various aspects of life in the Kingdom. The trip is part of the annual Going Overseas For Advanced Reporting (GO-FAR) programme of the Wee Kim Wee School of Communication and Information, Nanyang Technological University.

The once-isolated Himalayan kingdom has become a prominent case study in international discussions about sustainable development. Bhutan was even debated in Singapore's Parliament last year, after opposition MP Sylvia Lim asked if the government would create its own GNH index after co-sponsoring a Bhutan-led UN resolution to make happiness a key development goal.

In response, national development minister Khaw Boon Wan — who had previously visited Bhutan — cautioned against viewing the kingdom as "Shangri-La on earth". He remarked that the only "happy" people he saw were wealthy tourists, children with "angelic innocence" and foreign volunteers who found meaning in helping the less privileged.

"Most of time, I saw unhappy people, toiling in the field, worried about the next harvest and whether there would be buyers for their products," he said.

Yeoh and Bhaskaran agreed that Bhutan was a poor country whose people probably aspired to many of the comforts enjoyed in Singapore. Bhutan has a per capita income of US$6,000, compared with Singapore's US$49,700. Unlike Singapore's open and globalised economy, landlocked Bhutan is forced to depend heavily on neighbouring India.

Nevertheless, Bhutan's approach of measuring progress with relevant yardsticks is something that Singapore can learn from, the economists said.

In healthcare for example, possible indicators could be the proportion of citizens' "out of pocket" expenses compared with other developed countries, and the breadth of outreach of public hospitals. Yeoh noted that such targets – instead of looking solely at costs and facilities — would result in more people benefitting from a higher standard of care.

Income inequality was also a relevant measure, he said. A widening wealth gap was known to lead to various social ills including higher juvenile delinquency, diminished social mobility and shorter life expectancy. "Singapore is not focusing on the key indicators," he said.

Follow Go-FAR Bhutan on Facebook at http://www.facebook.com/GoFarBhutan2012.

 

You May Also Like

5 Minutes With… Leong Sze Hian on NTUC discounts

TOC spends 5 minutes with Leong Sze Hian discussing the NTUC’s U-Stretch vouchers for poorer Singaporeans.

今年第二季运营盈利1390万元 新捷运称轻轨亏损 吁公交理事会调整车资

根据新捷运(SBS Transit)2017年度报告,显示该公司从2013年以来的营收和股东应占盈利(profit attributable to shareholders),都呈现增长之势。 该公司去年的运营盈利达到5千930万新元,比2015年增长两倍。至于股东应占盈利,则从2015年的1千670万新元,三倍跃进至去年的4千710万新元。 根据新捷运发表的2018年第二季度表现,在公共交通服务方面的营收达到3亿3010万元,比2017年同季度还要高20.3巴仙。 在该报告中称,更高的车资,以及自2018年3月开跑的实里达配套和去年10月开跑的3号DTL捷运线,增加了该季度营收。 客流量增,惟轻轨面临亏损 在第二季度,DTL线路每日平均客流量增长了80.6巴仙,达到43万7千人次;东北线与2017年第二季度相比,每日平均客流量增长2.3巴仙,达到57万9千人次;轻轨平均乘客量增8.1巴仙至12万9千人次。 2018年第二季度的运营盈利(operating profit)达到1千390万元,比去年同季增加了660万元,原因是较高的营收抵消了其他增长的员工成本、燃油和电力、维修保养等运营成本。…

不必再带大量现金! NETSPay 提款卡今后可到槟城吉隆坡马六甲付账

国人今后到马来西亚槟城、吉隆坡以及马六甲,都能使用星网电子付款公司NETS的提款卡付账! 据PayNet官网指出,全马已将4500个星网提款卡的零售点增加至7400个,而该零售店均分布在不同地区。 2018年星网电子付款公司已开始扩大其服务至柔佛州的特定地点,包括JB City Square、 Sutera Mall以及 KSL City Mall。如今该服务更延伸至吉隆坡机场KLIA 2、Sunway Pyramid…

口罩和洗手液进口 关税局:未落实附加限制

针对社交媒体一则的贴文,新加坡关税局发文告澄清,当局对口罩和洗手液的进口,并没有实施附加的限制政策。 此前,有网民在脸书申诉,他携带七盒口罩入境,却需要缴付25.2新元的税款。他也上载一张照片,相信是在新加坡游轮中心的一则告示,上面除了提醒游轮乘客需申报烟酒之外,也要申报所携带的口罩和洗手液。 对此关税局指出,实则上述告示乃是出于善意提醒。近期手提携带大量手术口罩和洗手液入境的游轮乘客激增,为此才提醒,那些携带上述物品数量超过免税顶限的乘客,需前往关税柜台申报缴付消费税,此举是为了加快通关程序。 关税局也解释,所有被携带入境的物品,如果超过消费税进口免税额,或者用于商业目的,那么入境旅客都需要申报之。