On Thursday (18 March), the Ministry of Culture, Community and Youth invited Mr Joey Mendoza to substantiate his claims that he wrote the song “We Can Achieve” in 1983, before “Count on Me, Singapore” was created in 1986.

In its Facebook post, MCCY said: “Given that the two songs, and their lyrics, are practically identical, and that we hold the copyright to “Count on Me, Singapore”, we are puzzled by this claim.”

This is in relation to the ongoing plagiarism fiasco where the song, “We Can Achieve” has shown up in multiple videos online with the lyrics being almost word-for-word to the 1986 Singaporean version.

The Indian version simply changes all mentions of “Singapore” to “India” or “Mother India”.

Multiple versions of the song had been uploaded online sometime between July last year and January this year, but one version was uploaded on YouTube in August last year.

In the credits, the song was attributed to an individual named Joey Mendoza and the company that uploaded it is was named Pauline Communications.

The Indian public relations (PR) firm has come forward to say that it had bought the rights to the music and lyrics of local patriotic song ‘Count on Me Singapore’ from a man who claimed to own it.

MCCY reiterated in its post that the Government of Singapore holds the copyright to the music and lyrics of “Count on Me, Singapore”, ad noted the acknowledgement of Pauline Communications that the Indian version was substantially copied from Singapore’s version.

The Ministry also noted the PR firm’s clarification that it was unaware that “Count on Me, Singapore” had been Singapore’s national song since 1986.

The Ministry continued, “Whilst “Count on Me, Singapore” is one of our most beloved national songs, we are also happy that it seems to have been well appreciated in India, with the video showing teachers and students in a school performing the song, and expressing their love for their own country.

“We do not think any ill will was intended either by Pauline India or the school, and have accepted the apology.”

However, Mr Mendoza said in a statement to the media on Wednesday (17 March) that while he recognised that there are similarities between both songs except for the words “India” and “Mother India” in place of “Singapore”, he thought it could be a coincidence.

“There was no way I or the other composer could know that things would look so similar. (And no INTERNET ACCESS) With due respect to the other composer there are so many phrases that musically were connected and it could be all coincidental,” Mr Mendoza said.

He also said that he only found out about ‘Count On Me Singapore’ a few days ago

 

 

Subscribe
Notify of
31 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

General manager of PAP town council removed from duties and placed under CPIB investigations

Straits Times on the early morning of Friday released the news of the…

涉嫌抛弃新生男婴 印尼女子将被控上庭

涉嫌将新生男婴抛弃在私宅外的垃圾桶而被逮捕,29岁印尼籍女子周四(7月30日)将被控上庭。 警方发文告指出,在7月27日晚上7时47分,警方接获弃婴投报。报案人表示在大庆花园一带,一家住宅外的垃圾桶内发现一名新生男婴。 男婴身上并没有明显伤痕,且在被发现后就已经被送到竹脚妇孺医院,目前情况稳定。 据英文时评网站“慈母舰”(Mothership.sg)报导,目击者的丈夫当时听到住宅外一个垃圾桶内发出声音,起初还以为是流浪猫狗,但是很快就发现是个新生儿。目击者表示,男婴被发现时并没有哭泣,指示发出微弱的声音,被白布包裹着。 宏茂桥警署警员之后透过调阅电眼画面及展开调查后,确认了该印尼女子的身份后将她逮捕,并怀疑嫌犯就是男婴的亲生母亲。 警方目前仍在调查男婴的生父身份。警方也感谢民众提供线索以便尽早破案,并将嫌犯绳之以法。 若弃婴罪名成立,嫌犯可能面对不超过七年的监刑,或罚款,或两者兼施。

马国部长议员公布财产 工程部长月收入最高 逾3.5万新元

马来西亚反贪污委员会,今日在官网公布希盟政府内阁部长和国会议员的收入。其中,每月收入最高者为工程部长巴鲁比安,达到10万8056令吉(约3万5685新元),其次就是财政部长林冠英(2万8544元)。 首相敦马则位居第四,即7万5861令吉(约2万5052元)。假设有第十三个月花红,预计其年收入可高达32万5676元。另外,副首相阿兹莎的月收入为5万9048令吉(约1万9500新元)。 马国反贪会声称,要求议员申报财产,旨在使政府领导更为透明,民众可查阅和得知政府公务员和议员的财产状况。 根据反贪会网站,目前已申报财产的希盟议员多达82人、有官职者多达40人,尚有13内阁成员未申报。 网站显示一些议员有申报配偶和孩子的收入,但所公佈的是有关议员的个人每月收入,并不包括他们家人的收入。 这些收入包括了有关国会议员的每月薪金、津贴和其他收入。 网站也注明由於存在技术问题,网站目前只显示总收入,而问题解决后,才能显示与財產所有权相关的更详细信息。 最低月入议员逾五千新元 月收入第二高的是財长林冠英,他也是峇眼国会议员和亚逸布爹州议员。第三名为贸消部长拿督斯里赛夫丁纳苏申,为7万7629令吉。 在所有已呈报財產的国会议员中,甲洞国会议员林立迎月收入最少,仅为1万5850令吉(约5千234新元)。 原本反贪会定于10月15日公布议员财产,不过为了给更多部长和议员有时间申报,才展延至今日才公布。 假设一名马国普通公务员月收入是3500令吉,加上一个月花红,年收入约为4万5500令吉。与收入最高的工程部长巴鲁比安140万4728令吉的年收入对比,薪资差距约为30倍。

SPF: Facebook message of child kidnapped at Jurong Point Shopping Centre not true

The police have responded to the message circulating on Facebook about a…