On Facebook today (9 October), retired banker Chris Kuan shared a Straits Times article about President Halimah being briefed by GIC, MAS and Temasek on projected investment returns, a process which she described as “an important one within our annual Budget cycle”.
These estimations would be used to decide the amount of fund from the country’s past reserves that the Government will be able to tap for the upcoming Budget. Under the Net Investment Return framework, the Government is able to take up to 50% of the expected long-term real returns on net assets invested by Temasek, GIC and MAS into the Budget. However, this can only be done after deducting liabilities like government bonds.
MOF explained on its website that by doing so, it makes sure that any tapping of the reserves will be done in a sustainable way, so the future governments will be given a steady stream of returns to support the Budget.
Prior to the beginning of each financial year, GIC, MAS and Temasek will propose the expected long-term real rates of return after looking through the detailed study and assessments brought up by investment professionals within the three agencies. Additionally, external expert views are also obtained.
Following that, the MOF will review the methodologies used to propose the rates, and suggests the expected long-term real rates of return to be applied to the net assets invested by the three agencies.
It is only after that the President will be consulted, along with the CPA, before she decides if she agrees with the Government’s proposal or not.
On his Facebook page, Mr Kuan emphasised that the proposal is based on expected long-term real returns which he notes is problematic in a few ways.
First, Mr Kuan asked, “ How is the President able to challenge the assumptions made by the 3 agencies?”
He explained that President Halimah would not be able to challenge those assumptions given that she is not an investment expert herself and noted that the members of the Council of Presidential Advisers (CPA), “who might through majority vote advise her to accept the proposal”.
“So the idea that the President is the guardian of the reserve seems far more a formality rather than an actual check on the government,” said Mr Kuan.
The second point he made was that there is a better way to carry out this particular part of the process, which Mr Kuan asserted is “too damned opaque for a strategic issue”. He suggested that the expected long term real returns and any changes to it be tabled by Parliament for approval.
“The President’s own stamp is as much a formality as it already is,” he added.
He continued, “Better still, also have any changes in the investment mandate such as increasing the equity portion of the reserves or the private equity portions tabled to Parliament for approval.”
By doing so, Mr Kuan said, elected representatives and citizens will have some idea on the deliberations involved in using the earnings from the reserves to fund state expenditures.
“This is what the Norwegians do when it comes to the mandates for managing the reserves and using the earnings to fund expenditures,” explained Mr Kuan.
He went on to explain that these methods could engender confidence and broad public support when it comes to government finances, and even lessen the use of the Protection from Online Falsehoods and Manipulation Act (POFMA) on the issue.
On 25 November, political activist Brad Bowyer was issued a correction order under POFMA as directed by Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Finance Heng Swee Keat to correct statements he made on a Facebook post about government returns and investments. This is the first correction order to be issued under POFMA since it was gazetted on 25 June 2019.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

国大老龄中心研究:年长就业者反映,收入才是持续工作最主要因素

杜克新加坡国立大学医学院,老龄研究与教育中心(CARE)发布《新加坡健康、就业、社交和代际转移研究》报告,采访了4千549名,60岁以上的年长新加坡人。 报告也调查这些年长受访者的就业/退休情况。调查显示在2016-2017年度,60-69岁年龄阶层中有45巴仙男性和31巴仙女性反映,目前仍在就业。 其中65-69岁年龄群体,有高达77.2巴仙受访者反映,收入是促使他们工作的最主要因素。其次54.2巴仙为“享受工作”,只有32.6巴仙表示工作是为了能继续“维持良好健康”。 有关调查询问受访者目前的就业状况(全职、兼职、退休或从未工作等),以及正在求职的年长者。报告排除了其中469名反映从未工作的受访者。报告也纳入受访者年龄、性别、种族、婚姻情况、教育程度、住房类型和生活情况等因素。 其中,60-64岁群体中,有高达73巴仙男性和51巴仙女性仍在工作,相比下65-69岁只有60巴仙男性和38巴仙女性仍在就业。 高达76.8巴仙年长男性,以及77.5巴仙女性均反映,收入才是促使他们工作的主要因素,只有21巴仙男性受访者反映,工作是为了享受生活。 此外,只有32.4巴仙男性和54.3就业年长女性反映,工作是为了“维持健康”,至于认为工作是为了“打发时间”的受访者更是少之又少,男女性受访者均只有7.6巴仙和2.4巴仙。 报告也指年长者持续工作有收入,有助减少依赖储蓄来应付日常开销。如果劳工被迫离开职场,退休后面对健康和压力的风险更高。 报告也认可年长劳工对经济的贡献,年长与年轻雇员组成的混合工作团队能加强生产力。 报告指出,年长劳工就业课题乃是探讨新加坡社会老龄化现况的其中一项重要层面。    

我国骨痛热症稍有下降 渔港逾20工友相继染病

我国骨痛热症病例虽然在上周有下滑的迹象,自8月9日至15日共累积了1341起病例,但是在裕廊渔港就出现了五个黑斑蚊滋生地点,且一个月内有超过20名工友相继染病。 国家环境局的文告显示,第33周的骨痛热症累积了1341起新病例,比起第32周的1668起新病例少了327起,但是仍然维持在四位数。 然而,当局在裕廊渔港发现了五个黑斑蚊滋生处,包括在水沟、水桶盖和帆布下,而该区一个月内也有逾20名工友相继染上骨痛热症,他们多为居住在渔港临时住宿的马来西亚籍员工。 对此,环境局将对相关单位采取对付行动,而新加坡食品局也加强了灭蚊措施。 据悉,这些染病工友中,有者甚至被感染了两三次,而且他们都是受到两国防疫措施影响而被迫留在本地,并获得当局批准,在渔港的临时住宿居住。 新加坡鱼商总会指出,在陆续传出病例后,渔港的喷雾次数已经有所增加,从原本的每月一次改为每周一次。商会指出,当地居民都有在保持卫生,但是黑斑蚊滋生或受到天气影响,而变得比较快。因 据环境局数据显示,渔港路和惹兰德榜截至上周五,已经累积了29起骨痛热症病例,其中最近两周就有11起病例。 当局致力于减少蚊虫滋生地,然而截至上周,我国骨痛热症病例已经累积超过2万5000起。 因此当局除了加强和市镇理事会的合作,也敦促民众,尤其是居住在蚊症黑区的民众采取三项保护措施,即在家中黑暗部位喷洒杀虫剂、常常使用驱虫剂,以及穿长袖衣和长裤。 此外,当局也发布了两个教育短片,指导民众如何在家中喷洒杀虫剂,以及住在蚊症黑区的居民,若独自在家中看到蚊子,该采取的措施。

网民自发众筹 赠全新电动滑板车予外卖小哥

早前,一名Food Panda外卖递送员在送外卖时,在义顺被陆路交通管理局执法人员拦截,执法人员指他的电动滑板车违规超重而被没收。 几名巨轮滑板车论坛(BWSS)的会员见到此新闻,对外卖小哥遭遇感到同情,担心他失去电动滑板车可能影响工作遂发动群众募资,为外卖小哥集资买一辆全新的滑板车。 购买符合陆交局规格的电动滑板车 其中一名会员Swen Eihhaus在两日前号召热心人士一起集资,在上述论坛获得热烈响应,数名成员即开始讨论需提供何种价码、款式,有者甚至愿意出让自己的二手电动滑板车。 Swen Eihhaus也联系上外卖小哥,了解他正面临财务困难,急需继续送外卖工作,为此决定为外卖小哥众筹一辆符合陆路交通局标准的电动滑板车。 就在隔日,Einhaus为论坛会员更新资讯,指出已成功购置Fiido品牌的电动滑板车,据称是不愿具名善心人士所赞助,以及几名论坛成员协助安装电池和车灯。 至于Einhaus自身募捐的440元也悉数赠给外卖小哥,补偿他的收入损失。他们也在昨晚成功移交全新电动滑板车给外卖小哥。