On 22 November (Friday), the Central Provident Fund (CPF) Board took to its Facebook to reveal that the 56-year-old heart patient who requested to withdraw his CPF fund on medical grounds is actually certified by three doctors to be “suitable for jobs that do not require physical exertion”.

In 2015, Sim Kay Chuan was diagnosed with heart problems and underwent an operation two years ago, leaving his heart’s left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) at 37% performance. The normal LVEF for an individual ranges from 55% to 70%.
Due to his condition, he always feels weak, and the medicine that he takes to lower his blood pressure makes him susceptible to fainting spells even when walking.
Mr Sim has since exhausted his savings as he is unable to work due to his medical condition for the past two years. That’s why he applied to withdraw his CPF to ease his family expenses.
However, the authorities refused his application on the grounds that he did not qualify four conditions.
According to the official website of the CPF Board, in order to apply to withdraw some of your CPF savings on medical grounds, they need to certify that you:

  1. are physically or mentally incapacitated from ever continuing in any employment; or
  2. have a severely impaired life expectancy; or
  3. lack capacity within the meaning of Section 4 of the Mental Capacity Act (MCA) and the lack of capacity is likely to be permanent; or
  4. are terminally ill.

In CPF Board’s letter to Mr Sim in August this year, they said that after checking with the doctor, Mr Sim is “not physically incapacitated from ever continuing in any employment” (emphasis our), and therefore they are unable to process his application to withdraw his CPF Retirement sum of around S$18,000.
In Friday’s post, CPF Board stated Mr Sim’s own doctor made two separate assessments, and certified him “not unfit for employment and is suitable for jobs that do not require exertion”.
Additionally, the Board also engaged two of its own doctors to look through his condition, and “both shared the same assessment as Mr Sim’s own doctor that his medical condition did not meet the criteria for withdrawal on medical grounds”, the Board said.
“National Heart Centre Singapore will reach out to Mr Sim regarding his outstanding bills, and application for financial assistance if needed. We are also aware that local community partners are assisting him,” the authorities pointed out.
They added, “We will continue to work with relevant agencies to assist Mr Sim”.
In a previous TOC article, Mr Sim stated that in the two years since his operation, he has tried applying for work but failed to secure any employment due to his medical condition. He could not take up jobs such as private hire driver either because of his tendency to feel giddy and possible lose consciousness.
Currently, his wife is the sole breadwinner. She works as a welfare coordinator and earns a take-home pay of S$1,800.
To make things worse, the Social Service Office (SSO) also rejected his application for financial assistance on the basis that his wife was still working with a stable income. It wrote, “after careful consideration, we assessed that your family is able to support its basic living expenses.”
Upon reading CPF Board’s response on Friday, many netizens slammed the Board in the comment section of the post. Highlighting their pity for Mr Sim, some online users pointed out that it’s difficult to find a job when you have medical condition as most employers are reluctant to hire you.
Zen Rogue Xuan said, “Employers do require a health declaration when interviewing for a job. HR would think twice before employing people with such medical conditions as it could worsen.”




Some stated that CPF Board’s respond is “cold hearted” and their post also lacks compassion. “You really need to reconsider your strategy,” wrote Kenneth Lee.


On the other hand, a large group of online users also slammed CPF Board as they said that it’s the citizens’ choice on how they want to use their own hard-earned money. They added that this this is not whether Mr Sim is fit to work or not, but rather on how he wish to spend his own CPF fund.
Haz Sah said: “Why can’t CPF just return back our money. Let us handle our own money. If they’re scared we splurge on it, what they need is to just make an agreement. Once finish, they cannot ask the Govt for help. Is that so hard?”

However, a few of them penned their support towards CPF Board for helping to “put things in context”. Tan Ah Chuan said that a lot of people are complaining without knowing the full picture, so it’s good that CPF has “set things straight”.

 

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

前进党透过网络直播 推荐潜在候选人

昨晚(17日),新加坡前进党已进行第四场网络会见选民活动。该党秘书长陈清木医生坦言,参与网络直播的部分前进党党员,将在来届选举上阵。 由于受到疫情影响,各政党也调整接触选民的方式,包括使用网络直播活动。陈清木就表示,过去的会见选民活动,都是面对面与民众见面,但疫情不仅促使政党作出调整,整个国家在多方面也要调适。但他也希望,随着解封迈入第二阶段,能有更多机会接触选民。 “尽管我不认同在近期召开选举,以避免形成群聚和更多接触。如果执政政府要赢得选举,但万一之后面对更大的传播感染,是很令人遗憾的。” 昨晚现身直播活动的就包括陈清木医生本人、前进党中委阮健平、蔡德隆(Michael Chua)、Abas Bin Kasmani、郑财成(Damien Tay)、Kala Manickam、以及孙俊伟(Terence Soon)。 在牛车水长大、求学时期不幸父母离逝,尽管生活艰辛,早期新加坡也还未跻身第一世界国家,但充满关爱精神,人民满怀希望和求上进。 阮健平分享后来他也加入空军、获得武装部队奖学金,在军中以及之后管理跨国企业的经验,也让他意识到当前新加坡显然不在轨道上。…

黄循财:考虑放宽公积金购屋限制 让国人可购买旧组屋

国家发展部长黄循财在昨日(3月7日),参与国会拨款委员会辩论国家发展部开支预算,提及政府考虑放宽使用中央公积金,购买旧的重售组屋限制, 预期将在今年五月公布政策调整详情。 他说,看了一部题为《有楼万事足》的香港纪录片,指出香港年轻人难以圆拥屋梦,当地最便宜的三房式组屋等同44万新元,比新加坡的还贵一倍。他借此传达,相比香港,在我国买房子“并不难”。 黄循财也公布政府有意进行一系列措施,让民众更容易拥屋。 至于等候组屋抽签结果的时间,则从六周减缩到三周;同时会提前半年公布下来推出的预购组屋地点,以方便买家作更明智的购屋申请。 目前用公积金购旧组屋有限制 民众若要购买屋契仅剩60年的组屋,动用公积金会有一定的限制。一些银行也会依据这些限制,来决定贷款的期限。但是,市场上100万间组屋中,有九万间都是屋龄超过40年的组屋。 他提到,公积金的政策乃是确保公积金会员仍有足够的养老储蓄,不过这些限制也带来一些掣肘。 “例如,某买家有意动用全额公积金,购买屋龄39年的组屋,但是到了第二年,可以动用的公积金就会受限。”黄循财认为,屋龄只不过一年之隔,没有理由就要面对限制。 他认为,不应把中心放在组屋屋契的期限,而是确保买家可以买到足够他们终身使用的组屋。所以,即使屋龄少过60年,也应放宽动用公积金的限制。 屋契剩35年屋价走下坡 不过,有分析师曾警告,公共组屋跨过64岁的门槛(屋契期期限少过35年),屋价可能就逐步走下坡;屋龄到69岁(屋契剩30年),就不能用公积金来支付这种高龄组屋的头期。…

NEA reports an increase of dengue cases over the past three consecutive weeks

The number of dengue cases has increased over the past three consecutive…

Yusof Ishak Mosque is officially opened in Woodlands

Singapore has a new mosque which was named Yusof Ishak Mosque –…