This letter appeared in the Straits Times Forum.

DR PATRICK Tan’s deferment of his national service (NS) for 12 years (‘Patrick Tan on his medical studies’; last Saturday) brings to mind the stories of many other talented Singaporeans who were not allowed to defer their NS.

Some are talented musicians, sportsmen or artists who have qualified for prestigious schools or have trained hard enough to don national colours for competitions. The Ministry of Defence’s (Mindef) stock reply is that national servicemen are granted deferment only in rare and exceptional cases. After reading Dr Tan’s clarification, I cannot help but ask what the thus far unspecified criteria are that would allow for discretionary deferment.

Dr Tan’s case suggests to me that budding musicians, artists or sportsmen are deemed less important than future doctors or scientists. If Singapore is to be vibrant and enriching, talented citizens in any field should be supported.

What are the necessary conditions for deferment? Mindef’s transparency will set the record straight and help in future appeals.

Lim Guay Cheng (Ms)

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

房产前景分析:若经济衰退来临 应先提前作好准备面对

尽管总理公署部长英兰妮,早前对媒体表示我国经济尚未陷入衰退,但不利消息如制造业出口在8月份急剧衰退、PMI指数降至3年来最低点、2019年GDP增长预测下调0巴仙至1巴仙等等,都在显示我国经济当前面对的隐忧和挑战。 新加坡房地产网页Property Soul于周二(8日),发表一篇文章《经济衰退对物业又有何种意义》(What Recession Means for Properties),在本社英语站谈到几个观点,可供读者参考。 文内指出 , 经济衰退是全球性问题,无一幸免,尽管各国政府都在各尽所能,避免国家经济衰退,包括泰国投入100亿美元刺激经济、香港宣布拨款24.3亿美元舒缓经济措施、中国持续让人民币贬值等等。 但从近数个月来,经济衰退似乎成为全球的共识。举例来说,美国银行表示将在未来12个月,有三分一的可能出现衰退;摩根大通则将经济衰退的可能性提高到四成以上;摩根士丹利预测第三季度将出现经济衰退等等, 事实上,某些国家已经开始陷入衰退的迹象,例如中美两大国的经济因长久的中美贸易战而持续放缓,而德国的制造业已经陷入衰退,甚至连带服务业也受到波动;也有经济分析师表示全球科技、制造业以及工业正在经历衰退中。…

MP Indranee Rajah: The upcoming PSLE scoring system will produce similar outcomes for pupils exempted from taking mother tongue languages

Second Minister for Education Indranee Rajah said on Monday (2 September) that…

SMRT discusses with LTA to limit the number of passengers on its buses

As part of enhanced safe distancing measures against the transmission of COVID-19,…

中国籍男子涉非礼遭控,友人曾嚣张录视频辱警

日前涉嫌非礼啤酒女郎的中国籍男子,今日以非礼罪名遭提控。 中国籍男子余志勇(译音,41岁)于本月18日晚上9点35分在兀兰咖啡店,涉嫌非礼30岁的啤酒女郎。根据指控所诉,他被指伸出左手拍打女性的臀部右侧。 而早前在SG Kay Poh 的脸书上上载一段中国籍男子狂拍执法警员的视频,据了解,视频中身着红衣为中国籍男子余志勇,而其友人(蓝衣)则以嚣张的态度对着正在进行问话的执法警员狂拍。 现场民众也以拍摄视频,警告蓝衣男子要尊重新加坡法律,并扬言将此违法行为放上网络。视频曝光后,已有逾四万人次观看。一些网民也非议涉事者友人的态度。 被告随后以5000新元获批保外,并于本月30日再次上庭。 一旦罪成,被告或将判处鞭刑、罚款或最高2年监禁。