A letter to the National Wages Council by Transient Workers Count Too (TWC2)

The Secretary
National Wages Council
c/o Labour Relations Department
Level 6-01 Ministry of Manpower
18 Havelock Road
Singapore 059764

Dear NWC,

As a society concerned with the well-being of migrant workers in Singapore, Transient Workers Count Too wishes to appeal to you to give consideration to the raising of salaries in the lowest paid sectors of the economy, where migrant workers are concentrated.

Salaries of most work permit holders have failed to keep pace with rising costs, including the cost of placement, since the end of the last century. While efforts have been made to raise the skill levels of local low-paid workers so that they qualify for posts carry improved salaries, migrant workers have tended to be left behind.

This is evidently to their disadvantage, but also to that of the overall Singaporean economy. Improved pay levels would increase the incentive for workers to sign up again after their first placement for work in Singapore, and so the country would gain greater benefit from their enhanced skill levels, instead of seeing a large proportion go elsewhere at the end of their contracts and needing to replace them with inexperienced new workers.

In the shipyard and construction sectors, hours are often long and the work is hard and hazardous, despite serious efforts to raise safety standards, and yet most workers are paid $2-$4 an hour. This is inadequate compensation for their work.

It may be that the council would consider domestic workers salaries as being beyond its purview, in the informal sector. We hope not; what other body concerned with salaries will speak up for them otherwise? Most domestic workers are at present paid between $300 and $400 a month. The pay of a worker with no day off and a salary of $350 therefore works out at $11.67 a day. Many work long hours; for a 15 hour day, this would mean a worker being paid 78 cents an hour.

In view of the exceptionally low pay of domestic workers and their limited bargaining power, we believe that the introduction of a minimum wage (if necessary from a policy viewpoint, specifically limited to domestic workers as a special case) would be an effective means of redressing this situation. We note that the Philippines is seeking to establish an internationally accepted minimum monthly salary for its nationals of US$400 and suggest that this might be considered as a good starting point for considering its level.

The government has highlighted the need for enhanced productivity in Singapore’s economy. Reducing the level of turnover among migrant workers through improving salary levels could be one strong component element in the drive for improved productivity. Even if current efforts to curb recruitment, allied to a reduction in demand from the construction sector, produce a stabilisation or drop in migrant worker numbers, it is unlikely to radically alter the high level of migrant worker participation in Singapore’s economy. A long term relationship between migrant workers and Singapore society will develop more favourably for all concerned if locals and foreign workers are made to feel that they share a common interest in Singapore’s rising prosperity, reflected in enhanced pay levels, rather than being competitors who can only gain at each other’s expense.

Yours sincerely,

John Gee


Transient Workers Count Too

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Don't blindly trumpet achievements in standardised tests

The following is the  original letter of the one published in the…

群众问是否请反对党“群策群力”? 王瑞杰左右言他

上周六(15日),副总理王瑞杰出席由民情联系组(REACH)和亚洲新闻台主办的“群策群力,共创未来”对话会。在对话会上他倡议让国民也有机会能参与制定、涉及政策,并表示第四代领导团队自踏入政坛后,就不断与各界人士交流,倾听民声、广纳民意。 在问答交流环节,就有一名大巴窑的居民询问,出席对话会的群众是如何筛选而来?是否有反对党成员获邀参与? 这名民众认为,反对党也同样是积极参与建设民主社会的公民,既然政府要落实“以行动彰显民主的社会”,也应邀请反对党合作,才能达成真正的多元化。 对此,王瑞杰是这么回答的: “只要你的心是为了新加坡和国人好,我们可以和任何人合作。” 但他又指出,多元的观点不一定来自反对党,它可以来自方方面面,即便在内阁会议,部长们也会意见相左。 “让我们去辩论各种选项是好事。但是应避免有不同的目的,因为团结才是最重要的。迄今为止我们能引领新加坡前进,是因为我们拥有共同的目标。在共同目标下,我们可以讨论谁的方案、概念更好”。 不过,他并没有正面回应,究竟有关对话会,有没有邀请反对党成员出席、或未来有没有打算邀请。 至于对话会主持人Steven Chia则解释,并没有依据政党背景筛选对话会出席者。与会的大多涉足或在特定领域为新加坡作出贡献。 据了解,受邀者不乏非政府组织、福利团体、环保分子、工会、障友和宗教团体代表。 与会者对王瑞杰抛出涵盖社会流动、税务、社会包容性、年轻人处境等议题。…

奥南路名源起咯拉拉欧南节? 黄子明博士纠正:与爪哇商人Onan bin Rajidin有关

本月11日,《联合早报》刊载《加东如切的精彩碰撞》文章,描绘加东和如切缤纷多彩的景点。与此同时,也是多元文化的地区,不仅华巫印三族,也有显著的土生华人与欧亚人特色。 不过,文化遗产学博士黄子明,发现文章中谈及奥南路(Onan Road)路名的来源有谬误。 上述文章如是介绍奥南路名称缘起: “加东奥迪安后面的圣帕加维那雅加印度庙(Sri Senpaga Vinayagar Temple)历史可追溯到1875年,由住在附近的锡兰淡米尔人所建。街道名称锡兰路、锡兰巷反映出这一带的印族特色,而奥南路路名也是来自印度咯拉拉的欧南节(Onam)。” 对此,黄子明博士指出,尽管众所周知,三巴旺一带曾有印裔马拉雅丽(Malayalee)社群居住,他们在海军造船厂工作。不过仍未有听闻,奥南路路名来自该族传统节庆的说法。 若网络查询新加坡资讯百科(Infopedia),也不难发现奥南路很有可能是根据一名从爪哇移居来的商人Onan bin Rajidin来命名。他曾在这一带建设奥南路清真寺(1980年代中期因地区重新发展而拆除)。…

President Halimah Yacob wants OKLETSGO podcast to apologise for its “offensive, humiliating and misogynistic” comments about women

President Halimah Yacob has urged podcast channel OKLETSGO to apologise to all…