~ By Prof Lim Chong Yah ~

Paper presented at the Economic Society of Singapore Distinguished Speaker Public Lecture Series on 9 April 2012 at the Orchard Hotel, Singapore. This is Part 1 of Prof Lim's speech and Part 2 can be found here. TOC thanks Prof Lim for allowing us to republish his lecture in full.



Economic Conditions in Singapore in late 1970s

(Surfeit of low-wage workers)

* Low-wage occupations: ubiquitous

* Low-wage manufacturing: common

* General technology level: low, very low

* Women employment: low

* General under-employment: rife

* Wind of change in East Asia, particularly China

Economic Restructuring I (1979 – 81)

Singapore went through a formal economic restructuring exercise for three years, 1979 – 81, during which:

(1) Wage rates were increased across-the-board cumulatively by 20% per year;

(2) A portion of the wage increase went to CPF through increases in employers’ and employees’ contributions;

(3) Another portion of the wage increase, 4% of wages below a certain level, went to a newly-created tripartite-run Skills Development Fund;

(4) The new Skills Development Fund Advisory Council oversaw the administration of the Fund with twin objectives

(i) Substantial across-the-board subsidy for training and retraining of employees at all levels opened to all employers in Singapore.

(ii) A common-playing-field substantial subsidy for the mechanization of the production processes opened to all employers in Singapore.

Need and Objective of ER I

The overall objective of the restructuring exercise was to move the old traditional economy from a low-skilled, low-value-added and highly-labour-intensive structure to a high-skilled, high-value-added, and more technology and more knowledge-based new economy. The need for restructuring was urgent in view of increasing competition from new emerging and developing economies in East Asia particularly following the opening-up and the robust new industrialization programme of the People's Republic of China since 1978.

Five-Point Observations on ER I

Five general observations of the first formal economic restructuring exercise (1979-81) will be made here.

(1) It was self-funded, or strictly speaking, funded by the employers, not by the Government through higher taxes or from quantitative easing, or from accumulated reserves or otherwise.

(2) The exercise was very focused with only one Government-appointed tripartite agency, the Skills Development Fund Advisory Council, overseeing the exercise.

(3) The “means” for the restructuring objective was also much focused. The means were only two: one, mechanization, that is, the substitution of capital for labour, and two, training and re-training of workers, particularly technologically replaced workers.

(4) Even the training and mechanization programmes were highly focused: mechanized and trained to meet the anticipated demand of the employers; not training for the sake of training and mechanization for the sake of mechanization.

(5) Lastly, the modus operandi was through inducement, incentives and disincentives programmes, and not direction. Market forces were given a full reign. The Skills Development Fund was merely providing the direction, the support, the philip and the accelerator. The SDF merely provided the GPS.

Success of ER I

Despite some teething problems, the then considered bold and iconoclastic restructuring exercise was a great success. Real GDP displayed high real growth rates of 9.4% in 1979, 10.0% in 1980 and 10.7% in 1981. After 1981, the built-in restructuring momentum continued unabated until the regional recession year of 1985.

Subsequent Low-Wage Labour Import

Since 1985, fearing that the Singapore economy would become internationally uncompetitive, we gradually and imperceptibly eased the moratorium on the intake of lowly-paid, lowlyskilled foreign labour. Non-resident labour force increased steadily from 300.8 thousand in 1991 to 1.157 million in 2011, as shown in Diagram 1, which is based on published official statistics. GDP, as expected, expanded pari passu, as impressively as the inflow of lowlypaid foreign labour. Non-resident labour is cheap. Out of the 1.157 million non-resident work-force in 2011, only 1.7% earned wages high enough to pay income tax. The rest, the majority 98.3%, did not earn high enough to fall into the income-taxable bracket.


Increasing Supply of Non-resident Labour Force (‘000)

It cannot be over-stated that successful economic restructuring can only take place with a moratorium on cheap labour import. There is, as you know, an unlimited supply of lowlypaid foreign labour in our region. One cannot substitute capital for labour, if labour is cheap.

That was why the NWC in 1979 recommended a cumulative 20% increase in labour cost per year for the restructuring years of 1979-81.

Adverse Impact on Domestic Wage Rates

Below is a simplified diagram to illustrate this often forgotten simple principle of price in relation to supply and demand. Diagram 2 shows that an increase in the supply of labour, ceteris paribus, brings down the wage rate from W0 to W1.

Part 2 continues here


Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

A question of basic respect

Ghui/ I refer to the article entitled ‘Boy, 10 calls school bus…

SportSG called for a full explanation from Football Association of Singapore on usage of donation amount

The unclear distribution and usage of a huge donation that had been…

WhatsApp rushed to fix security vulnerability exploited by Israeli spyware

WhatsApp discovered a disturbing security breach early this month when they found…

血癌夫妇因疫情被迫滞留新加坡 辗转申请如今得以返马

曾几何时,回家就只是一张车票或一辆车子的事,谁都不曾想过,在如今被誉为地球村的现代,终有一天也会家而归不得。疫情的出现间接阻断了人们的行动,各国实施行动限制,也让许多人滞留海外包括在国外求医的人,有家归不得。 马来西亚柔佛再也州议员廖彩彤,今日(22日)分享一则血癌夫妇归家故事。该患者刘先生称呼,当初因患上血癌,在行动管制令(MCO)前,于我国进行治疗。不料却因马国行动管制令,而滞留在新加坡。 廖彩彤表示,由于行动管制令数度被延长,加上我国也开始实施阻断措施,以至于刘先生与妻子滞留新加坡无法回国。 由于刘先生的情况特殊,除了正在进行血癌治疗,也同时深受严重焦虑症所困,因此隔离期间,仍需妻子时刻在旁稳定情绪。院方也为此作出特别安排,让两人一同隔离。 然而,面对病情日益加剧,加上新加坡昂贵的医药费用,使得夫妇二人相当煎熬,经常向女儿想回家的心情。 廖彩彤也表示,在经过多次的申请后,终于在昨日下午获得通关许可,在各方配合,包括医院、救护车、最高专员署的协助下,如今刘先生能够如愿以偿,踏上回家的路。 廖彩彤于今日也陪同女儿到医院等候医疗团队将夫妇二人接回家。女儿随后也向廖彩彤表示,夫妇二人在得知可以回国后,非常开心,也希望能够在14天隔离结束后立即与家人团聚。 “刚刚刘先生也开玩笑告诉我,终于踏在家乡的土地。可以感受到他雀跃的心情。” 消息一出,也引起网民的关注,网民纷纷感谢议员帮助,并表示这也为黑暗时期增添不少温暖。截至目前已获得逾1千赞。