Our reply (view original letter here):

I refer to the letter of Mr Lionel De Souza on 15 June.

The Online Citizen (TOC) consistently practices a policy of community moderation, which relies on a process of reader feedback and moderator responsibility. Our comment filter is programmed to exclude comments which contain terms and references that might promote enmity between different races or religions, or which might be defamatory.

Additionally, we rely on reader feedback to identify and remove such comments. This form of moderation on the basis of community feedback was most recently practiced during the Aware issue.

In relation to the eight alleged offending comments, if Mr De Souza had raised his concerns directly to TOC, we would be happy to consider removing them if they were indeed a potential violation of the law. Naturally, as the parties who have the most to lose if prosecuted, we have an interest in taking such constructive feedback very seriously.

Unfortunately, Mr De Souza sent us no such notification or email.

Maturity in public discourse can only arise with a willingness to engage parties with whom you disagree. In choosing instead to appeal to the heavy hand of the regulatory authority, Mr De Souza has chosen to bypass a far more effective solution to the problems he is alleging: community moderation.

Mature public discourse is also not served with Mr De Souza’s ad hominem attack on our writers and commentors, whom he calls “nonsensical, crude and not worth reading”. Ironically, his is precisely the sort of online language that makes it easy to negatively stereotype online discourse.

This vitriol can only lead a discerning member of the public to question what his personal motives are in writing his letter.

Choo Zheng Xi


The Online Citizen


Letter of complaint (view original letter here):

Immediately after the report, “8 weeks’ jail each” (June 11), there are as of June 14, a total of 86 posts by anonymous bloggers on The Online Citizen’s (TOC) website.

I have no quarrel with these as most of the posts are nonsensical, crude and not worth reading. However, I came across 8 posts which to my mind have the tendency to espouse religious disharmony. These irresponsible and insensitive bloggers may, whether consciously or unconsciously by their comments (posts) sowed seeds that may inevitably promote religious disharmony or feelings of enmity between different religious groups.

Hence, the conduct of the perpetrators of the posts may probably be a transgression of section 298A of the Penal Code, (Chapter 224) – “ Promoting enmity between different groups on grounds of religion or race and doing acts prejudicial to maintenance of harmony.”

The moderation clause of TOC expressly stipulates that it reserves the right to moderate, edit, disallow, remove or delete comments posted on their website which are deemed to be unwarranted and are racially offensive remarks or religiously insensitive or provocative.

I am of the opinion that TOC’s moderators have in this instance failed to exercise due diligence by allowing comments laced with insensitive religious connotations to be published on their website with regard to the topic “Perdition and sedition.”

I therefore urge the Media Development Authority of Singapore to look into the conduct of TOC’s moderators, and seek an explanation for their omission in ensuring that their website will in future not be used to ignite the flames of religious disharmony.

Lionel De Souza

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

【冠状病毒19】本地共51孩童与青少年确诊 九成孩童28天内康复

我国昨日(22日)在康复出院的病例中,其中有一名三岁女孩,是众多儿童患者中确诊至康复时间最长的小孩。 据卫生部昨日(22日)文告指出,该名女孩为第582例,于3月24日中确诊。从卫生部的更新的数据显示,目前已有51例儿童与青少年的案例,其中42例是本地传染,9例为境外移入病例。 一岁以下约9名、一岁至6岁以上约12名、7岁至12岁约22名、13至16岁则8名。 51人中已有26人康复出院,25人仍在就医。有半数儿童在14天内获得康复,约九成的孩童在28天内康复。 只有两病例需花费逾四周以上才康复。 根据《新报》报道,国立大学医学组织教授费舍尔表示,孩子感染冠状病毒19的可能性比成年人低,并没有证据表明孩子是家中首个感染者,通常是父母将病毒传染给他们。

Honour in Singapore – About executive director Jason Wong

“Honour in Singapore” is a mini series by TOC following the recent formation…

SMRT fined S$400,000 for safety lapses in Pasir Ris accident

Singapore Mass Rapid Transit (SMRT) Trains was fined S$400,000 on Tuesday (28…

国人陆续从各地返狮城 我国确诊病例或增加

卫生部长称,陆续数周都会有国人从世界各地回国,相信我国确诊病例还会再增加,幸运的是中国已经成功控制可疫情传染,上周逾千名从中国回国的本地人中,都没有出现感染迹象。 卫生部长颜金勇昨日在国会上,发表部长声明时指出,我国冠毒新增病例在过去一周内翻倍,从境外输入的新病例占了将近八成,但是相信在接下来数周,一部分逗留在世界各地的20万国人会回国,病例也会随着增加。惟,随着疫情“震央”已逐渐转移到欧美地区,上周自中国回来的1000名国人和长期证件持有者都没有人被感染。 卫生部专注于降低感染率 他在会上指出,我国至今已进行了3万9000个检测,包括为完成隔离的人士进行检测,以便能够更快速、更早地确认病例。相关检测次数相等于每100万人进行了6800个检测,比韩国和台湾来的高。韩国的检测为每100万人6500个,而台湾则是每100万人1000个。 他指出,已经有超过900家诊所参与公共卫生防范诊所(PHPC)计划,为呼吸道疾病患者提供津贴看诊和治疗,看诊病患已经超过了26万人次。 追踪病例团队基于预计本地病例将持续增加,已经从原有的三个增加到20个,每日平均追踪4000个亲密接触者。 然而颜金勇确认为,若出现更大的感染群,或许医疗和追踪资源将会不足,疫情会难以控制,因此我国专注于降低感染率,并且把感染率保持在越低越好。 他指出,在减低病毒传染方面,我国政府部门采取了必要的防疫措施,主要包括减少入境病例、及早诊断和隔离、并且加强社会责任及个人卫生习惯。 我国疫情未来发展 颜金勇也在国会上展示疫情有可能发展的情况,包括病例激增至高峰期,以及病例在高峰期不多,但是却拖较长时间才结束。 他指出,若没有任何防疫措施,我国出现病例会激增,到时就只能指望多数人患病并出现抗体、甚至免疫,冠毒感染率才会减缓,直到疫苗或治疗出现了才能断绝。“虽然这样似乎能够更快结束,但是存在两种风险,即短期病例激增将导致医疗系统超负荷,或者导致更高的死亡率,一发不可收拾,另外就是我们还不确定病毒免疫力是否有效且期限多长。” “若不要病例激增,那么就要设法减低感染率,但是疫情可能会拖更长的时间,就是第二个状况。”…