The Progress Singapore Party (PSP) member Harish Pillay has weighed in on the recent revelation of police being given access to data collected from TraceTogether (TT) programme for criminal investigations, which was announced by Minister of State for Home Affairs Desmond Tan in Parliament on Monday (4 January).

During the Parliament session, Mr Tan explained that police is empowered under the Criminal Procedure Code (CPC) to get hold of any data, and that includes the data gathered from TraceTogether.

Responding to this, Mr Pillay expressed in a post published on his blog on Wednesday (6 January), that he felt “let down” by the Government for going against its earlier assurance that TT will solely be used for contact tracing purposes in order to contain the spread of COVID-19 in Singapore.

During a Multi-Ministry Taskforce (MTF) press conference on 8 June last year, Education Minister Lawrence Wong, who co-chairs the MTF, and Minister-in-charge of the Smart Nation Initiative Vivian Balakrishnan both stressed that data from the TraceTogether app and token would not be used for anything else other than for the purposes of contact tracing.

Dr Balakrishnan was quoted saying then: “TraceTogether app, TraceTogether running on a device, and the data generated is purely for contact tracing. Period.”

Before that, on 5 June last year, Dr Balakrishnan gave the same response to MP Murali Pillai in Parliament when the latter questioned the confidentiality of the data collected.

Despite initially saying that TT will only be used for the purposes of contact tracing, Dr Balakrishnan clarified in Parliament on Tuesday (4 January) that police can get TT data for criminal cases.

Commenting on this, Mr Pillay suggested that a bill should be introduced to exempt TT data from Criminal Procedure Code (CDC), only for as long as this pandemic lasts.

“It is time bound and very specific and targeted. I am very sure, the police investigators would not need additional TT Data to help with their investigations,” said Mr Pillay, who works with global open source communities and government technology policy makers in driving policies and setting direction for open source technologies that are driving disruptive changes globally.

He continued, “I do not, honestly, think that excluding CPC access to this data will hinder criminal investigations. The records are valid only for 25 days and the accused person could have deleted the app and hence data,” adding that other means like CCTVs and phone records can help police gather information for criminal cases.

Technical aspects to TT App, TT token and SafeEntry

In the post, Mr Pillay, who is the founder of Red Hat Singapore, extensively explained about the technical aspects of TT App, TT token and SafeEntry (SE), and how data gathered from these three platforms may not be very helpful to the police when it comes to investigating a criminal case.

The PSP member explained that TT contact data is stored at three different places – the TT App’s database, exchanged IDs from other phones or tokens, and the Ministry of Health (MOH) or GovTech servers.

He went on to note that only the last 25 days of contact data remains in the user’s phone’s database, and all that information will be only sent to MOH or GovTech if the person is infected with COVID-19 given that actual contact tracing needs to take place.

Based on this, Mr Pillay said that there are different scenarios in which the TT data may not be useful for the police.

Some of the scenarios include criminal deleting all data from their phone, or deleting the app altogether and destroying the token, as well as police apprehending them after 25 days of committing the crime. All these situations will bring the police to a deadend in their investigation even with the access of TT data, Mr Pillay said.

Separately, he also highlighted that the SE is not an accurate indicator of individuals who have been in close contact with a COVID-19 patient since it only scans the QR code of a location.

“Nothing in SE suggests proximity to others other than perhaps time of scanning of the QR code – which is still not a accurate indicator because the QR scanning could be done at entrance of the facility and the person does not enter but leaves,” he said.

If that’s not all, the PSP member also voiced concern on GovTech assuring one’s privacy as it does not track location.

“Now, while the large granularity of SE’s location information is still there, the fact that one has to use the TT App for that, does throw some caution to the statement from GovTech that TT App honours privacy in that it does not track location.

“This exclusive functioning of SE scanning only via TT App, does taint the TT App’s privacy stance – even if it does not actually store the location info in the phone,” he said.

“SE broke the privacy fallacy/bubble and it is indeed disappointing to see how TT App with SE has evolved.”

 

 

 

Subscribe
Notify of
3 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

ICT make-up pay: Part-time workers shortchanged?

Leong Sze Hian Full-time workers who are called up for In-camp training…

为母则强! 曾笳恩分享准妈妈回国经历

冠状病毒19疫情导致新马之间一度需关闭边境,也苦了往来两国的人民,尤其是妈妈和准妈妈们。 马国士都兰州议员曾笳恩在脸书上,分享了一名待产妈妈佩玲的辛苦经历,并赞誉到“为母则强”。 帖文中指出,这名准妈妈原本打算回到马来西亚生产,而曾笳恩和团队们则已经和新加坡移民及关卡局取得联系。然而,计划赶不上变化,孩子在回国数天前,就迫不及待的在新加坡出生了。 他指出,面对有关的变动,佩玲依然决定回到马国,因此在坐月子中,她和先生忙于为孩子处理报生纸、护照申请和回国后居家隔离等手续。 他也不忘补充,虽然回国路艰难,但是还是有不少新马官员给予帮助和优待这名妈妈。“生活给了他们诸多挑战,他们都一一克服,母子两人回国前,通过移民局的交通协助,顺利通关抵达检测中心,官员也优先让他们进行检测。” 曾笳恩感慨地指出,经过一个月的奔波劳累,佩玲和宝宝终回到马国,并且是在宝宝满月的隔日,他和团队也到现场去为两人送上祝福。 在贴文的评论区中,不少网民对曾笳恩及团队所付出的努力表示赞扬。 疑似帖文主角的佩玲Denise Pei Lin,也在评论区中,对曾笳恩和美女助理的帮助表示感谢。

Percussion instruments will be allowed to be played in Thaipusam for first time since 1973

The Singapore Police Force said in a statement to media on Wednesday…

CPF Board: Not withdrawing $140K would have given man monthly payouts of $1K or more after 65

Clifford Theseira, 72, has earlier wrote on his Facebook page relating that…