by Teo Soh Lung

The contempt of court hearing against lawyer Mr M Ravi on 10 Oct 2022 before High Court Judge Hoo Sheau Peng relates to his conduct before District Judge Chay Yuen Fatt and High Court Judge Audrey Lim.

Senior State Counsel Adrian Loo submitted that Mr Ravi had alleged bias against both judges and uttered insulting words in open court. He alleged that Mr Ravi also told District Judge Chay: “You can be removed but not the High Court”.

Responding, Mr Ravi told Justice Hoo Sheau Peng that both judges had already filed disciplinary proceedings against him, and he has been suspended from legal practice. The present proceedings by the attorney general was therefore an overkill.

He told the court that since being confirmed to have suffered a relapse of his bipolar disorder in December 2021, the Attorney General had commenced five disciplinary proceedings against him.

Throughout the months of his medical leave from December 2021 to May 2022, he was stressed out. He was not able to rest and recover from his illness. He said there were “enough ongoing proceedings against me.” Further the allegation of bias was fair comment.

Medical reports have confirmed that Mr Ravi was suffering from a relapse of his bipolar illness. Public Prosecutor Adrian Loo who was assisted by three counsel from the Attorney-General’s Chambers however argued that Mr Ravi’s mental condition was a mitigating rather than an exculpatory factor which would absolve him from the consequences of his act. This was the position held by the High Court judges in the disciplinary proceedings.

In response, Mr Ravi said that the prosecution have to prove contempt of court beyond a reasonable doubt. Mens rea is required for a conviction.

Mr Ravi told Justice Hoo that Singapore signed and ratified the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. He said that the prosecution had taken a clinical approach to dealing with persons with disabilities and had not produced any precedent where a person with disabilities has been charged for contempt of court. He submitted that the burden of proof on the prosecution is very high and he should be treated as a vulnerable person and that “only a sick society would kick a sick person.”

Mr Ravi also explained that when he uttered the words “You can be removed but not the High Court” to District Judge Chay, he was verbalising the structural deficiency regarding the appointment of State Court judges who, unlike High Court judges, did not have security of tenure and can be removed and sent to the Attorney-General Chambers during his term of office.

The hearing has been adjourned. Justice Hoo said there may be a pre-trial conference for further directions. The prosecution have reserved their submission on sentence should Mr Ravi be judged to be in contempt of court.

This was first published on Teo Soh Lung’s Facebook page.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Will Josephine Teo continue to fund SMT at S$180m a year after the revelation of SMT “faking” its circulation data?

At the Parliamentary sitting on 15 February last year, the Minister for…

Changi Airport Group reported earnings of S$33 million in FY2023, bounced from previous S$838 million net loss

Singapore’s Changi Airport Group (CAG) sees a financial turnaround with net earnings of $33 million for fiscal year ending March 2023, up from last year’s net loss of $838 million. This comes as passenger traffic increased to 62% of pre-pandemic levels. However, operating expenses rose by 42% due to increased business activities and higher energy costs. Despite potential challenges, CAG aims to reach pre-COVID traffic levels by 2024 while focusing on sustainable travel and innovation.

Death of 77-year-old man in Toa Payoh Flat unveiled amid withered plants and foul odor

A 77-year-old uncle was found dead inside his Toa Payoh flat after neighbors reported a foul smell resembling that of a decomposing corpse. Preliminary investigations indicate no criminal activity. A neighbour remembers the man’s love for gardening, but she hadn’t seen him for about two weeks and observed his outdoor potted plants wilting over the past week.