Comments
Netizens describe S’pore as “toxic rat race environment”, only the change of citizens’ mindset and the Govt’ policies can help to tackle low fertility rate
In an opinion piece published by TODAY online last Thursday (22 October), titled “To boost fertility rate, do more to lower costs of raising children”, a member of public, Peter Heng Teck Wee penned his opinions suggesting the Government to implement “a holistic fertility policy” that go beyond existing handouts and subsidies in order to tackle the low fertility rate of the country.
Mr Heng, who has three young children and was a past beneficiary of Baby Bonus scheme, firstly lauded the recently announced Baby Support Grant of S$3,000 as it will provide additional relief to the parents amid this trying times.
Despite saying that the overall financial support given to parents is “substantial” – which range between $21,000 and $35,000 per child, Mr Heng however lamented that the financial support may only be “a drop in the ocean” as compared with the high total cost of raising a child in Singapore.
To prove this, he cited the data from SmartParents which estimated that the cost of raising a child in Singapore was more than S$670,000 before inflation.
“The high total cost of raising children here may explain why, generous handouts notwithstanding, Singapore’s total fertility rate has steadily trended lower, reaching a nadir of 1.14 in the past two years,” Mr Heng noted.
He continued, “To reverse this trend, our fertility policies must go beyond existing handouts and subsidies and address the expense side of the ledger.”
He thus suggested that a number of Certificates of Entitlement (COE) should be “set aside” for the parents with young children and the foreign domestic worker levy should also be waived for such parents.
Besides this, Mr Heng also said that the measures aimed at reducing childhood expenses “need not be at the expense of state coffers”.
“For example, we can tackle the tuition arms race at the primary school level by replacing competitive exams (that is, the Primary School Leaving Examination) with balloting for entry into secondary schools,” he said.
He also proposed to set “minimum nutritional standards” for pre-school meals and school canteens in order to reduce the number of visits to paediatricians.
“A holistic fertility policy which incorporates smart cost-saving measures can be more effective and sustainable than one which relies solely on one-off handouts.
“Raising children is, after all, a lifelong commitment,” he noted.
Earlier on 14 October, the Second Minister for Finance Indranee Rajah revealed in Parliament that Singapore’s total fertility rate was 1.14 in 2019, which is “below replacement”.
Concerning the low fertility rate, the Government had in place some measures such as providing financial supports to the parents including Baby Support Grant, Baby Bonus Cash Gift, Child Development Account, and MediSave Grant for Newborns.
As for the recently announced Baby Support Grant, it is a one-off grant of S$3,000 for the parents of infants born from 1 October 2020 to 30 September 2022.
According to the National Population and Talent Division (NPTD) of the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO), the Grant is on top of the Baby Bonus Cash Gift worth up to S$10,000 that aims to help couples defray child-raising costs amid these extraordinary times due to COVID-19 pandemic.
Netizens call S’pore as “toxic rat race environment” that discourage S’poreans from giving birth
On the issue of low fertility rate, most of the netizens, however, held different views with the writer. Describing Singapore as “toxic rat race environment”, the netizens said that the mindset of citizens that not willing to compromise their lifestyle, and their commitments in work have discouraged them from giving birth in this competitive country.
A netizen also commented that the Government policy and assistance plays a “decisive factor in giving a conducive environment” for the couples in Singapore to build a new family.
Instead of saying this is the responsibility to the Government, other netizens felt that raising a child should be a “shared responsibility between a couple”. They opined that “monetary incentives is secondary”, compared to the “lifestyle change” and “the parents’ sacrifice” which must be made to raise a child.
Meanwhile a handful of netizens pointed out that “the real killers” are the baby products- and services-related industries as they will seize the chance to increase their products prices when the Government increase grants and handouts to the parents.
Standing on the side of writer, a couple of netizens agreed that “every single little help” from the Government such as increase subsidy for infant care and school fees definitely counts in reducing costs of raising a child and consequently helping to boost the birth rates.
Recounting their experience, another two netizens seemed to have tough times in taking care of their children and working to sustain the livelihood at a time.
Comments
LHL’s 15-minute visit to Dr Lee Wei Ling’s wake raises eyebrows among Singaporeans
On the evening of 10 October, Senior Minister Lee Hsien Loong and his wife, Ho Ching, attended Dr Lee Wei Ling’s wake, staying for about 10-15 minutes. This brief visit sparked online discussions about the custom of family members remaining throughout the day at funerals.
On Thursday evening (10 October), Singapore’s mainstream media, stationed outside Singapore Casket where Dr Lee Wei Ling’s wake was held, reported the arrival of Senior Minister Lee Hsien Loong and his wife, Ho Ching, to attend his sister’s funeral.
Dr Lee, the daughter of Singapore’s founding Prime Minister, Lee Kuan Yew, passed away on 9 October at the age of 69, at her family home at 38 Oxley Road.
Her wake is being held at Singapore Casket from 10 October to 12 October.
According to Lianhe Zaobao, SM Lee and Mdm Ho arrived outside Singapore Casket at around 8.30 pm.
They reportedly stayed at the wake for about 10 minutes and did not provide any comments to the media.
In contrast, the South China Morning Post reported that SM Lee and Mdm Ho stayed for approximately 15 minutes before leaving.
A member of the public who paid respects to Dr Lee shared with TOC that SM Lee had written a simple “RIP” in the condolences book.
Mr Li Yipeng, the eldest son of Senior Minister Lee Hsien Loong, also attended Dr Lee’s wake earlier.
Observing comments on social media, some users questioned the brevity of SM Lee’s visit to his sister’s wake.
One user remarked that even attending a friend’s funeral typically lasts at least 30 minutes, asking, “Where can you find a brother who attends his sister’s funeral for just 15 minutes?”
Others pointed out that it is customary for family members to stay the entire day at a funeral, particularly the eldest brother, who usually greets visitors and offers hospitality, such as refreshments.
“That’s what family members do,” one user noted.
A netizen lamented that instead of receiving guests at his sister’s wake, LHL appeared as a VIP guest accompanied by bodyguards.
Another user expressed sadness over the situation, noting that the eldest brother was attending the wake like any other outsider.
The comment highlighted that Lee Hsien Yang, the younger brother, was organizing the funeral remotely and could not return.
This led to a broader question among netizens: Would LHL attend his own brother’s funeral if he were to pass first?
Some netizens disagreed with the criticism of LHL’s attendance at his sister’s wake, arguing that, regardless of public sentiment towards the government, this is a personal matter.
One comment emphasised the need for objectivity, stating that people cannot judge LHL solely based on appearances or media reports.
He questioned what LHL might have done for his sister behind the scenes and pointed out that even if he had stayed longer, some would still find fault with his actions.
A comment on Reddit expressed that while LHL doesn’t necessarily need to be invited, his absence from receiving mourners as the eldest family member suggests he was not asked or instructed to participate in the funeral proceedings at all.
A netizen lamented that family disputes deeply affect one’s soul, particularly when reconciliation with a sibling is impossible, even in death.
The Reddit comment emphasised the emotional pain that arises from being reminded of happy childhood moments during such difficult times.
Comments
Netizens: Was Ho Ching smirking before entering Dr Lee Wei Ling’s funeral?
On 10 October at around 8.30 PM, Senior Minister Lee Hsien Loong and his wife, Ho Ching, were spotted arriving at Dr Lee Wei Ling’s funeral. While Singaporeans mourned Dr Lee’s passing, some netizens, after viewing media footage, questioned whether Mdm Ho was smirking before entering the funeral.
Dr Lee Wei Ling, the daughter of Singapore’s founding Prime Minister, Lee Kuan Yew, passed away on 9 October at the age of 69, at her family home at 38 Oxley Road.
Lee Hsien Yang (LHY), Dr Lee’s brother, announced her passing on social media, and had earlier requested that the wake and funeral remain a private affair.
He also noted that respects could be paid on a strict queue basis, adding, “There will be no exceptions, not even for VIPs,” to ensure that everyone is treated equally during the visitation period.
The wake is being held at the Pearl & Sapphire Hall of Singapore Casket, located at 131 Lavender Street, Singapore. Public visitation is open from 2 PM to 10 PM on 10 October, and from 10 AM to 10 PM on 11 October. The final visitation period is scheduled for 10 AM to 1 PM on 12 October.
Despite the request for privacy, mainstream media (MSM) representatives have gathered outside the Singapore Casket building.
MSM reporters are focused on whether Dr Lee’s elder brother, Senior Minister Lee Hsien Loong, will attend her funeral.
On Thursday (10 October ) at around 8.30pm, MSM spotted Senior Minister Lee and his wife, Ho Ching, entering Singapore Casket.
According to Lianhe Zaobao, SM Lee and his wife stayed at the wake for about 10 minutes and did not provide any comments to the media.
Comments on social media pages of various media outlets show Singaporeans pouring in with condolence messages, remembering Dr Lee’s contributions to Singapore’s medical field.
They praised her as a low-profile and modest woman, despite being a President’s Scholar and the Head of the Neurology Department.
Many noted how much she resembled her mother, who also shunned the limelight, even at their funerals.
However, some netizens, after viewing videos and photos taken by mainstream media, questioned whether Mdm Ho Ching was smirking before entering Dr Lee’s funeral.
Netizens Urge Media and Public to Give Grieving Family Space
Some netizens disagreed with the speculation surrounding Mdm Ho Ching’s expression in the media footage, urging others to refrain from making unfounded assumptions.
They called for compassion, emphasizing the need to give the grieving family some space.
Some netizens also recalled the Lee family feud surrounding the 38 Oxley Road house, where Dr Lee and LHY accused their brother, SM Lee, of opposing their father’s wish to have the house demolished after his passing.
One netizen lamented the strained relationship within the Lee family, questioning why there was supposed to be a sense of family, yet it felt more like guests attending the wake.
Another commented on the fact that SM Lee and his wife attended the wake rather than being involved in arranging it, especially given that Dr Lee was unmarried and their parents are no longer around, “it says alot about their relationship.”
One netizen speculated that Dr Lee might be SM Lee’s greatest regret in life, as he had failed to mend his relationship with her.
The comment added, “Attend or not attend his sister’s wake doesn’t really matter since the person had already gone.”
Meanwhile, some netizens questioned the media’s actions, pointing out that despite LHY’s request for no media coverage, reporters were still camping outside Dr Lee’s funeral.
-
Comments2 weeks ago
Netizens question Ho Ching’s praise for Chee Hong Tat’s return from overseas trip for EWL disruption
-
Singapore2 weeks ago
Lee Hsien Yang pays S$619,335 to Ministers Shanmugam and Balakrishnan in defamation suit to protect family home
-
Singapore2 weeks ago
Train services between Jurong East and Buona Vista to remain disrupted until 1 Oct due to new cracks on East-West Line
-
Comments1 week ago
Netizens push back on Ho Ching’s 8-10 million population vision and call for more foreigners
-
Singapore2 weeks ago
Full-time NSF found unconscious in camp dies; MINDEF says death not training related
-
Singapore1 week ago
Commuters face service disruption on TEL due to train fault following 6-day EWL disruption
-
Comments1 week ago
Dr Chee Soon Juan criticises Ho Ching’s vision for 8-10 million population
-
Singapore1 week ago
PM Lawrence Wong reaffirms government’s commitment to integrity after ex-minister Iswaran’s jail sentence