Singapore / photo:

I refer to the article “Singapore a good policy laboratory for other countries: Expert” (Straits Times, 19 Jan).
The article states that “Singapore is a “policy laboratory” that both developed and developing countries can look to in crafting their policies. ..In his book, he examines the Republic’s domestic policies in areas such as education, post-retirement savings, housing, ethnicity and transport.”
The comments were made by Dr Kent Carlder, an American expert on East Asia and author of a new book on Singapore, “Singapore – Smart City, Smart State”
I was in Hong Kong when I read the above.
So, I checked out the statistics on government social welfare spending in Hong Kong.
Social welfare spending: $2.5b vs $130m?
Perhaps arguably, the biggest difference between Hong Kong and Singapore on its social welfare expenditure may be that whilst Hong Kong’s social welfare spending was HK$13.4 billion (S$2.5 billion) –  Singapore’s equivalent (ComCare) spending was only S$130 million.

social welfare
Expenditure by Hong Kong SAR
Rats in a laboratory?
If I may borrow the writer’s words – don’t you think Singaporeans,  especially the needy and lower income, may in a sense be like rats in a laboratory, testing policies on how little can the government spend on its citizens before they cry enough is enough?
In this connection, we should applaud and support initiatives like “Chiam, Peng Siong team up for new charity foundation” (Today, 19 Jan) – “Two Singapore icons, veteran politician Mr Chiam See Tong and former star swimmer Mr Ang Peng Siong, have come together to set up a foundation that will provide financial aid to people who need it to pursue their goals, but fall outside the current systems that provide such help.”

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

The degree of trust Singaporeans place in the government places the government in an even greater position of responsibility where the coronavirus is concerned

By and large, Singaporeans trust the People’s Action Party (PAP) dominated government…

The country is interested, the country is watching – what about the President and Prime Minister?

by Augustine Low Home Affairs and Law Minister K Shanmugam said of…

Double standards in ban

The issue of work passes is a contentious one in Singapore. There…

People always forget that the money Heng Swee Keat is giving out is other people’s money

By other people’s money (OPM), we of course refer to money that…