Addressing a specific section of the remarks made by TOC Chief Editor Terry Xu on his Facebook page about POFMA, the Ministry of Health (MOH) alleged that “Terry Xu’s/The Online Citizen’s statement that there was a “Hep C cover up prior to the GE2015” is false.”
The Online Citizen, however, disagrees.
In a Facebook post, MOH highlighted the Independent Review Committee (IRC) report on the Hep C incident in 2015 which found “no evidence of deliberate delays by SGH [Singapore General Hospital] or MOH in escalating the Hepatitis C outbreak, let alone a cover up”.

MOH added, “The timeline of key events was disclosed by MOH. Questions on the incident were raised in Parliament, to which the Minister for Health provided full responses.”
Sharing the MOH post on Facebook, Gov.sg, the official Facebook channel for the Singapore government, echoed the same assertion, saying “This is false” in reference to Terry’s post.

Responding to these claims, TOC on its own Facebook post says it disagrees with MOH’s statement as the ministry took Terry’s comments out of context. TOC even provided an excerpt of the IRC report summary.

First, TOC recounted the details of the Hep C incident in 2015, providing a timeline of events.
On 6 October 2015, SGH revealed that 22 people had been infected by the Hep C virus (HCV) at its renal ward earlier this year and three more were detected in further tests. Of the 25 patients in the HCV cluster, 20 were more susceptible to infections before and after undergoing kidney transplants.
The IRC found that of the deaths of those patients, HCV was likely a contributory factor to the death of seven cases.
TOC said in its post, “It is undeniable that the infections took place from April onwards and that information was withheld from the public on the discovery of such a large number of infections at the SGH renal ward.”
In his own Facebook post, Terry wrote about the use of POFMA: “So effectively, if someone whistleblows during an election or just prior, to something the nature of the Hep C cover up prior to the GE2015, the ruling party can throw a takedown or correction order on the story or statement by the whistleblower, only for the story to be proven correct after the election is won without the voters knowing what actually happened.”
TOC asserted that the context of the cover-up is about the disclosure of the occurrence of the outbreak – not on the management of the outbreak itself.
Using this incident as an example, TOC explained that a whistleblower within the system could have made public the unnaturally large numbers of infections at SGH to the media or public, either in May when the 8th case was detected or in July when the 20th case was detected.
In Terry’s example, given the negative information released, the statement made by this hypothetical whistleblower could have been marked as a falsehood under POFMA, and the information would have been proven correct only after the election.
As such, TOC asserted “it is wrong for MOH to state that Terry’s comment on a possible cover-up to the nature of the Hep C incident is false”.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

【选举】被指破坏“君子协议”攻杨厝港 梁文辉澄清前进党革新党无正式协议

昨日,革新党主席朱来成发文指责,前进党未能遵循与该党秘书长肯尼斯的“君子协议”,执意要攻打杨厝港。 他指出,杨厝港单选区原本就是宏茂桥的一部分,且该党本就应有在该区上阵的权利。 他称,秉持反对党团结精神,革新党让出西海岸集选区,避免三角战,前进党也献议让出包括义顺等议席,且他指后者(前进党)也知道,革新党有意在宏茂桥、杨厝港和拉丁马士上阵。 前进党今日公布有意角逐四个集选区和五个单选区,其中就包括杨厝港。 不过,前进党助理秘书长梁文辉,在今日(26日)的线上记者会上,就澄清该党在杨厝港选区上并未有任何正式协议。 他指出,尽管他都有联系肯尼斯,但实则两党间未有达成任何正式协议。“一开始我就与肯尼斯先生联系,过程中有序都哟富有成果和坦率地讨论,他是位绅士,我们交换了许多想法。” 但梁文辉也指出,任何概念和建议都需要得到党中委的同意,遗憾的是两党间并没有达成任何正式的协议。 梁文辉表示,若当中出现任何误会,也对肯尼斯和革新党表达歉意,希望对方停止攻击陈清木和前进党。

每户免费领四张口罩 网民讥:我一家七口人

政府今日(30日)宣布,自2月1日起,将派发多达520万个口罩,予国内130万户家庭,即指每户人家平均获得四个口罩,而民众可前往民众俱乐部和居委会中心领取口罩。 当局称将优先让老弱人口较多的地区、建国一代居民和租赁租屋居民,领取口罩。 声明一出,立即引起网民热议,许多网民认为,政府要民众出门去取口罩本就将民众陷于易感染区域内,反建议应该用寄送的方式,将口罩放入信箱,让人与人之间的感染可能性降低。 网友Cindi Cscraze: 就连去排队取口罩都觉得很危险,万一带菌者也在队伍内呢?是否应该将口罩送到每户家庭门前,以防止人们接触人潮。 网友 Clara TanSuLin:就算现在不生病,但在接触人潮后都有可能会生病,最好是避免人潮,不然要追踪带菌者也非常困难。所以为何不学学SARS的时候,将口罩送上门,一直呼吁人们避免去人潮区,却要人们去人潮区取口罩,真的很讽刺。 网友Jasmin Lim:为何新邮政不能将口罩放到我们的信箱内,避免我们接触人群,以及让不方便去取口罩的人也可以获得。 网民轰四张口罩并不足够…

Foreign expert in NUHS told Singaporeans not to wear masks if one is well

As early as Jan this year, Dr Dale Fisher who is a…

Alternative parties’ greetings for Singapore’s 55th National Day

In conjunction with Singapore’s 55th birthday yesterday (9 Aug), various alternative parties…