Saturday, 30 September 2023

We are shifting our daily news to Gutzy.Asia Support us there!

Judgment reserved in criminal reference against nursing home worker accused of molestation

What is the legal test to be applied when evaluating the evidence of an eyewitness to any crime? Would the evidence of an eyewitness be generally less reliable compared to that of the victim itself?
These are the legal questions which the Court of Appeal faced on Wednesday (25th September), in the context of a criminal reference filed by the Prosecution, against a nursing home worker who had been cleared by the High Court of molestation.
The 35-year-old man was accused of having committed outrage of modesty on a 56-year-old patient on 26th November 2016. At trial, the Prosecution’s case turned on the evidence by a nurse, who was an eyewitness to the alleged incident. The patient herself was unable to testify and give evidence.
The district judge found the nurse’s evidence to be “unusually convincing” and convicted the man as charged, but High Court Justice Aedit Abdullah acquitted the man on appeal in November last year in an oral judgment.
In his written grounds of decision subsequently released in February this year, he stated that the nurse’s evidence “would not have been sufficient to secure a conviction”, and that there might have been a reasonable doubt that she was mistaken as to what she had seen.
The three-hour debate between Chief Prosecutor Kow Keng Siong for the Prosecution, and Mr Lau Wen Jin for the Defence, centred on how certain paragraphs in Justice Abdullah’s written judgment should be interpreted.
Mr Kow submitted that it was unclear which legal test Justice Abdullah had adopted in assessing the nurse’s evidence, even though the High Court judge agreed that the evidence of an eyewitness must be “unusually convincing” if it was the sole basis for the Prosecution’s case.
Mr Lau, on the other hand, relied on both the oral judgment and the written grounds of decision in refuting Mr Kow’s submission by stating that Justice Abdullah had clearly applied the “unusually convincing” standard in assessing the nurse’s evidence.
In relation to another paragraph where Justice Abdullah had stated that “an eyewitness’s account would be subject[ed] to a greater degree of misperception, misapprehension and misattribution” as compared to the account of a victim, Mr Kow took the position that the judge had expounded his general opinion on while Mr Lau maintained that it was just a general starting point of the analysis.
Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon was troubled by this proposition as it was not supported by scientific facts, while Judge of Appeal Andrew Phang questioned whether such a proposition was correct in law even as merely a starting point.
Mr Lau also made the point that the questions of law referred by the Prosecution, though of public interest, did not affect the outcome of the case as the High Court’s decision on appeal was based on its assessment of the totality of the evidence adduced.
Finally, in the event that the apex court decided to review the facts of the case, Mr Lau forcefully submitted that the nurse’s evidence was inconsistent and not reliable.
The Court of Appeal – which also included Judge of Appeal Judith Prakash – has reserved judgment.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Latest posts

Election surprises and certainties: Dissecting Tharman’s presidential win

In the 2023 Presidential Election, Mr. Tharman Shanmugaratnam secured a stunning 70.4% landslide victory, surprising many, including himself. Despite expectations that TKL would win the opposition votes, voters from both camps showed a preference for Tharman's charisma and perceived competency. As Singapore reflects on the outcome, questions arise about the election's fairness and the real implications of Tharman's dominant win.

Volunteer as a Polling and Counting Agent for Singapore’s 2023 Presidential Election

For the upcoming Singapore Presidential Election on 1st September, members of the civil society have spearheaded an initiative to strengthen our democratic fabric. We invite committed individuals to join us as Polling and Counting Agents, standing together for a transparent, fair, and just election. This vote counting exercise, organized by members of civil society, is not specifically in support of Mr Tan Kin Lian, a candidate in the upcoming Presidential Election. It's an exercise in active citizenry. Nonetheless, Mr Tan endorses this initiative, which hinges on his candidacy, championing transparency, and has given permission for the results to be shared publicly.

Reflections from the Centenary: The Legacy of LKY and Singapore’s Future

Gilbert Goh reflects on the LKY centenary event: an inspiring showcase of a leader's global legacy juxtaposed against current challenges, urging Singapore to continue its path of progress.

Lim Tean advocates for Tan Kin Lian: A visionary leader for Singapore’s Presidency

In his speech at Mr Tan Kin Lian's launch of his presidential bid, Mr Lim Tean passionately championed the need for a truly Independent President. Highlighting Mr Tan Kin Lian's unique credentials and genuine concern for the wellbeing of Singaporeans, the Peoples Voice leader emphasized the pressing challenges of rising living costs and job insecurities faced by the public. Mr Lim depicted Mr Tan Kin Lian as a beacon of hope for the nation, advocating for a leader who genuinely understands and represents the people’s aspirations.

Tan Jee Say endorses Tan Kin Lian for President: A courageous, genuine, and humble...

In advocating for a truly representative leader, Tan Jee Say underscored Tan Kin Lian's humility, courage, and genuine dedication. Highlighting the pressing need for restored public trust and effective independence, Tan Jee Say emphasized that Tan Kin Lian, as the 'People's President', would bring back hope to Singaporeans and champion true democracy

Tan Kin Lian’s pledge: Rekindling unity and charting a vigorous future for Singapore

In the press conference to announce his bid for the Singapore presidency, Tan Kin Lian emphasizes safeguarding Singapore's reserves and strengthening public service integrity. Drawing on his 30-year leadership at NTUC Income, he envisions a future with affordable living, accessible housing, and job stability, pledging collaboration with the government for a united nation.

Strengthening Singapore’s political foundations: A call to action by Leong Mun Wai on Singapore’s...

Leong Mun Wai urges Singaporeans to strengthen political checks and balances, emphasizing, 'The best is yet to be for Singapore if we dare to make the right decision in upcoming elections.

Trending posts