Economist Yeoh Lam Keong said that the portrayal of countries with unemployment insurance (UI) inaccurate having persistently high unemployment is inaccurate at best and misleading at worst”.

This was one of the three points that Mr Yeoh had outlined in response to the parliament exchange between Minister of Manpower Josephine Teo and Worker’s Party (WP) MP Sylvia Lim who had proposed that UI be implemented for older workers who have been retrenched.

In his Facebook post on 27 February —  the former GIC Chief Economist, explained that 25 out of 27 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development  (OECD) developed countries operated an unemployment insurance system including countries with low unemployment. The examples he listed include Germany, Japan, Switzerland, Korea and Taiwan—some of which are more competitive expert economies and have lower unemployment when compared to Singapore.

Next, Mr Yeoh pointed out that there is “little evidence of an inefficient reduction in incentive to work in properly designed UI systems” as claimed by Ms Teo.

“In fact, the labour market evidence shows that UI for about 3 months enables optimum job search that prevents workers from jumping at the first job that may not be such a good match for their skills or experience,” said the veteran economist.

Finally, he said, “Minister Teo seems oblivious to the trend that artificial intelligence is already increasingly replacing both unskilled and skilled workers and consigning them to a gig economy of much more frequent job shifts, often with lesser paying work.”

Mr Yeoh elaborated that there are en estimated 25,000 to 30,000 households that fall into poverty at any one time due to involuntary unemployment, adding that the lack of an automatic unemployment protection system will cause many to “fall through the cracks” of the country’s Commcare and skills retraining systems.

He concluded, “Not putting in place an intelligent unemployment protection system is thus short sighted, inhumane and just poor manpower policy, [in my honest opinion].”

However, Mr Yeoh also credited Ms Teo for her promise to “keep an open mind” on the issue.

“Let’s hope it is open enough to see the above arguments and the big picture that Singapore still lags the developed world in many areas of much needed social protection,” he said.

Apology for “mis-reporting” Ms Teo

Mr Yeoh apologised yesterday (1 March) on Facebook for “mis-reporting” Ms Teo and “confusing The Independent and perhaps the public”.

Mr Yeoh was referring to his post on 27 February which was then reported on by online local news site The Independent the next day, which the economist said used a “sensationalistic and inaccurate headline quote” from him which was “lifted entirely out of context”. The economist said that he strongly objects to and disagrees with that headline.

He explained further down,

“The full quote should be :

“ Unfortunately Manpower Minister Josephine Teo does not seem to have sufficient understanding of labour market economics to understand the important need for unemployment insurance in Singapore for at least three reasons” which has quite a different, specific and qualified meaning.

Mr Yeoh added, “For the record, I did not mean to say that Minister Teo’s overall understanding of labour market economics was insufficient per se.”

Regarding his own mistake in the earlier post, Mr Yeoh quoted the erroneous sentence which was: “Minister Teo’s portrayal that companies with UI “usually have persistently high unemployment “ is inaccurate at best and misleading at worst.”

He explained that he meant to say ‘countries’, not ‘companies’.

He went on to clarify, “Hopefully the very next paragraph conveyed that my intended meaning was clearly “countries” and not “companies”.

Mr Yeoh said he has corrected his original post accordingly and hopes that The Independent would make note of the correction and made the necessary amendments to their article.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Ho Ching says KTV and Geylang nightlife can be reopened as vaccination is now available

Given that the national COVID-19 vaccination programme has kicked off, all KTV…

Busker Jonathan Goh voices frustration over how regulations are being used to to cause issues for unproblematic buskers

A busker, Jonathan Goh, took to Facebook on Thursday (3 October) to…

李函轩中暑身亡案 上尉被控行为鲁莽罪

国民服役人员李函轩中暑身亡案,警方今早把涉案的一名上尉军官,以行为鲁莽罪控上法庭。 被告陈宝树(30岁)案发时是李函轩的长官,他面对一项行为鲁莽导致他人死亡控狀。一旦罪成将被监禁长达五年,或罚款,或两者兼施。 19岁的第一精卫营士兵李函轩,在4月18日参加八公里快步行军后,出现热损伤(heat injury)症状。虽然当场接受降温急救并送院治疗,但经12天抢救后回天乏术,于4月30日在樟宜综合医院过世。 陈宝树是上述快步行军的负责长官,被控在4月18日8.25分至9.10分期间,无法及时判断李函轩的状况,并为他安排有效的治疗。 此外,还有其余六名服役军人被指涉案,正接受国防部的调查。在文告中,国防部表示将暂缓内部审讯,直至陈宝树的刑事诉讼结束。 文告补充如内部调查发现上述六名军人有罪,将依据《武装部队法令》,从施以罚款、拘留或降级等惩罚。 “武装部队认真看待军人的人身安全,如有军人违反军令、故意或疏忽训练安全守则,将依军法在即决审判(Summary trial)普通军事法庭审判并严惩,或在民事法庭下严审并起诉。” 11月28日过堂 被告陈宝树的代表律师向法庭申请四周休庭,案件展延至11月28日过堂,被告以1万元保释。 根据今年8月7日,国防部长黄永宏在国会发布的调查委员会调查结果,李函轩所属单位在事发前玩,在一项体能训练违反《安全训练守则》,没有让士兵获取足够睡眠。…

徐顺全访武吉巴督遭火患单位 居民反映一消防喉无法运作

武吉巴督21街的第210A组屋13楼的一座单位,日前不幸遭火患而焚毁。民主党秘书长徐顺全昨日前往该单位视察。 事故发生在上周五凌晨,由于厨房当时堆积大量物品,限制了民防队员的救灾工作,难以救出现场两名已精疲力尽男子,故此最后民防部队出动60米的登高云梯施救。云梯救援具有一定风险,徐顺全赞扬当局专业地执行救人工作。 以下为当时民防部队出动云梯施救的视频: 不过该区居民告知,火患发生时,该楼的一个消防喉竟无法运作,紧急情况下没有水源可救火! 根据有关消防喉的标签,刚在今年10月经过检修,为此徐顺全表示已致函民防部队申诉此事。 邻里也反映单位外也囤积一些物件,当火灾发生时恐怕会造成救援困难。 今年8月通过防火安全(修正)法案 国会刚在今年8月通过《防火安全(修正)法案》,赋予民防部队更大执法权,包括可对不合规的建筑产品加强执法,民防总监可强制要求建筑业主安装警铃系统和消防喉等重要防火措施。在新条例下,所有新建住宅都需安装家用防火警报器。 当时即已有议员提及组屋走道物品囤积的问题,可能引起火患和阻碍逃生出路的隐忧。 新修正法案通过后,民防部队今后可以将怀疑有防火安全风险的产品,列为不合规格产品或材料,禁止在建筑中使用。