• About Us
    • Fact Checking Policy
    • Ownership & funding information
    • Volunteer
  • Subscribe
  • Letter submission
    • Submissions Policy
  • Contact Us
The Online Citizen Asia
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Commentaries
    • Letters
    • Comments
  • Current Affairs
    • Singapore
    • Malaysia
    • Indonesia
    • China
    • ASEAN
    • Asia
    • International
  • Finance
    • Economics
    • Labour
    • Property
    • Business
  • Community
    • Arts & Culture
    • Consumer Watch
    • NGO
    • Lifestyle
    • Travel
  • Politics
    • Civil Society
    • Parliament
    • Transport
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Housing
  • Law & Order
    • Legislation
    • Court Cases
No Result
View All Result
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Commentaries
    • Letters
    • Comments
  • Current Affairs
    • Singapore
    • Malaysia
    • Indonesia
    • China
    • ASEAN
    • Asia
    • International
  • Finance
    • Economics
    • Labour
    • Property
    • Business
  • Community
    • Arts & Culture
    • Consumer Watch
    • NGO
    • Lifestyle
    • Travel
  • Politics
    • Civil Society
    • Parliament
    • Transport
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Housing
  • Law & Order
    • Legislation
    • Court Cases
No Result
View All Result
The Online Citizen Asia
No Result
View All Result

Prosecution’s failure to call material witnesses to rebut accused’s defence saves accused from death penalty

Court of Appeal expands Prosecution's duty of disclosure to include statements of material witnesses capable of contradicting accused's defence

by Guo Rendi
31/03/2020
in Court Cases, Crime, Law & Order
Reading Time: 4 mins read
0

The Court of Appeal has overturned the conviction of a death-row inmate on two capital drug trafficking charges on Tuesday (31st March) morning, finding that the Prosecution’s failure to call material witnesses to rebut his defence effectively undermined their own case.

Instead, Muhammad Nabill bin Mohd Fuad will only have to spend 8 years in prison for a single charge of possession of 63.41g of diamorphine simpliciter, the imprisonment term being backdated to his remand on 27th January 2016.

His appeal against the drug trafficking charges, which concerned the same amount of diamorphine and 2,251.90g of cannabis respectively, was heard in August last year and judgment was reserved.

In reserving judgment then, the Court of Appeal – comprising Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon, Judge of Appeal Judith Prakash and Judge of Appeal Steven Chong – had directed the parties to file further submissions on the following question:

“Where a witness has had a statement taken from him by the police or the CNB, and where the defence mounted by an accused person can be expected to be either confirmed or contradicted by that witness, is there a duty on the part of the Prosecution either to call that witness to testify, or to make available to the Defence copies of that witness’ statements?”

Nabill, who was a methamphetamine addict, lived together with his wife Mashitta, his cousin Sufian and a domestic helper in his flat at the material time. His supply of methamphetamine originated from his friend, one Faizal. On the night before Nabill’s arrest, Faizal brought a red trolley bag to the flat, which was placed in the storeroom by the helper while Nabill was apparently asleep and had no knowledge of such.

Nabill’s account was that on the next day, he saw several packets of diamorphine laid out on the bed in the bedroom occupied by Sufian, as well as the red trolley bag (which he thought contained cigarettes) in the storeroom. He asked Faizal and Sufian to come to his flat and “clear the stuff” and both men agreed. Later that night, Nabill was arrested by the officers from the Central Narcotics Bureau (CNB), who seized the diamorphine from the wardrobe in the bedroom and the red trolley bag containing cannabis, as well as forty cartons of cigarettes.

Nabill was convicted and sentenced to death on both charges by Judicial Commissioner Audrey Lim in November 2018, after she disbelieved his account and find that he was not a mere courier. She also disagreed with the Defence’s contention that statements recorded from Mashitta, Sufian, Faizal and the helper by the CNB should have been disclosed by the Prosecution to the Defence.

As CJ Menon took 20 minutes to read out his oral summary of the judgment, Nabill’s family and relatives present at the gallery were elated at the outcome of Nabill no longer facing the death penalty.

In essence, the Court of Appeal agreed with the parties that the Prosecution is under an obligation to disclose a material witness’ statements, i.e. witnesses that can be expected to confirm or contradict an accused person’s defence, and such obligations continued all the way until the proceedings against an accused person (including appeals) had been disposed of.

The court also held that while there was no legal duty on the part of Prosecution to call material witnesses, there may be circumstances where the failure on the Prosecution’s part to call such witnesses might mean that it has failed to discharge its evidential burden to rebut an accused person’s defence.

The Prosecution would not need to call such witnesses if there were other evidence it could rely on, or the accused person’s case was patently or inherently incredible to begin with.

In Nabill’s case, the Prosecution’s failure to call Faizal and Sufian as witnesses despite both men being in CNB’s custody, meant that Nabill’s account was effectively unrebutted, and that he had rebutted the presumptions under the Misuse of Drugs Act (presumption of trafficking under section 17 in relation to the diamorphine, and presumption of knowledge under s 18(2) in relation to the cannabis).

Nabill’s DNA found on the diamorphine packets can also be reasonably explained by two other possibilities: firsly, that he had placed the diamorphine packets laid out on the bed into the box which he then placed in the wardrobe.

One of the officers handling the drugs at that time, though wearing gloves, might not have been wear a mask at that time, giving rise to his DNA spotted on the drugs; by parity of reasoning, Nabill’s saliva could also have spreaded to the diamorphine packets as his contemporaneous statements were recorded there.

For just US$7.50 a month, sign up as a subscriber on The Online Citizen Asia (and enjoy ads-free experience on our site) to support our mission to transform TOC into an alternative mainstream press.

Related Posts

Adani’s brother runs SG company and registers as director with local ID
Current Affairs

Adani’s brother runs SG company and registers as director with local ID

03/02/2023
Minister Tan See Leng only reveals 500 intra-corporate transferees from India for last year – a Covid year
Opinion

Increasing number of working Permanent Residents in Singapore but with a stable PR population

03/02/2023
Opinion

A multi-party parliament is the only way to make sure that Singapore continues to not condone or tolerate corruption

03/02/2023
Anwar criticised over appointing own daughter as his senior advisor
Malaysia

Anwar criticised over appointing own daughter as his senior advisor

03/02/2023
Level of unemployment in Indonesia shows failure in the Job Creation Law, says KSPI
Indonesia

Level of unemployment in Indonesia shows failure in the Job Creation Law, says KSPI

02/02/2023
Commentaries

The Keppel bribery scandal tests Singapore’s zero-tolerance policy towards corruption

02/02/2023
Subscribe
Connect withD
Login
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
Notify of
Connect withD
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Latest posts

Adani’s brother runs SG company and registers as director with local ID

Adani’s brother runs SG company and registers as director with local ID

03/02/2023
Minister Tan See Leng only reveals 500 intra-corporate transferees from India for last year – a Covid year

Increasing number of working Permanent Residents in Singapore but with a stable PR population

03/02/2023

A multi-party parliament is the only way to make sure that Singapore continues to not condone or tolerate corruption

03/02/2023
Anwar criticised over appointing own daughter as his senior advisor

Anwar criticised over appointing own daughter as his senior advisor

03/02/2023
Level of unemployment in Indonesia shows failure in the Job Creation Law, says KSPI

Level of unemployment in Indonesia shows failure in the Job Creation Law, says KSPI

02/02/2023

The Keppel bribery scandal tests Singapore’s zero-tolerance policy towards corruption

02/02/2023
Singapore Law Watch removes commentary on CPIB’s decision to not prosecute former Keppel executives

Singapore Law Watch removes commentary on CPIB’s decision to not prosecute former Keppel executives

02/02/2023
US businesses ‘fear internet curbs in Hong Kong’

Hong Kong offers free flights after COVID isolation

02/02/2023

Trending posts

Former Singaporean shares change of life in Australia with annual pay of S$80,000 as a plumber

Former Singaporean shares change of life in Australia with annual pay of S$80,000 as a plumber

by Yee Loon
30/01/2023
25

...

Earning only S$400 a month, delivery-rider turned hawker threw in the towel after two years of running a rojak stall

Earning only S$400 a month, delivery-rider turned hawker threw in the towel after two years of running a rojak stall

by Yee Loon
26/01/2023
24

...

They have done a fine job of confusing us about the jobs situation

They have done a fine job of confusing us about the jobs situation

by Augustine Low
01/02/2023
36

...

Two Indian nationals paid about S$330 and S$730 respectively for forged certificates submitted in their S-Pass application

MOM found issuing EPs meant for foreign PMETs to PRC waitress and general worker

by Correspondent
26/01/2023
41

...

Singapore warns slower economic growth in 2023

Less than 1 in 10 jobs created in first three quarters of 2022 went to Singaporeans?

by Leong Szehian
28/01/2023
69

...

Excessively charging for an essential need, and calling it affordable because people still can pay for it?

by Terry Xu
31/01/2023
39

...

March 2020
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031  
« Feb   Apr »

The Online Citizen is a regional online publication based in Taiwan and formerly Singapore’s longest-running independent online media platform.

Navigation

  • Editorial
  • Commentaries
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Community

Support

  • Contact Us
  • Letter submission
  • Membership subscription

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Fact Checking Policy
  • Privacy Policy

© 2022 - 2023 The Online Citizen Asia

No Result
View All Result
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Commentaries
    • Comments
  • Current Affairs
    • Malaysia
    • Indonesia
    • China
    • ASEAN
    • Asia
    • International
  • Finance
    • Economics
    • Labour
    • Property
    • Business
  • Community
    • Civil Society
    • Arts & Culture
    • Consumer Watch
    • NGO
  • Politics
    • Parliament
    • Transport
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Housing
  • Law & Order
    • Legislation
    • Court Cases
  • Lifestyle
    • Travel
  • Subscribers login

© 2022 - 2023 The Online Citizen Asia

wpDiscuz